Do angels have souls?

Answered from the commentary of Frederick William Grant, A. J. Pollock, John Ritchie and 9 others

No. Angels are spirits, never souls, and this is what Hebrews 1:7 and Hebrews 1:14 call them: "ministering spirits". Scripture calls God "the Father of spirits" (Hebrews 12:9), never of souls, and calls demons "unclean spirits," never souls. Angels are therefore spirits only, while animals are soul and body and man alone is "spirit, and soul, and body" (1 Thessalonians 5:23). The angels are purely spirit beings, while man is a composite being, partly spirit and partly matter. They are pure spirit, living in the heavens and not burdened with the body of clay that links man to the earth.

The reason lies in what the soul is. In man the soul is the link between the spirit and the body, and it is the life of the body. It is the seat of the affections, appetites and desires, which man shares with the creatures below him. Being "a living soul" (Genesis 2:7) therefore joins man to the lower creatures, and it is the very thing that marks him off from pure spirits such as angels. Among spiritual beings, being a living soul is man's real distinction, and this reminds him that he is akin to the beasts. The same point explains why man was made "a little lower than the angels": he is a soul, and they are not. Lacking a soul does not make angels perishable, however, for the angels are not subject to death. All rational beings, angels and men alike, have a spirit that cannot perish.

Verses: Hebrews 12:9, Hebrews 1:14, Psalms 104:4, Hebrews 1:7, Luke 20:36, Matthew 22:30, Luke 24:39, Ephesians 6:12, Jude 1:6, 2 Peter 2:4, Matthew 25:41, Luke 15:10, Luke 2:13, Luke 2:14, Revelation 5:11, Revelation 5:12, 1 Peter 1:12, Psalms 148:2, Psalms 148:5, Colossians 1:16, Hebrews 2:16, Hebrews 2:7, Psalms 8:5, Hebrews 12:22, Genesis 2:7, 1 Thessalonians 5:23, Revelation 12:7, Revelation 12:8, Revelation 12:9, Isaiah 6:2, Isaiah 6:3, Job 38:7, 2 Samuel 14:20, Revelation 22:8, Revelation 22:9, Matthew 8:29, James 2:19

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

Frederick William GrantFacts and Theories as to a Future State

Still, why is man called a living soul, a title which is his in common with all the animate creation, rather than a "living spirit," which would distinguish him from them? The answer would seem to be that the point of contrast is not with the lower animals, but with the class of God's creatures to which as a moral being man belongs. The angels are spirits, never souls. The distinction between them and man, "made a little lower than the angels," is thus that man is a soul. That which links him with the inferior creatures, is that which distinguishes him from pure "spirits," such as angels are.*

A. J. PollockPractical Papers

Scripture speaks of God as “The Father of spirits” (Heb. 12:9), never of souls. Angels are called “spirits”—“Are they not all ministering spirits. … .” (Heb. 1:14)—never souls, and demons are constantly spoken of as “unclean spirits” (Mark 3:11)—never souls.

John RitchieMan: A Triune Being

Derived, as Genesis 2:7, informs us, from the inbreathing of the Creator, which raises him far above the beasts, which are said to have “soul” (Gen. 1:30, margin), man is the offspring of God (Acts 17:28), formed to have dominion, in the image and glory of God (1 Cor. 11:7), even though now fallen from his first estate. Man is linked with the inferior creatures by being, as they are, “a living soul,” and distinguished from angels, who are only “spirits” (Heb. 1:7, 14), but not “souls.” While man is alive in the body, he is a “soul” (see Ezek. 18:20 ; Lev. 5:2, 4; 7:20 , where the person—the individual—is clearly meant); when out of the body, he is then called a “spirit” (Heb. 12:23 ). It is the intermediate link between spirit and body, and the life of the latter. To it are ascribed the functions of loving (1 Sam.18:1), hating (2 Sam. 5:8), desiring (Job 23:13 ), longing (Ps. 84:2). Affections, appetites, desires belong to the soul. The soul is said to be the seat or spring of sin—“the sin of the soul” (Mic. 6:7)—for it atonement is said to be made (Lev. 17:11), and as it is by the soul needed, so by it is it made, as we read, “When Thou shalt make His soul an offering for sin, He shall see His seed. He shall see of the travail of His soul, and shall be satisfied” (Isa. 53:10-11).

W. W. FeredayQuestions of the Hour

Man differs from other created beings in that he is made up of "spirit, and soul, and body" (1 Thess. 5:23). Angels are spirits only (Heb. 1:7); animals, etc., consist of soul and body (Gen. 1:20, see margin). The spirit is the seat of the will and of the intelligence — the mental and moral faculties (1 Cor. 2:11); the soul is the seat of the affections and desires (1 Sam. 18:1; Luke 2:35); the body is the vessel by means of which these express themselves. The word "mortal" is only applied in Scripture to the body; never to either soul or spirit. It is sometimes objected that the term "immortal soul" is not found in Scripture. This is admitted; but what is the force of the objection if that which the orthodox mean by the expression is found there? Moreover, it should be remembered that "immortal" is a negative term; and could only properly be applied to that in man which at some time was "mortal." Since the soul never was mortal; there was no need for the Spirit of God to specifically describe it as immortal.

W. W. FeredayEternal Punishment

We have two things here: First, the formation of the body; then the impartation of life by the inbreathing of God. Man has, in consequence of this, a character of life within him that is not possessed by the lower creatures of God's hand. He holds a very special place in God's universe. Angels are spirits; beasts, etc., have soul and body; man is distinguished from them all by the possession of spirit, and soul, and body (Ps. 104:4; Gen. 1:20-21, 24; 1 Thess. 5:23).

James McBroomCreation and New Creation

We must mark the difference between the physical creation and the moral order of life placed therein. The first gives the sphere in which God's eternal counsels are worked out and the latter those whom those counsels concern. The higher intelligences — angels — are purely spirit beings, but man is complex in his being, partaking of both spirit and matter. Immortal in his spirit and mortal as to his body, he joins in himself both the moral and the physical parts of creation. Man is unique in the creation of God. As a spirit being he is the lowest in the scale of the moral order, the higher intelligences being much greater in power and glory. As to his physical being he is above the whole range of the animal creation.

The Bible TreasurySonship, and Eternal Life

"In Him was life." He is the Author of all life, from the highest to the lowest, and in all its forms and phases; but this is no assertion either of the identity of life in all cases, or of the Pantheistic denial of a distinct personality, separate from the Deity, though not independent of Him. The mere brute has an animal soul, — a soul the existence of which depends upon the blood of the animal, and upon the air which the animal breathes. Man also has an animal soul, but he has a rational soul too, in virtue of God's inbreathing into his nostrils the breath of life. Man's soul therefore is immortal, his spirit is imperishable. Indeed all rational beings whether angels or men have an imperishable spirit, i.e. have immortality in this defined sense. Yet scripture does not call this "eternal life." The full import of this term goes far beyond the mere assertion of an endless life. It is a mode and phase of life in us, as we see it absolutely in the Incarnate, but now glorified, Son of God; and for which the only suitable and proper abode is His own immediate presence in heaven. In fact the character of life in men and angels differs. Again, as fallen, men need redemption and regeneration; and surely it will not be denied that the character of life, in virtue of which a man is regenerate, differs from that which our first parents had when first created. Life is not characterised as "eternal life," till manifested in the Son, and eternal life is, in scripture, predicated only of those who are sons, — only of those of whom it can be said that Christ is the "firstborn amongst many brethren." Again, life as given by Christ in resurrection w hen He breathed on His disciples, — a life which has passed through and is triumphant over death, was there in this, nothing new, nothing special and specific, nothing in advance of every spiritual privilege or condition which had gone before? Was there no difference in the spiritual condition of the apostles before and after our Lord breathed on them? Conversion and the remission of sins they undoubtedly had before. Was there no difference in the condition of the believers in Acts 10 before and after receiving the Holy Ghost? Our Lord's baptism by the Holy Ghost was quite distinct from His conception by the Holy Ghost, and so the gift of the Spirit to believers is quite distinct from the operations of the Spirit, whether in quickening souls, prophecy, etc. So little was the latter for their own personal benefit, that we read in 1 Peter 1:12 it was revealed to the Old Testament prophets that their predictions as regards our Lord, were for us, and not for themselves. But spiritual condition, privilege, etc. are dependent on the revelation which God gives, and according to which the faith is formed; it is this which gives distinctive character to the life. As Creator, God is the Father of angels and of men, — in this sense they are His sons; but is there no difference between this and the being made "partakers of the divine nature" (2 Peter 1:4)? or, between this and our being "the sons of God by faith in Christ Jesus" (Gal. 3:26)? Difference between the Old Testament, saints, as being partakers of the divine nature, and our being the "sons of God by faith in Christ Jesus," is categorically stated in Gal. 4:1-7.

Numerical Bible NotesThe Pentateuch

Let us note first, then, that angels are spirits and that the angels had already fallen; also that the condemnation of the devil is for pride. (1 Tim. 3:6.) Now all through this account there seems the constant endeavor (which, to speak humanly, is God's, we know,) to "hide pride from man." (Job 33:17.) Thus he is called "Adam," from adamah, the ground, as if to remind him of his origin — "Dust thou art." Yet he was assuredly something more than "dust." Here, in the same way, his being a living soul reminds him of his kinship with the beasts; yet it does not show that he is not more. Among spiritual beings, this is, indeed, his real distinction, — that he is a "living soul."

William KellyThe Preaching to the Spirits in Prison

Again, our Lord in Luke 24:39, compared with 37 (and see Matt. 14:26), explains "spirit." "A spirit hath not flesh and bones as ye see Me have," even when risen. He had a "spiritual body," and was not a mere "spirit," though a quickening spirit. Granted that angels are spirits, but so is man when disembodied, whether the Lord Himself before He rose (Matt. 27:50; John 19:30), saints (Acts 7:59 ; Heb. 12:23; Rev. 22:6, as rightly read), or the unbelieving (l Peter 3:19). Soul (ψυχὴ) is the "ego" or 'I," the seat of personal identity, and therefore predicable of men alive or dead, as in ver. 20, etc., for the former; or Rev. 6:9; Rev. 20:4, for the latter; while πνεῦμα expresses the spiritual capacity, inseparable from the soul, wherein is the working of the will. They compose the inner man, as the body is the outer.

A. J. PollockThe Nature and Ministry of Angels

They form a spiritual race, for Psalm 104:4, quoted in Hebrews 1:7, says: “Who makes His angels spirits, and His ministers a flaming fire.”

Though angels are spirits it does not follow that they are incorporeal, for Scripture speaks of a spiritual body. In the resurrection the saints will have spiritual bodies. We mention this simply to show that there is such a thing, a body not subject to the limitations of our earthly condition. Angels often appeared in bodily form. We do not assert that they are corporeal. We merely point out that they are not of necessity incorporeal.

Verses

  • Hebrews 12:9Moreover we have had the fathers of our flesh as chasteners, and we reverenced [them]; shall we not much rather be in subjection to the Father of spirits, and live?
  • Hebrews 1:14Are they not all ministering spirits, sent out for service on account of those who shall inherit salvation?
  • Psalms 104:4Who maketh his angels spirits; his ministers a flame of fire.
  • Hebrews 1:7And as to the angels he says, Who makes his angels spirits and his ministers a flame of fire;
  • Luke 20:36for neither can they die any more, for they are equal to angels, and are sons of God, being sons of the resurrection.
  • Matthew 22:30For in the resurrection they neither marry nor are given in marriage, but are as angels of God in heaven.
  • Luke 24:39behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself. Handle me and see, for a spirit has not flesh and bones as ye see me having.
  • Ephesians 6:12because our struggle is not against blood and flesh, but against principalities, against authorities, against the universal lords of this darkness, against spiritual [power] of wickedness in the heavenlies.