They said to one another, “Here comes this dreamer.
Genesis 37:19 · ESVView all translations

Joseph's brothers see him coming across the fields of Dothan, and they decide his fate before he is close enough to hear them. The way they name him shows what they could not forgive.

Sent on an errand of love

The errand was his father's. Neither father nor son measured the danger waiting at the end of it.

Joseph then starts on his mission. He is sure of his father's love. He knows his brothers hate him. And deep inside he carries an idea of future greatness that he does not yet understand. Responding to the will of the father, he did not shrink from the post of danger which the father did not foresee for him... instead of returning when he could not find them, he stays at his post until he gets news of them. He then follows them to Dothan. He was not ready for the murderous, spiteful welcome waiting for him.

The Bible Treasury

"Master of dreams"

What they could not stand was not the dreaming itself.

They could not bear the idea of his exaltation. They hated him, and called him "this master of dreams" (v. 19), so they plotted his death. But Reuben rescued him, and says, "Shed no blood, but cast him into this pit."

W. T. P. Wolston

Hatred that did not wait

Distance was no protection for Joseph. The same distance means something very different when a sinner turns back to God.

For them Joseph is only a dreamer whose dreams they would gladly frustrate by conspiring to kill him... And how eager man is to express his hatred. "When they saw him afar off … they conspired against him to slay him." But God's thoughts are not our thoughts, nor His ways our ways. If it is a question of the Son of the Father's love drawing near to men, then indeed He will be rejected while still far off. But what if it is a question of a sinner drawn to the Father? Then we read that while he was "still a long way off, his father saw him and felt compassion, and ran and embraced him and kissed him."

Hamilton Smith

"This is the heir"

The same reasoning turns up in a parable Jesus told.

These words strongly remind us of the parable in Matthew 21. "But last of all he sent to them his son, saying, They will respect my son. But when the tenants saw the son, they said to themselves, This is the heir; come, let us kill him and have his inheritance. And they took him and threw him out of the vineyard and killed him." God sent His Son into the world with this thought: "They will respect my son." But sadly, man's heart had no reverence for the "well beloved" of the Father. They cast Him out. Earth and heaven were at issue about Christ, and they are at issue still. Man crucified Him; but God raised Him from the dead.

C. H. Mackintosh

The dreams they meant to bury

They meant to bury the dreams along with the dreamer.

They thought his dreams were only an idle fancy, which they could easily get rid of. They had to learn that the dreams were a revelation of the purpose of God, and they could not overthrow it.

F. B. Hole

That failure turned out to be the best thing that ever happened to them.

The dreams of Joseph were God-sent, and as real in the outcome as the realities of others are only daydreams. And what a mercy it was for his half-brothers, who were not brothers in heart! Their cruel purpose took effect only in part. God, in His goodness, wisdom, and power, turned it to bring about the very rise they hated as much as they envied.

William Kelly

"We shall see"

Their taunt challenged God's word. Events answered it then, and a larger answer is still coming.

Man imagines in vain that corruption and violence will prosper. The brothers of Joseph did the same. They had planned to kill their brother and meant to cover their act with lies, yet they could say with complete confidence, "We shall see what will become of his dreams." They will indeed see. And it is a terrible thing for those who reject Christ. They too will see, for it is written: "Behold, He is coming with the clouds, and every eye will see Him, even those who pierced Him, and all tribes of the earth will wail on account of Him."

Hamilton Smith

Summary

- Sent. Joseph came on his father's errand. He knew his brothers hated him, and he did not turn back when the first search failed.

- Scorned. They refused his name and called him "master of dreams". They could not bear the rise his dreams promised.

- Settled. They formed the plot while he was still far off. The same reasoning appears in the parable of the vineyard: "This is the heir; come, let us kill him."

- Stopped. The dreams they called fantasy were God's declared purpose. Their plan half failed, and it produced the very rise they wanted to stop.

- Seen. Their taunt, "We shall see what will become of his dreams," came true against them. It points to a day when every eye will see the One they rejected.

Reviewed by Orion on September 4, 2026