Pharaoh said to his brothers, “What is your occupation?” And they said to Pharaoh, “Your servants are shepherds, as our fathers were.”
Genesis 47:3 · ESVView all translations

Famine in Canaan has driven Jacob's family to Egypt, and five of Joseph's brothers now stand before Pharaoh. His question about their work is simple. Their answer decides where they will live and how Egypt will see them.

A Plain Answer, Matching Joseph's Word

Joseph had already told Pharaoh who these men were. Their own answer matches his.

Joseph tells Pharaoh that his father and his brothers have come. First he introduces five of his brothers. We are not told which ones, but they were likely those who could speak on behalf of their other brothers. They answer Pharaoh's question about their occupation by confirming Joseph's word. They were shepherds as their fathers were, and they wanted to live in Egypt for a time, because the famine had left no pasture in Canaan.

L. M. Grant

Why Goshen Was the Right Land

Their answer named a trade Egypt despised. One commentator shows why Goshen still suited them, and why Pharaoh had to decide it himself.

On every point of view Goshen was the land most appropriate for his father and his brothers. The land lay nearest for those who were only staying in Egypt for a time. God had destined them to enter Canaan, the land He had promised long before, when their father had not even one son. Again, it was near Joseph, and the king also; and further, it was the least frequented by the people of the land, to whom herdsmen, shepherds and the like were detestable, as Joseph let them know. … But it mattered that the king should come to the same conclusion as his minister of state, and decree freely without any pressure from one so near to the sons of Israel. Bringing in enough of his brothers was a wise arrangement. They stated their occupation plainly, as handed down from their fathers. The king not only agreed that Goshen was the best place for them to live; he gave them a hearty welcome.

William Kelly

Why a Despised Trade Found Favour

Egyptians loathed shepherds, yet Pharaoh welcomed this family. One writer explains it from who held power in Egypt at the time.

The last verse of the next chapter tells us that "every shepherd is an abomination to the Egyptians." This might have surprised us, if we did not know, as we said before, that at that time the ruling powers in Egypt were not true Egyptians. They were a foreign race, closely connected with the wandering, shepherd people that Jacob and his sons belonged to. The Pharaoh of those days may well have seen it as a stroke of good business to receive Jacob and his descendants. It would bring under his protection those who would be his natural allies.

F. B. Hole

The Trade That Kept Them Separate

What made Egyptians recoil served God's purpose. This family was about to become a nation.

The Lord, without doubt, directed this move to Egypt. It guarded the family from being scattered, and from mixing with strangers, during the important period that had now arrived, when the family was appointed to grow into a nation. In Canaan both of those bad results would have been unavoidable. Neither could follow in Egypt. Goshen gave ample room for their growing numbers, while the Egyptians' dislike of shepherds kept the two peoples from marrying into each other.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Owned Before the Throne

Joseph is the lord of Egypt. The men he brings in are shepherds from a starving land. He claims them anyway.

They were only shepherds, it is true, and such men were detestable to the Egyptians. But Joseph "is not ashamed to call them brothers." Strangers they were, and dependents. But the man of that day, the lord of Egypt, again I say, was "not ashamed to call them brothers." He owns them in the presence of the king, of the palace, and of the nation. And the king proves to be of the same mind. That they were Joseph's brothers was enough for Pharaoh.

J. G. Bellett

The Calling the World Still Resents

The trade the brothers named carries a lesson for believers now.

God expects His own people to have hearts as shepherds, to care for the needs of souls. The world (Egypt) not only ignores such shepherd care, but resents others who engage in it. In fact, even believers too often do not value the care and concern a godly person tries to show them. For this reason we sadly neglect to do true shepherd work.

L. M. Grant

Summary

- Confess — Asked what they do, the brothers name their trade and trace it to their fathers. It is just what Joseph had said for them.

- Ask — That answer opens the way to Goshen: nearest to Canaan, nearest to Joseph, least visited by Egyptians.

- Favour — Pharaoh's own line was tied to shepherd people. He welcomed them as natural allies worth protecting.

- Separation — What Egypt despised became God's fence. Goshen gave room to multiply, and no marriage ties to dissolve the family into Egypt.

- Owned — The lord of Egypt is not ashamed to call shepherds his brothers, and says so before king, palace and nation. God still looks for shepherd hearts the world resents.

Reviewed by Orion on September 19, 2026