‘Who is this that hides counsel without knowledge?’ Therefore I have uttered what I did not understand, things too wonderful for me, which I did not know.
Job 42:3 · ESVView all translations

Job has just heard God speak, and he answers by turning God's own question against himself. This verse is the hinge. A man who argued his case for chapters now admits he had been talking about matters he never understood.

The Rebuke Job Takes as His Own

The words "who is this that hides counsel without knowledge?" are not Job's invention. He is quoting the opening question God had put to him, and by quoting it he agrees with it. Some readers have aimed that question at Elihu, one of the men who had spoken to Job.

Here we have his full answer, his complete bowing down before Jehovah. He acknowledges first Jehovah's supreme power. He is all-powerful and can do all things. Then he quotes Jehovah's own words (38:2; 40:2). "You have asked me, Who is this that hides counsel without knowledge?" It is strange that some interpreters misuse these words, as if the Lord were rebuking Elihu again. No — as we have shown before, He rebukes Job for the wild and reckless charges he had made against the Lord. And now Job acknowledges that Jehovah's rebuke is right.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

What It Means to Hide or Darken Counsel

To darken counsel is to throw a shadow over God's ways by talking about them. Job's speeches had not cleared the mystery of his suffering; they had made it darker.

Quoting Jehovah's own words, he asks himself, Who is he who darkens counsel? — who dares to throw a shadow upon the Almighty! There are mysteries in His ways, as there are in all creation and providence. But no one gains anything by rebelling against these mysteries of God's counsel. He did not even know the simplest truths of nature in their hidden meaning. Yet he had spoken of things beyond the reach of a limited mind, and so he had spoken folly. How different he had been from the devout psalmist: "Such knowledge is too wonderful for me; it is high, I cannot attain it" (Ps. 139:6). He had intruded into the things of God, and had dared to speak evil of divine omnipotence and goodness!

Samuel Ridout

"Things Too Wonderful for Me"

Job's confession is about reach, not honesty. He had handled subjects far above him, and behind that lay how little he knew of God.

He now realises that his earlier words came out of ignorance of God, who "can do everything." This reminds us of Peter's words to the Lord Jesus, "Lord, you know everything" (John 21:17). Peter had to learn the same lesson as Job. He too had trusted himself too much, insisting that he would never deny the Lord Jesus, even if everyone else did. Job fully admits to the Lord that he had spoken without knowing what he was saying — things too wonderful for him. He had tried to handle matters far beyond his understanding, and he found himself humiliated.

Leslie M. Grant

Silence About His Friends

Job had spent chapter after chapter answering his friends. Notice who is missing from his confession.

He complains no more, he resents no more, he questions no more. He openly owns, as something real in his soul, that Jehovah is able to do all things, and that no purpose is withheld from Him. Evil in men or Satan, and ruin everywhere in this fallen world, had touched Him in no way. His own difficulties and arguments were only the unsubmissive heart of a man who darkened counsel without knowledge, as Jehovah Himself had said at the start. Now it was Job who declared his own ignorance. He did not understand — things too wonderful for him that he did not know. Not a word now about his friends, or their lack of intelligence, honesty and charity, however true that was. He judges himself before God. He takes the words God had used against him — the crushing proof of his presumption — and makes them his own. They become the humble words of a man who felt his need to learn from God, and who wanted that learning worked in him.

William Kelly

Why an Upright Man Had So Much to Take Back

Job's outward life was excellent. The problem was what that excellence had done to his opinion of himself.

Job had opened his mouth "in vain," or "in vanity." His words were many, but they carried no knowledge. The excellence of Job's outward life had betrayed him into an inward spirit of vanity. That vanity was the root of his failure to truly know himself. Job himself confesses this in Job 42:3.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- Knowledge missing. Job's speeches were many but empty. Many words are not the same as understanding, and God's question exposes the gap.

- Knowledge borrowed. He repeats God's own words instead of building a defence. That is the mark of a rebuke he now accepts as true.

- Knowledge overreached. He reached for matters beyond any creature's grasp. The reaching cast a shadow over God's ways instead of clearing them.

- Knowledge turned inward. The friends vanish from his answer. The man who judged everyone else now judges himself before God.

- Knowledge at the root. A fine outward life had bred inward vanity. His real ignorance was not about God's world but about himself.

Reviewed by Orion on September 2, 2026