And we have the prophetic word [made] surer, to which ye do well taking heed (as to a lamp shining in an obscure place) until [the] day dawn and [the] morning star arise in your hearts;
Peter has just described the mountain where he saw the Lord's majesty and heard the Father's voice. Now he sets two lights side by side — a lamp in a dark place, and the dawn with its star — and the question is why one gives way to the other.
The older translation read "a more sure word of prophecy." The ESV reads "more fully confirmed," and Gaebelein explains why that difference matters.
Arno Clemens Gaebelein"We have also a more sure word of prophecy" should be rendered, "We have the word of prophecy made more sure." The word of prophecy is, of course, in the Old Testament. But is it not sure enough already? Why make it more sure? It should be understood as attesting, or confirming, the word of prophecy. The transfiguration confirmed the prophecies in the Old Testament.
It confirmed prophecy because everything the prophets promised stood there together, in living people.
William KellyOn the holy mount God let chosen witnesses see, as a living scene, the central point to which all prophecy tends — the coming and kingdom of our Lord Jesus. Moses represented the dead saints, raised. Elijah represented the saints taken to heaven without dying. And there was the Lord Jesus, the head and centre of all blessedness and glory. Besides, there were saints in natural unchanged bodies: Peter, James and John. The whole group was like a seal, confirming what the prophets had given the people of God to expect.
The word behind "dark place" is stronger than dimness.
F. B. HoleThe word translated "dark" in the original means "squalid" or "filthy." This world, with all its clever inventions and elegant splendour, is only a squalid place in God's sight. Every Christian taught by Him sees it the same way. The only real light in the squalor comes from the lamp of prophecy. Men dream up an empty "millennium" they will produce out of the present filth. The lamp of prophecy brings us into the light of God's purpose and His coming work of both judgment and salvation. It lets us see the squalor of the world that is, and the glory of the world to come.
Prophecy is not just information. It shows where the world is heading, and that changes what you hold on to.
J. N. DarbyThe power of prophecy is that it lays bare what is going on in the course of this world, and takes it into judgment. If I know that judgment is coming, and that the weeds are to be burned, I shall not have anything to do with the weeds.
The verse does not say "until the day of the Lord arrives." It points somewhere else.
William KellyHere prophecy is compared to the lamp shining in a squalid place, and the heavenly hope to daylight — above all to the person of Christ as the day-star. Notice it is not "till the day come," or "till the arrival of the day of the Lord." It is "till the day dawn and the day-star arise in your hearts." It is the heart getting hold of the heavenly hope. It is the heart now having Christ as its constant hope, and so in the spirit and light of the day before it shines on the earth by and by.
The lamp shows the world's evil and where it is heading. The dawn and the star bring something else into view.
William KellyThe lamp is excellent for casting enough light on this dark world, its evil and its doom. They did well to pay attention to it, "till day dawn and a morning star arise in your hearts." That is, until they enjoy the bright heavenly relationship which Christianity, fully understood, gives us now in Christ. And until they hold the heavenly hope of His coming to bring us into the Father's house.
Commentators differ on the last phrase. Some tie "in your hearts" to taking heed, not to the rising of the star.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThere is a difficulty connected with this verse. One suggested rendering removes it: "We have also the prophetic Word confirmed, to which you do well in taking heed (as to a lamp that shines in an obscure place, until the day dawn and the morning star arises) in your hearts." It does not mean that the morning star is to arise in the heart of the believer. It means that we should take heed to prophecy in our hearts. And how the entire prophetic Word, that blessed lamp, is needed in these darkening days!
- Confirmed — the transfiguration did not replace prophecy. It sealed it, showing in living people what the prophets promised.
- Lamp — prophecy is light for a place God calls squalid, showing both what this world really is and what is coming.
- Heed — if the weeds are to be burned, loosen your grip on them now.
- Dawn — the verse moves the sunrise indoors: not the day breaking over the earth, but light breaking in the heart.
- Star — the better light is a Person — Christ as the constant hope. Commentators differ on whether "in your hearts" goes with the star's rising or with the heeding.
knowing this first, that [the scope of] no prophecy of scripture is had from its own particular interpretation,
Peter says there is one thing his readers must grasp "first of all" about the prophetic word. Does his sentence forbid ordinary people to interpret the Bible for themselves, or does it say something else about how prophecy holds together?
Much of the difficulty comes from one disputed word. Commentators say its plainest sense is not "private" but "its own":
William Kelly"Its own" is the simplest, strictest and most common use of the disputed word, and it is the only sense that fits the context. It is hard to see why the King James Version and the Revised Version chose "private," except that they did not know what to make of it.
Read that way, the verse is not about who may interpret. It is about how a prophecy must be read:
J. N. DarbyNo prophecy of Scripture is its own interpreter: you cannot interpret it by taking it on its own. That is the plain translation.
Older translations say "private." Some have used that word to keep the Bible out of ordinary hands. Commentators answer plainly:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinRome has used the word "private" to hold up its terrible lie that no private individual should ever interpret Scripture. As a result Rome discourages the reading of God's Word in every way... Only the prophetic Word is in view here... In interpreting prophecy, prophetic Scripture must be compared with prophetic Scripture. Prophecy must be taken as a whole.
That reply sets two limits. Peter has prophecy in view, not the whole Bible. And the liberty at stake is the soul's freedom to hear God for itself:
Numerical Bible NotesTaking single texts away from their context has often been disastrous for interpretation, as we all know. But it has nothing at all to do with the so-called "right of private judgment," which is better called the liberty of the soul to hear for itself what the Spirit makes known to everyone.
The positive teaching is that prophecy is one connected body, because one mind produced it. Verse 21 supplies the reason for verse 20:
F. B. HoleIt is instead a warning against treating each prophetic saying as if it stood alone — a self-contained statement to be interpreted apart from the whole body of prophetic teaching. All prophecy is connected and related, and can only be understood in connection with the whole. It was never spoken by the will of man, but by the inspiration of the Spirit of God. He used different men in different ages, but His one mind runs through it all.
If prophecy is one whole, it must have one destination. Commentators name it as the kingdom and glory of Christ:
J. N. DarbyThey were all parts of one whole, with one and the same object: the kingdom of God. Each event was a step towards that object, a link in the chain of God's government that led to it. No link can be explained unless you grasp the aim of the whole — the revealed aim of God's counsels in the glory of His Christ.
A prophecy still speaks into a local event. But that event is never the whole story:
William KellyLocal circumstances of the moment give the occasion for a prophecy, but it forms part of a great whole, and Christ the King is the centre of that whole. Taking it on its own is like cutting a branch off a magnificent tree that it belongs to.
Peter's phrase is careful. Not every predictive word in the Bible falls under it — a point that keeps the rule from being stretched too far:
William KellyHe does not deny that many a prophecy had its scope only in one particular, passing event important enough to call for it... Take the dreams of Pharaoh in Genesis, and of his two officials before that. Take the prophecies of Agabus in the book of Acts about the famine and about the apostle Paul. Many such prophecies are recorded in the Old Testament. Yet none of them is a prophecy of Scripture in the sense meant here.
Reading a prophecy on its own is not just a mistake in method. It changes what the heart waits for:
W. T. P. WolstonThose who look for prophecy to be fulfilled before the Lord comes for us miss the joy of waiting for Christ. They see a close likeness between a prophecy and some passing event, but they do not know what it is to watch for the bright and morning star.
- One Author. Prophecy never came by the will of man. One Spirit spoke through many writers in many ages, and one mind runs through it all.
- One Body. Because the Author is one, no prophecy is self-contained; each is a link, and a link cut from the chain cannot be read.
- One Centre. It all points to the kingdom and glory of Christ. That is why one local fulfilment never uses up a prophecy.
- One Misreading. "Private" never banned ordinary readers from the Bible. Commentators call that a misuse of the word: Peter is talking about how prophecy is read, not about who may read it.
- One Result. Tie prophecy to passing events and you lose the waiting heart. Read it as one whole and you watch for Christ Himself.
for prophecy was not ever uttered by [the] will of man, but holy men of God spake under the power of [the] Holy Spirit.
Peter has just called the prophetic word a lamp shining in a dark place. Now he says where that word came from: not from a human being, but from God through men the Spirit carried along.
The first half of the verse rules out one source. Prophecy is not a talent a gifted person can develop.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe will of man could never produce prophecy. Only God knows the future, and He has spoken about the future.
One writer weighs the scope of what prophecy covers against what man's will could ever reach:
William KellyMan's will resists all this. Even if it were ever so eager to help, who is able except God to take in a range so vast, deep, and high? So the only possible power is that of the Holy Spirit. In His great love for man's blessing, God chose to tell us beforehand of those coming glories of Christ, just as through holy men He also predicted His sufferings.
Peter's phrase "carried along" points past the writers to Someone else.
F. B. HoleNotice how verse 21 speaks of inspiration. "Holy men of God" spoke and wrote "moved by" or "borne along by" the Holy Spirit. They put their pens to paper under His power, so He is the real Author of what they wrote.
Peter's phrase "men spoke from God" also tells us who these writers were. (Older translations read "holy men of God.")
Arend RemmersThose who wrote the books of the Bible were holy men of God, acknowledged by Him as His instruments. Moses was such a man of God (Psalm 90:1), as was Elijah, who could say, "the LORD... before whom I stand" (1 Kings 17:1). They stood before God, conscious that He was constantly looking on them.
Another writer notes how far their words ran past their own understanding:
Leslie M. GrantBy the Holy Spirit He moved them to speak far above the measure of their understanding. They took no place of authority, but in the lowliness of faith searched their own writings, wanting to find God's interpretation of them (1 Peter 1:10-12).
The Spirit did not turn these men into machines. Their personalities still show on the page.
Samuel RidoutHe brings down the exalted one and lifts up the lowly one, putting them on one common level. He uses them as He finds them, making them the channels of His thoughts and not their own. Yet here is the remarkable fact: He never does violence to their individual character. Peter remains Peter and Moses remains Moses. Their abilities show in their writings. Their style is there. Everything there speaks of the man, yet nothing there fails to speak of God.
Peter writes here about men who spoke. One writer adds that inspiration does not stop with the speakers.
William KellyIt is a distortion of the truth to say that the writers were inspired, but not the writings. If 2 Peter 1:21 supports the first, the claim for the second is even more explicit and directly to the point in 2 Timothy 3:16... Not only were the men inspired, but so, according to the apostle Paul, is the result.
The same conclusion is reached from the other direction: if what was said was inspired, writing it down loses nothing.
A J PollockIn 2 Peter 1:21 we get the claim in definite terms... for surely if the spoken prophecies were inspired, their being written down would not be less authoritative.
Verse 21 gives the reason for verse 20. Man had no hand in where prophecy came from, and one writer draws the consequence:
Leslie M. GrantIf man had no part in originating prophecy, then certainly mere man is not the interpreter of it.
Because one Spirit carried every prophet, no prophecy stands on its own.
Frederick W GrantNo single prophecy must be read alone, as if it stood apart from the rest. Read each one in connection with the whole plan of it in the Word. "For no prophecy was ever produced by the will of man" — so it is not the expression of the many minds of men. "But men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit" — there is One perfect mind throughout it.
- Source — Prophecy did not rise out of human will. Only God knows the future, so only God could give it.
- Carried — "Carried along" means borne by another. The Spirit's power, not the writer's skill, produced the words, so He is the real Author.
- Vessels — The men were holy men of God, owned by Him as His instruments. They spoke far beyond what they understood.
- Preserved — The Spirit never crushed the man. Peter stays Peter and Moses stays Moses, yet every line still speaks of God.
- Result — One mind runs through the whole Bible. So read each prophecy with the rest, and take Scripture as God's authority, not man's.