And at the harvests you shall give a fifth to Pharaoh, and four fifths shall be your own, as seed for the field and as food for yourselves and your households, and as food for your little ones.”
The famine has taken Egypt's money, its livestock and at last its land. The people now stand before Joseph with nothing but their lives, and this verse sets the terms they will live by from here on.
Seed Before Harvest
The people had nothing left before this verse begins. Joseph gives them seed to sow, and the larger share of the crop stays with them.
L. M. GrantJoseph was not a cruel dictator who was seeking his own wealth by impoverishing the people. Some have strangely criticized the plan he put into action, but the people themselves appreciated it (v. 25). He had bought them and their land. Now he tells them he will give them seed to sow the land. For their labor they would receive four fifths of the crop. This arrangement would work very well, but only on one condition. The rulers had to be fair-minded and considerate of the people, and the people had to act responsibly.
The Fifth as Acknowledgment
Pharaoh had already bought the land. The people get it back as a gift from the king, and the fifth they hand over each harvest marks what they owe.
Numerical Bible NotesThe people are bankrupt through the famine. They receive their lands back from the king's bounty, and they give him one fifth of the crop. That fifth is the token of what they owe to the grace they have received. This is how the world, under Christ, will find its place in true blessing before God. The one fifth they hand back reminds us once more of the Abrahamic five — the weakness of the creature and the all-power of God — that one part being a recognition of divine sovereignty. If we take it as two tenths, it may remind us of the double claim of God upon us — by creation and by redemption.
Elsewhere in Scripture the number five stands for what a person owes to other people.
Edward DennettTen is the number of responsibility towards God, as, for example, in the ten commandments (see also Exodus 30:13, etc.), and five is responsibility towards man. (See Gen. 47:24; Num. 5:7, etc.)
A Verdict Not Shared by All
Commentators differ over how to judge the arrangement. One sees a settlement the people welcomed. Another reads the lasting rent as harsh, and traces a long result from it.
F. B. HoleSo bit by bit everything in Egypt fell into Pharaoh's hands. Joseph made a law that people must acknowledge Pharaoh's ownership by paying rent in kind — a fifth of all the produce. This was oppressive legislation indeed, but quite ordinary in those days. We can see how, over many years, it may have helped to provoke that uprising of the ancient Egyptian dynasty. Scripture records it like this: "Now there arose a new king over Egypt, who did not know Joseph" (Ex. 1:8).
Egypt as a Sample of the Coming World
Read as a picture, Egypt under Joseph shows what the earth will look like when redemption has brought it back to God.
J. G. BellettThey hand over their money, their cattle, their lands and themselves to Pharaoh. Yet it all pleases them, for they owe their lives to Joseph. Egypt, in those days, was a sample of the new world, the world brought back to God by redemption. It was a "purchased possession," just what the millennial earth is to be. Eph. 1:14. It was creation reconciled, delivered from the doom of famine, from death and the curse, by the hand of a saviour.
Power Held for Another
Notice who receives the fifth. Joseph claims everything, but never for himself.
Hamilton SmithA second great fact stands out: in claiming everything, Joseph claims it for Pharaoh. Joseph gathers up all the money, and we read that he "brought the money into Pharaoh's house" (v. 14). The land comes under Joseph's control, and we read that he "bought all the land of Egypt for Pharaoh" (v. 20). So too, of the people, Joseph can say, "Behold, I have this day bought you and your land for Pharaoh." So Joseph uses his supreme power not to advance himself, but for the glory of Pharaoh.
The two aims are not rivals. One and the same power upholds the throne and blesses the people.
Hamilton SmithOn the one hand, Joseph uses his power to bring everything under Pharaoh. On the other hand, he uses his complete supremacy to bless the people. Where Pharaoh's glory is upheld, the people's blessing is sure — but only as they submit to Joseph without holding anything back.
Summary
- Bankrupt. The people owned nothing when Joseph spoke these words. Pharaoh had already bought the land.
- Given. They receive seed and their fields back from the king's bounty, not by buying them.
- Owned. The fifth is the token of what they owe to the grace that saved them. It acknowledges God's sovereignty, and His double claim by creation and redemption.
- Kept. Four parts stay with them — seed, food, and bread for their households. They welcomed the terms, though some have judged them oppressive.
- Foreshadowed. Egypt settled under Joseph is a sample of the world brought back to God by redemption. There one power serves the throne's glory and the people's blessing at once.