(There are those who snatch the fatherless child from the breast, and they take a pledge against the poor.)
Job's friends insist that suffering always follows sin. He answers by pointing at the world as it is, where cruel men prosper, tear a nursing child from its mother, and squeeze security for a debt out of the poor.
The question driving the chapter
Verse 9 belongs to a list Job builds to press one complaint: God sees everything and does not act.
Leslie M. GrantJob wonders why God (who is Almighty) does not take account of all that happens in time. He wonders why those who know Him see no serious dealing on His part with gross evil when it is present. For, he says, "Some remove landmarks," thereby stealing land from others; they steal flocks of sheep by force and feed on them; "they drive away the donkey of the fatherless; they take the widow's ox as a pledge."
What a pledge was
A pledge is an item handed over as security for a loan. It was a normal part of life long before Job's day:
Morrish Bible DictionaryPeople took articles as security for loans, and made similar deals, from very early times. The law then set restrictions on this, so that no one could take unfair advantage through it. Exodus 22:26; Deuteronomy 24:10-17; Job 22:6; Job 24:3, 9; Amos 2:8.
One restriction shows where the line fell:
Numerical Bible NotesA creditor might take a pledge from his poor neighbour, but not the hand-mill which ground his corn from day to day: that would be taking a man's life as a pledge. The law punished with death the greed that went so far as to steal a man.
A picture of systematic cruelty
Verse 9 sits inside a portrait of rich men who use the poor and keep them poor. The wording below follows an older translation:
William Kelly"They cause the naked to lodge without clothing" — that is what these wicked rich do. They have no pity for them; they make use of them for their work… "They pluck the fatherless from the breast, and take a pledge of the poor. They cause him to go naked without clothing, and they take away the sheaf from the hungry." There might be a sheaf or two forgotten at harvest, but they have found it out, and they are after them to get the sheaf back. "Which make oil within their walls." The owners employ them to pile up their own abundance — they make the oil, but never have a drop of it for themselves.
Job's answer to his accusers
Job is not just reporting misery. He uses these open crimes as evidence against the theory of his friends. Eliphaz is one of them:
Samuel RidoutJob takes other cases to illustrate the same heartlessness. The wicked tear the fatherless from the breast; they defraud the poor. Why do his friends hint that he was guilty of such conduct, when glaring cases were obvious to them?… How can Eliphaz make such facts fit his theory that evil is always punished in this life? But how can God close His eyes to these things, and afflict a faithful man instead of these wrongdoers? This is Job's great trouble, and for this he has found no solution.
Why the silence is not indifference
Job cannot explain the delay. One commentator closes the same passage with the reason:
William KellyGod does not take any notice of it, and the reason is that He is waiting for that day.
The two groups named in verse 9 are the two God has always claimed as His own charge:
Edward DennettOf all the helpless ones who appeal to our compassion, surely the widow and the fatherless have the first claim. Here God surrounds them with the powerful defence of His own arm… All through Scripture these two groups stand out as the special object of God's care. So they should be objects of our compassionate concern. James accordingly says, "Religion that is pure and undefiled before God the Father is this: to visit orphans and widows in their affliction, and to keep oneself unstained from the world."
The poor and the gospel
Job saw the poor trampled and knew no remedy. One commentator notes what later came into the world for these very people:
William KellyWhat a wonderful love it is to the very people to whom the gospel is preached. It was to the "poor" that the gospel was preached; they were especially the object of the Lord Jesus. There never was such a thing before, since the world began. Nobody ever made them his great object, and that for eternity. But Job could know nothing of that.
Summary
- Charge — Job lists crimes everyone could see: infants seized, the poor squeezed for security. They prove his friends wrong. Suffering is not proof of guilt.
- Pledge — the law allowed security for a loan, but never the tool a man lived by. Take that, and you take his life.
- Pattern — the oppressors use the poor for their work, leave them unclothed, and chase down a forgotten sheaf. The poor press the oil and never taste a drop.
- Patience — God seems to take no notice, and Job has no answer. The delay is God waiting for that day.
- Claim — Scripture marks out the fatherless and the widow as God's special care, so they must be ours. The Lord Jesus made the poor His great object, and the gospel went to them.