Have you listened in the council of God? And do you limit wisdom to yourself?
Job 15:8 · ESVView all translations

Eliphaz turns on Job with a sarcastic question. Has Job stood inside God's private council chamber and walked away with wisdom no one else owns? The taunt is meant to cut Job down to size. Yet behind Job's suffering stood a real counsel of God, and no one on earth had heard it.

What the Question Asks

Eliphaz is not asking for information. He is stacking up credentials Job cannot have. One of them reaches back before the earth and hills were made.

He next challenges Job: where did he get wisdom greater than theirs? Has he been in the secret counsel of God from the beginning, before the earth and hills were made? Only divine Wisdom, the eternal Son, could claim such a relation to God as that (Prov. 8). As for Job, he is like them, only with less experience than many people Eliphaz could point to.

Samuel Ridout

An Accusation Job Never Earned

The charge of hoarding wisdom fits someone in that conversation — but not the man it is aimed at.

Therefore it was dishonest of Eliphaz to ask him, "Are you the first man who was born? Or were you brought forth before the hills? Have you listened in the council of God? And do you limit wisdom to yourself?" (vv.7-8). Job had asked his friends almost the same question that Eliphaz asks in verse 9, "What do you know that we do not know?" He had said, "What you know, I also know; I am not inferior to you" (ch.13:2). But Eliphaz accused him of claiming to be superior to them. Eliphaz should have rebuked Zophar for assuming that he knew the secrets of wisdom and that Job did not. The arguments of Eliphaz only exposed his partiality.

Leslie M. Grant

A Counsel No One on Earth Heard

The irony is that a conversation about Job had taken place. The whole value of the book turns on where it was held.

At first sight the difficulty grows. Remember how precious Job was to God, and how tender God's mercy is to His children. Then think of such a trial on earth, after hearing what God said about him in heaven. But much of the good this book brings depends on one fact: heaven alone heard God's estimate of Job and Satan's plan to test him. The reason for the trial stayed secret for the time being — a secret here on earth, not there in heaven. Neither Job nor his friends knew anything of what God had said about him. Satan knew well, but he could not imagine an integrity that keeps suffering with nothing to gain.

William Kelly

The Mistake Underneath the Taunt

The friends had no window into heaven. So they judged Job by what they could see.

Their error was not a rare one, especially among the righteous — people who know God but have never been thoroughly broken down about themselves. You still find such people among His own on the earth. But here is where they went astray: they assumed that the present state of the world fully expresses God's judgment of men's ways.

William Kelly

A God They Only Knew as Judge

Their trouble went deeper than a wrong reading of Job's suffering. It lay in how they pictured God Himself.

The friends spoke much of God, but they looked on Him only as a judge. This was a great defect, and correcting it is the moral of the whole book. Some people think the one question before God now is whether He is marking down what we deserve in this life. They fail to see that God has used the evil that is here to show the grace that is in Himself, a grace above the evil.

William Kelly

Who Gets Let In

Eliphaz's sneer assumes no human being is ever admitted to God's private thoughts. God does share His mind. But the condition is not the one Eliphaz had in mind.

His secret is with those who fear the Lord. God does not make His mind and the secret of His ways known to all His children, nor does He admit them all to the closeness of friendship — and much less the world. Every child of God has the same standing in grace, and enjoys the same life, relationship, and favour. But not all enjoy the same closeness of communion. One thing is needed to know the mind of God. It is not outward standing, or correct position, or learned knowledge of Scripture, but a spirit and a life saturated with the fear of God.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- Secret mocked. Eliphaz demands credentials no man holds. Only divine Wisdom, the eternal Son, stood in God's counsel before the hills were made.

- Secret misused. The charge of hoarding wisdom fit Zophar, not Job. Job had claimed only that he was not inferior. Eliphaz's partiality showed.

- Secret withheld. Heaven alone heard God's estimate of Job and Satan's challenge. Job and his friends knew nothing of it, and that secret is the point of the book.

- Secret replaced. With no view into heaven, the friends read God's judgment off a man's circumstances. They knew Him only as judge, and missed His grace.

- Secret given. God does share His mind — not with the best-positioned or best-read, but with a life saturated with the fear of God.

Reviewed by Orion on September 16, 2026