They lie down alike in the dust, and the worms cover them.
Zophar had insisted that a wicked man's ruin always shows, so Job points to two men — one comfortable, one bitter — who end in the same dust. What, then, can a man's outward life prove about him before God?
Two lives, one end
The verse closes a short argument that runs from verse 22. Job sets one wicked man beside another and asks who can account for the difference.
Leslie M. GrantHow foolish it is to think that anyone can teach God knowledge (v.22), since He judges those on high just as He does the lowest. The wicked differ so widely among themselves that it is folly to judge by what happens to them. Why? Because "one dies in his full vigor, being wholly at ease and secure" (v.23). He keeps his property and his health right up to his death (v.24). Another wicked man dies in bitterness, after a whole life of misery. Yet in the end "they lie down alike in the dust." The one finishes where the other finishes, though their lives on earth were opposites. Who can explain why? Zophar thought he had the answer to Job's troubles. But he had not faced this difference that Job set before him. The answer to all such questions must wait until after death.
Appearances prove nothing
Job's friends judged by what they could see. Two dead men, side by side, break that method.
William KellyLook at these two men, each with a full cup, one of happiness, the other of misery; both lying dead together. Appearances prove nothing but the haste and folly of those who judge before the time.
The same scene overturns the rule the friends applied to Job.
Samuel RidoutBoth alike reach the same end in the grave. Since that is so, how wrong it is for his friends to lay down an unchanging rule — that trouble in this life is always a sign of sin, and prosperity always a sign of righteousness, in the people it falls on. Job himself had found no solution to his problem. Even so, he could at least urge his friends not to "pronounce judgment before the time."
Half a truth
What the friends said was not false. It was partial — and Job, for all his faults, held the larger view.
William KellyYou see, what Zophar and the others pressed was only half a truth. And half a truth never sanctifies. What you leave out may be just as important, or even more important. That was exactly the difference. For all his faults, Job really was holding on to the truth. He looked at it with a larger heart and with a conscience that had been tested. Some people talk morally, or, as you might say, they preach. But it did not come from their souls. It was only the correct thing to say by human standards. It was not really the language of faith at all.
The funeral that decides nothing
The mistake did not die with Job's friends. Funerals still invite it.
William Kelly"They lie down alike in the dust." And the careless world goes to their funeral and thinks they are both all right, that all is well with them both. That is what people call "judging with charity" — charitable judgment! They hope that everybody goes to heaven, unless they are too bad — openly wicked!
What lies past the dust
Job could not see the whole answer, but he was looking in the right direction — forward, not at the present scene.
William KellyThe friends judged too soon. They turned their eyes — blinded eyes, sadly — to the present, as the Christian world does, instead of waiting, as Job did, for the resurrection and the kingdom.
The two men part company after the grave. The Lord gave the picture of what follows.
William KellyBut there is the terrible end that waits for them — the waking up of the rich man in the Lord's story: "in Hades, being in torment, he lifted up his eyes." That was a solemn thing, and it was the Lord who gave us that picture. Nobody could speak with certainty about it until the Lord came. And this does not describe what happens after the resurrection. This is what happens right after death.
Summary
- Same dust. One man dies comfortable, another dies bitter; the worms treat them the same. Burial is the one thing every life has in common.
- No verdict. Both ends look the same. So a man's comfort or misery now tells you nothing certain about his standing before God.
- Half a truth. The friends were not lying, only partial — and a half truth, however well spoken, has no power to sanctify.
- False comfort. A shared funeral tempts people to assume a shared destiny. That is charity in name only.
- After death. The grave keeps the answer back; God gives it later. Job was right to wait for the resurrection and the kingdom, instead of reading God's verdict off the present.