They killed Hamor and his son Shechem with the sword and took Dinah out of Shechem's house and went away.
Two brothers walk into a city whose men cannot fight back. They kill its ruler and his son. Then they take their sister and go. The rescue is real, but the means are murder — and the rest of Scripture never lets the deed go unanswered.
Where the Ruin Began
One writer traces this bloodshed back to a much earlier failure in Jacob's own walk.
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 shows the unhappy results that sprang from the lowering of Jacob's separation from the world. Its effects for evil were not seen in Jacob himself but in his family. The tide of evil runs in two broad channels: violence and corruption. The world is just the same today. How often we have to hang our heads in shame and admit the truth. A little living on the border of the world on our part, as Christian parents, has led to sorrow and even disaster in our families.
A Sacred Sign Used as a Trap
Jacob's sons had set one condition on the city: every male must be circumcised. That left the men unable to fight. One writer names that condition for what it was.
William KellyNot the smallest thought or wish had they for inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap them and slaughter them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as they ignored their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong; but Dinah too was at fault. The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext to carry out their resentment to the very end.
Killing Men Who Could Not Resist
Two of Dinah's brothers did this, and the men they killed could not lift a hand.
L. M. GrantOnly Simeon and Levi are mentioned here, brothers of Dinah, though Reuben and Judah were also her brothers. The two attack the unarmed city, killing every male while they were still sore from surgery. Of course this was totally unexpected and the men had no defence. No men were left to organise any counter-attack. Hamor and Shechem also, who had been considerate of Jacob's family, were killed.
Vengeance Out of All Proportion
The brothers later defended themselves by pointing to their sister's disgrace. That defence does not survive examination.
L. M. GrantThis was not fair-mindedness, for Shechem had not actually dealt that way, and if he had, did that justify Simeon and Levi in killing all the men of that city and plundering their houses? Their dealings with the city were far worse than was Shechem's sin.
Under the appeal to their sister's honour, another writer hears greed.
The Bible TreasurySimeon and Levi say, "Should he treat our sister like a prostitute?" — making her honour cover their covetousness. At least Jacob is honest, for he says, "You have brought trouble on me by making me stink … I shall be destroyed, both I and my household."
The Long Reckoning — and the Turn
Years later, on his deathbed, Jacob cursed the anger of these two sons. He said they would be divided and scattered. One writer notes that the sentence stood, yet God changed what it produced.
F. B. HoleThe shameful story of Genesis 34 caused Jacob "to stink among the inhabitants of the land." That was a dreadful position for him, since he was the only man in the land who truly knew God. It also brought judgment on the two who promoted the violence. In later days the tribe of Levi acted in a way that gained a special blessing. So we are allowed to see how God can turn what was at first a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel." They were divided. But God did it by calling Levi to special service and scattering him throughout all the tribes.
The Same Sword, a Different Cause
Levi carries a sword again later in Israel's story. This time the cause is different.
C. H. MackintoshIt is true we see him here again with his sword by his side, but for what a different purpose, and in what a different cause! He is not now killing a man in anger and self-will. He acts in holy care for the honour of the Lord God of Israel, and in simple obedience to His command. He is no longer "joined" with his brother Simeon. In the days of his wickedness he might join him for deeds of blood. But here a new scene opens, and he is "joined" with the Lord and His servant Moses.
Summary
- Drift. Jacob's lowered separation from the world set the stage; the evil broke out not in him but in his children.
- Deceit. Jacob's sons offered the sign of God's covenant as bait, not as welcome — a lying pretext to disable a city.
- Disproportion. They avenged a real wrong with a far greater one, and plundered the houses too. Their sister's honour covered their greed.
- Divided. Jacob's dying words cursed their anger. His sentence scattered their descendants through Israel.
- Redeemed. Levi lifted his sword again, this time for God's honour. The scattering then became the tribe's service.