How can I know the Bible is true?

Answered from the commentary of J. N. Darby, C. H. Mackintosh, Frederick W. Grant and 13 others

The Bible is known to be true chiefly by its own testimony. It carries its own credentials, and when the Holy Spirit brings it home to heart and conscience, its divine character is known, just as the woman of Samaria perceived that the Lord was a prophet. A book that tells a man all that is in his heart, judges him thoroughly, and at the same time reveals One who meets his every need proves itself to be the word of God, as light needs no proof to one who has eyes. For this reason reasoning cannot give faith. If Scripture has to be proved by reason or accredited by the church, God is not believed because He has spoken, and a faith that rests on such human motives is merely of nature. "He that believeth on the Son of God hath the witness in himself" (1 John 5:10), and the Spirit confirms in the heart what the Scriptures set forth, not the other way round. The Lord Himself gives the way in: "If any man will do His will, he shall know of the doctrine, whether it be of God" (John 7:17). A single eye and a real desire to do God's will discern the truth, while the working of our own wills blinds us to it.

Alongside this inward witness there is abundant outward evidence, and most of these authors set it out at length. The first is the unity of the Bible: sixty-six books, written by some forty writers over about fifteen hundred years, many of them unknown to each other, show one controlling mind, the Holy Spirit. The second is fulfilled prophecy, since only God can foretell the future. The sufferings of Christ, Daniel's four world empires and the scattering of the Jews were all fulfilled to the letter, which marks the Bible as inspired. The third is the resurrection of Christ, attested by many witnesses, among them five hundred at once, most of whom were still alive to be questioned; for unbelievers it is the pivot on which the evidence turns. Ancient monuments and the spade of the excavator confirm the record again and again, and the Book's power to transform lives is a further witness.

Yet the authors differ in how much weight they give these proofs. Pollock credits fulfilled prophecy with convincing him of inspiration and keeping him from infidelity. Darby, Dennett, Kelly and Mackintosh hold that such evidence exposes the folly of doubt and leaves unbelief without excuse, but cannot produce faith. In their view, if the word of God is not its own witness, no amount of human evidence will establish it in the soul. A man may be intellectually convinced by the facts and never have felt the Bible's saving power.

Where difficulties remain, a difficulty one cannot solve shows one's own incompetence, not the falseness of what has been positively proved. Apparent contradictions lie most often in our own understanding, and they diminish as light increases.

Verses: 1 John 5:10, 2 Timothy 3:16, 2 Timothy 3:17, 2 Peter 1:16, 2 Peter 1:19, 2 Peter 1:20, 2 Peter 1:21, John 17:17, Psalms 119:160, Proverbs 30:5, Numbers 23:19, Titus 1:2, Hebrews 6:18, John 20:30, John 20:31, Luke 1:1, Luke 1:2, Luke 1:3, Luke 1:4, 1 John 1:1, 1 John 1:2, 1 John 1:3, 1 Corinthians 15:3, 1 Corinthians 15:4, 1 Corinthians 15:5, 1 Corinthians 15:6, 1 Corinthians 15:7, 1 Corinthians 15:8, Acts 1:3, Isaiah 46:9, Isaiah 46:10, Isaiah 41:21, Isaiah 41:22, Isaiah 41:23, Deuteronomy 18:21, Deuteronomy 18:22, Luke 24:25, Luke 24:26, Luke 24:27, Luke 24:44, John 5:39, John 5:46, John 7:17, John 10:35, Matthew 5:18, Matthew 24:35, Isaiah 40:8, 1 Peter 1:24, 1 Peter 1:25, Psalms 12:6, Psalms 19:7, Psalms 19:8, Psalms 19:9, Psalms 33:4, Hebrews 4:12, 1 Thessalonians 2:13, 1 Corinthians 2:12, 1 Corinthians 2:13, 1 Corinthians 2:14, John 16:13, Romans 10:17, Acts 17:11, Romans 15:4, John 14:26, Psalms 119:89

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

A. J. PollockIs the Bible Inspired of God

We rise from our task. This brief survey of Scripture has only served to deepen in the writer’s mind the truth of the inspiration of the Scriptures, and how they should be treated with the utmost reverence, realising that God Himself is speaking to us in them. We have brought forward very little, but that little overwhelmingly proves that the Scriptures are all that they themselves claim to be. The claim has been amply substantiated by the contents of the Book, the character of its writers; the fulfilment of prophecy; the correspondence between the shadows of the ceremonial law and their fulfilment in Christ and His atoning death on the cross; the supreme Person of our Lord, as delineated in the four gospels, the presentation of a life unique in every way, and in character and degree infinitely beyond every other life, however exalted, and finally its living power in moulding human lives for God. By its fruits we know the Book to be supremely good.

Other AuthorsH. P. Barker

The marvellous and detailed fulfilment of its prophecies; the perfect harmony between its various parts, indited as they were under varying circumstances and at different epochs; the utter failure of its critics to substantiate their charges of imperfection; the impossibility of the human mind, trained and cultured though it be, to fathom and exhaust its teachings—all these, and many other facts, testify to the divine authorship of the Bible.

C. H. MackintoshThe Great Commission

God alone can give the knowledge that the Holy Scriptures are His own very revelation to man. If He does not give it, no one can; if He does, no one need. If I want human evidence to accredit the Word of God, it is not the Word of God to me. The authority on which I receive it is higher than the Word itself. Supposing I could by reason or human learning work my way to the rational conclusion that the Bible is the Word of God, then my faith would merely stand in the wisdom of man, and not in the power of God. Such a faith is worthless; it does not link me with God, and therefore leaves me unsaved, unblessed, uncertain. It leaves me without God, without Christ, without hope. Saving faith is believing what God says because He says it, and this faith is wrought in the soul by the Holy Spirit. Intellectual faith is a cold, lifeless, worthless faith, which only deceives and puffs up; it never can save, sanctify, or satisfy.

A. J. PollockThe Fundamentals of the Christian Faith

One of the most striking proofs of the inspiration of the Bible is the way its prophecies have been fulfilled. No mind, however far-seeing, can penetrate the future centuries, and say what they will unfold. The only book in the world that sets out to prophesy, and whose prophecies have been fulfilled to the letter, is the Bible, and this clearly proves that it was not written merely and only by men like ourselves, but that there was a Divine Mind that inspired it all.

The Bible TreasuryDivine Inspiration of the Scriptures

One of the most striking proofs of inspiration is the fact that the Bible is a collection of books by different authors, written at different times, the first and last books differing by a period of many hundreds of years. And yet there is a perfect unity of design running right through the whole Bible, the separate parts being perfectly linked up with each other, so that it is evidently the work of one mind producing the harmonious whole — even the work of the Spirit of God. The various authors lived and died, and yet the true Author remains from the first book to the last, all being fitted in according to His mind. I hope to show later, more in detail, how the various parts fit in one with the other, each filling its place so naturally that, until removed, one is not aware how important it is. The existence of a Master Mind guiding the hand of the various writers must be admitted by all serious students of Scripture.

J. N. DarbyHave we a revelation from God?

The proof of Scripture in this respect is in Scripture, in the power of the word wielded by the Holy Ghost. When in that power it reaches the heart and conscience, its character, its divine character, is known, not only in the particular point in which it reaches them, but as to the true power and character of that which has done so. The woman of Samaria does not say when thus reached, "What you say is true," but, "Sir, I perceive that thou art a prophet." What He said came from God. His character and word were known to her. So it is with the Bible when a man is taught of God. It is recognised as His word, as Christ was recognised by those whose eyes were opened to see what was divine. Human testimony may prove the folly of human doubt, but no more, and so be useful; but divine operation alone gives divine faith. "He has opened mine eyes." When men believed only through proofs to man, by miracles, Jesus did not commit Himself to them; He knew what was in man. It was man's judgment about Him, very justly formed, but only man's judgment, no revelation of the Son of God to the soul: this is by the word through the operation of God; and then a man is born of God and sees. But I must pursue my inquiry.

The Bible TreasuryThe Positive Evidences of Christianity

1870 156 I cannot here, of course, write a book on the positive evidences of Christianity. But no one is ignorant that there are such, and that the positive proofs of it — proofs such as no event, no system, no person on earth has for itself — have been detailed in the language of every civilized people. Now particular objections leave this all out of sight; yet, where anything has been largely, positively proved, the dwelling on the objections that may be saved, without estimating the positive proofs of the whole system, is a totally unsound mental process. It is a way of judging of the truth of anything which would be admitted in no other case whatever. I do not object to the examination of every difficulty in detail. In the case of scripture, the positive proof is that of the divinity of the system as a whole. If the system at large is positively proved, a difficulty attached to it which I cannot solve is a demonstration not of the falseness of the system, but of my incompetency to deal with the difficulty. In such a case a sound-minded man is content to say, "I do not know." The historical facts and documents of Christianity are proved with an evidence such as no other universally-believed event or acknowledged book has any evidence to be compared with, and if proved show that it is divine. It has met with an opposition which made every document and fact to be scrutinized with a closeness which left only what was incontestable uncontested. This was to be expected, because it presented the claims of a holy God, to which the antagonist will of man never would submit. Hostile heathens, philosophical adversaries, heretical corrupters, foolish advocates, elaborate historians, voluminous commentators, every kind of author and character has been occupied with it from the time of its promulgation, and authenticated its history and its doctrines even when opposing them; and this in the presence of the hostility of religions divinely established or nationally and deeply enracinated on the one side, and sceptical scorn on the other. On the books on which the smallest doubt could be cast, doubts were cast; and their authenticity made a subject of question as they are by objectors now.

The internal difficulties by which the sceptic seeks to invalidate the inspiration of the New Testament, or at any rate the greater part of them, were noticed already in the second century, and answered. The Jews were as desirous to prove Jesus was not the Messiah, as the sceptic could be now. In a word we are on ground travelled over for eighteen centuries — old infidelity dressed up in a new form, to be met by increasing light and increasing proofs which God in His goodness affords both internal and external.

C. KnappWe believe and are sure

There are evidences, on every hand, many and varied and of the very best; evidences both direct and indirect. The world is full of them, and they may be seen every day; museums of antiquity contain them; evidences of the Bible's veracity are writ large on Egyptian and Assyrian monuments and temples; the ruins of buried cities and the tombs of forgotten kings abound with them, even mummies bearing mute testimony to what the "scripture of truth" declares; and the spade of the excavator brings to light fresh witnesses every year. The natural sciences, astronomy, geology, physiology, anatomy, including even that most exact of all sciences, mathematics, all bear united and harmonious witness to the truth of Scripture, written with "the finger of God."

C. H. MackintoshNumbers 1 - 8, Section 1 of 3

But is it that we despise external evidences? Far from it. We delight in them. We value every argument and every evidence calculated to strengthen the foundations of the heart's confidence in the divine inspiration of holy scripture; and, most assuredly, we have abundance of such material. The very history of the book itself, with all its striking facts, furnishes a broad tributary stream to swell the tide of evidence. The history of its composition; the history of its preservation; the history of its translation from tongue to tongue; the history of its circulation throughout earth's wide domain — in a word, its entire history, "surpassing fable, and yet true," forms a powerful argument in defence of its divine origin. Take, for example, that one fact of most commanding interest, namely, its having been kept for over a thousand years, in the custody of those who would have gladly consigned it, if they could, to eternal oblivion. Is not this a telling fact? Yes; and there are many such facts in the marvellous history of this peerless, priceless Volume.

Michael HardtThe Inspiration of the Bible

The Bible puts man into the light of God. This is why the natural man hates this book - and has tried to find contradictions everywhere. However, 90% of these are due to either ignorance or bad intentions, or both. Then there are real difficulties, such as differences between Gospel reports. Here it is a matter of asking God to help us understand the Divine design of the scriptures. If we do, the difficulties disappear and the beauty of inspiration is seen. In some extremely rare cases an error may have occurred: in 2 Ki. 8:26 an age of 22 years is given, while in 2 Chr. 22:2 the age given is 42 years - possibly the result of a copying error. But our faith does not depend on this detail.

Verses

  • 1 John 5:10He that believes on the Son of God has the witness in himself; he that does not believe God has made him a liar, because he has not believed in the witness which God has witnessed concerning his Son.
  • 2 Timothy 3:16–1716Every scripture [is] divinely inspired, and profitable for teaching, for conviction, for correction, for instruction in righteousness; 17that the man of God may be complete, fully fitted to every good work.
  • 2 Peter 1:16For we have not made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, following cleverly imagined fables, but having been eyewitnesses of his majesty.
  • 2 Peter 1:19–2119And we have the prophetic word [made] surer, to which ye do well taking heed (as to a lamp shining in an obscure place) until [the] day dawn and [the] morning star arise in your hearts; 20knowing this first, that [the scope of] no prophecy of scripture is had from its own particular interpretation, 21for prophecy was not ever uttered by [the] will of man, but holy men of God spake under the power of [the] Holy Spirit.
  • John 17:17Sanctify them by the truth thy word is truth.