The sons of Jacob came upon the slain and plundered the city, because they had defiled their sister.
Two brothers had killed the men of Shechem. Now the rest of Jacob's sons come to the bodies and strip the town. Scripture gives their reason in one clause: "because they had defiled their sister." Was that reason enough? And what else was driving them?
What Happened at Shechem
The plunder came on top of a massacre.
Leslie M. GrantThen the cruel treachery of Jacob's sons comes to the surface. The text names only Simeon and Levi here, the brothers of Dinah, though Reuben and Judah were also her brothers. But the two of them attack the unarmed city. They kill every male while the men are still sore from surgery. Of course this took the men by surprise, and they had no defence. No one remained to organize a counter attack. The two also killed Hamor and Shechem, who had been considerate of Jacob's family. They took Dinah from Shechem's house. They carried off the other women and children as captives. They seized the goods of the people, including all their livestock, as if they were the spoils of war.
The Reason Given, and the Reason Underneath
Dinah's honour is the reason given. It was not the only motive at work.
The Bible TreasurySimeon and Levi say, "Should he treat our sister like a prostitute?" making her honour cover their covetousness. At least Jacob is honest, for he says, "You have brought trouble on me by making me stink … and I shall be destroyed, both I and my household."
Religion Turned into a Weapon
They killed under cover of religion. One commentator calls that the worst part of the whole affair.
The Bible TreasuryIn condemning Simeon and Levi, the Holy Spirit speaks out against religious intolerance and persecution. They are joined together and deceitful, as religious bigotry always is. But every truly religious man will echo Jacob's rejection of it: "Let my soul come not into their council; O my glory, be not joined to their company. For in their anger they killed men, and in their willfulness they hamstrung oxen." The innocent suffer with the guilty in these cursed crusades — the innocent ox along with the guilty Shechem — and Shechem was not half as bad as they were. The worst of this crime is that they do it in the name of God, religious order and separation. So they bring religion into the contempt of unthinking minds. They manage to wrong the world and the church at the same time.
Where the Trouble Started
Commentators trace the disaster back past the sons to the father. Jacob had bought land at Shechem and built a house there instead of moving on.
William KellyOne wrong step away from our true position before the Lord leads to many a sin, scandal, and sorrow. So we find here, as the consequence of Jacob's buying the land of the Hivite and building himself a house. His stay at Succoth and Shechem covers some ten years. He had to be unsettled to get him back to his pilgrim place. But the way was painful for all. For Jacob himself it brought deep shame, humiliation and fear.
God's Verdict — and What Grace Did With It
Jacob never forgot. Years later his judgment fell on Levi, one of the two ringleaders.
George C. WillisYears later, in Genesis 49, the dishonour to the name of God and the horror and shame of the whole thing come over Jacob's soul. They strike him far more strongly than they seem to have done at the moment of the sin. He cries: "Cursed be their anger, for it is fierce, and their wrath, for it is cruel! I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel." God scattered Levi in Israel to punish that terrible sin, committed centuries before at Shechem. But now, for our encouragement, see the grace of God. The very punishment, the scattering in Israel, becomes an unspeakable blessing. God chooses this tribe to draw near to Him. He scatters them through Israel, so the knowledge of God and His Word spreads just as widely through them.
Scripture does not soften the picture, and that is deliberate.
C. H. MackintoshWe have here a truly humbling view of human nature as seen in the light of the holiness of God. It is as if the Lord would say to us: Look here! See a man dressed in nature's blackest clothing, showing nature's most repellent face. Examine him closely. See what man is once you strip away all the false clothing that ignorance or empty self-righteousness would put on him. Then you may know the rich abundance of My grace, which can lift even such a one into the highest heights of communion.
Summary
- Cause — A father who settled where he should only have passed through. One step out of place bred the sin, scandal and sorrow that filled his house.
- Cover — The sister's honour was real; it was also a cloak. Covetousness took the flocks, the wealth, the wives and the children while claiming to defend her.
- Cost — They used religion as the weapon. The innocent fell with the guilty, and religion itself fell into contempt.
- Curse — Jacob refused to be joined to that deed. He cursed their anger, and Levi was scattered for it.
- Conversion — The scattering itself became the blessing, for God chose Levi to draw near to Him. Scripture shows human nature at its blackest so we can measure grace against it.