But when he told it to his father and to his brothers, his father rebuked him and said to him, “What is this dream that you have dreamed? Shall I and your mother and your brothers indeed come to bow ourselves to the ground before you?”
Joseph tells his second dream to the whole family, and this time his father answers him. The rebuke raises three questions: was Joseph boasting, what did the sun and moon stand for, and did Jacob believe him?
The symbols Jacob read at once
Jacob did not need the dream explained. The heavenly bodies carried a plain meaning in a household like his.
F. B. HoleBoth his dreams foretold his coming greatness and glory. The meaning was so plain that his brothers, and his father too, saw it at once. The drift of the two was the same. But only the second suggested that his father and mother, as well as his brothers, would bow down to him in a day to come. There was a further difference. Sheaves belong to an earthly harvest, while sun, moon and stars are heavenly objects. The sun is a symbol of supreme authority, and the moon of authority derived from it and joined with it. Jacob saw at once how well this fitted the place of father and mother in his large family.
Why the rebuke came
Commentators differ on what Jacob was reacting to. One reading is that he heard pride in it.
L. M. GrantThe second dream seems to have raised questions in his brothers' minds. He told them, and told his father too, that he had dreamed of the sun and moon and eleven stars bowing down to him. His father rebuked him. He evidently felt that pride in Joseph had produced the dream. The implication was plain to him: he himself, Rachel and his eleven children would all bow down to Joseph.
Another finds no fault in Joseph, and puts the trouble on the brothers.
William KellyThe second dream implied a remarkable honour, and it moved Jacob. He could not help storing up its meaning, dim as it still was to him. Joseph was simple and open, with no presumption in him at all. That only made his brothers' spite burn hotter, and it soon found an occasion to break out in outrageous malice. How like the way of the Jews with Him who was long afterwards to be the blessed One that Joseph pictured!
A rebuke that did not close the matter
Jacob's rebuke was not his last word. The next verse says he held on to what he had heard.
F. B. HoleHis father rebuked him. He assumed that what the dream pointed to could never happen. Yet Scripture records that he "kept the saying in mind." That shows he could not dismiss it, and that he saw more in it than he had thought at first. He had faith in God, even if it was weak; whereas the brothers had none.
The brothers' response: envy
Jacob questioned the dream; his brothers resented it. That reaction has a direct echo in the trial of Jesus.
C KnappAnd see what happens next. When Joseph tells his second dream, we read that his brothers envied him. It was the same with the great One whom he pictured. It is written of Pilate, "he knew that it was out of envy that they had delivered him up" (Matthew 27:18). And who can stand before envy, as the proverb asks? The rulers and the Pharisees were jealous of His standing. "Look, the world has gone after him," they said, in alarm.
Why two dreams and not one
The move from sheaves in a field to sun, moon and stars is not repetition. It widens the scope.
Hamilton SmithOne dream might have been enough to foretell the glories of Joseph. It would be far too small to picture the glories of Christ. For His supremacy will have a twofold character… The dream of the sheaves bowing to Joseph's sheaf may well speak of that excellent supremacy over all the earth which Christ is destined to wield. Yet this first dream does not set out His supremacy in full. He is destined to be supreme not only on earth, but to hold universal sway over heaven and earth… And this second dream speaks of that heavenly supremacy. It presents heavenly bodies — the sun, the moon, and the stars — bowing down to Joseph.
A dream larger than the household
Jacob measured the dream by the household he knew. The picture reaches further than that.
The Bible TreasuryJacob's view of the prophetic dream seems limited to his own family. He heard that the sun and moon and eleven stars paid homage to Joseph. He then asked whether he, Joseph's mother and Joseph's brothers would really bow to the ground before him. The sun and the moon were, to Jacob, father and mother. But this dream goes far beyond Jacob's family, or the nation of Israel.
Summary
- Read — Jacob needed no interpreter. Sun stands for supreme authority, moon for authority derived from it, and he applied both to himself and Rachel.
- Rebuked — He objected to the dream. Some read his reaction as a charge of pride; others find no presumption in Joseph at all.
- Retained — The rebuke was not the whole of Jacob. He kept the saying in mind, and that marks faith, weak but real, in a man whose sons had none.
- Resented — The brothers answered the second dream with envy, the same motive Pilate saw in those who handed Jesus over.
- Reach — Jacob measured the dream by his own household. The sheaves picture supremacy over the earth, and the stars supremacy over heaven too.