Then, when the copy of King Artaxerxes' letter was read before Rehum and Shimshai the scribe and their associates, they went in haste to the Jews at Jerusalem and by force and power made them cease.
Ezra 4:23 · ESVView all translations

The king's reply has arrived. The men who wrote against Jerusalem now have what they wanted: royal permission to stop the building. Two questions follow. Why did a Persian king care about a small building project? And was the enemy's letter the true reason the work stopped?

A gap in the timeline

The order of events here puzzles many readers.

Here there is a considerable gap. Several kings reigned between Cyrus and Darius, and they appear in the rest of the chapter. That part is an insert (verses 6-23), explaining what took place between those two points.

William Kelly

Royal authority, carried out at speed

The verse turns on how quickly the opponents moved once the answer arrived. One writer traces the king's reasoning and then the result: the two arguments in the letter were fear of future trouble and fear of lost income, and the palace records appeared to back them up.

The adversaries were successful, and having received the letter, they went up as fast as they could, armed with royal authority, and effectively made sure no attempt could be made to continue the work of building the Lord's house. "They made them cease," it says, "by force and power."

Edward Dennett

The argument that reached the king

Why would a Persian king bother with a city far away?

The adversaries of those days present the king with political reasons for preventing the reuniting of the people. Such motives had great weight with this crafty, usurping monarch and, in fact, were the only motives that might draw his concern. The king notes that Jerusalem once had powerful kings. They would overshadow him if their throne were re-established. He also notes that the city had always shown itself rebellious against any foreign rule. This is enough to stir him to put a stop to the work.

H. L. Rossier

Was the accusation just a lie?

Their last king, Zedekiah, had "sworn by God" to be faithful to Nebuchadnezzar, but he broke his oath and rebelled against the king of Babylon. So there was truth in the accusation that Jerusalem had been a rebellious city. The returned exiles were under God's favour and protection, and no one could harm them as long as they went forward in confidence in Him. Yet they now suffered, in His government in this world, the consequence of the sins of their fathers.

Edward Dennett

Four weapons in one chapter

The opposition changed shape as the chapter went on.

And so these four hostile forces unite here to ruin the work of God: trickery, intimidation, accusation, and violence. Only faith could have resisted them. But the people had no faith at all, and so the building of the house stopped for fifteen years.

H. L. Rossier

What actually stopped the building

Commentators press a point the verse does not say out loud. Compared with the prophecy of Haggai, it appears the work had already slowed badly before any order came from Persia.

But notice this — it is very important. God does not attribute the stopping of the work to the king's command. The king did give in at last, and did yield to their persistent begging to stop the Israelites. The Israelites began to stop before the king's authority arrived. It was lack of faith, not the king's authority, that stopped the work; and, beloved friends, as a rule, is it not always so? The ceasing of blessing among God's people is really never the work of the enemy outside, but lack of faith, and therefore of faithfulness, within.

William Kelly

The same writer quoted above tests this by a New Testament case, where opposition and open opportunity existed side by side.

These adversaries could have had no power against the people of God if the people themselves had not lost faith in God and heart for their work. The apostle wrote, "For a wide door for effective work has opened to me, and there are many adversaries" (1 Cor. 16:9); but not one of his opponents could have hindered his work, because he was counting on Him who "opens and no one will shut."

Edward Dennett

The silence that follows

Something is missing from the end of the chapter, and its absence is the point.

We can well imagine the scene when the letter was read before Rehum and Shimshai and their companions. They must have rushed up to Jerusalem in a fever of haste, and made them stop the work by force and power. "Then the work on the house of God that is in Jerusalem stopped, and it stopped until the second year of the reign of Darius king of Persia." The returned exiles faced a hard test, and a decline set in at that time. Their former energy seems to have left them, as we find when we consider Haggai's message. Nor do we read anything at the close of this chapter about turning to the LORD in prayer.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Darkness, but not defeat

Nothing in the closing verses records God speaking or acting.

Altogether it is a sad chapter — the account of Satan's activity. The only bright gleam in it is the faithfulness of the leaders of Israel in refusing an alliance with the world. The rest of the chapter is darkness. God does not appear in it; and, looked at with human eyes, it would seem as if the enemy had completely conquered. Yet while God does not step in, He is no uninterested spectator of what is taking place. Whatever His people are, He remains faithful. He will have His people thoroughly tested. But we shall see that He only waits for the right moment to raise up a power the enemy will not be able to withstand.

Edward Dennett

Summary

- Fear — The charge that moved the king was political, not religious: a rebuilt Jerusalem meant rival kings and a rebel city.

- Force — Armed with the king's letter, the opponents rushed to Jerusalem and stopped the building by force and power.

- Fault — Yet the work had already begun to stop before the king's order came. The real cause was unbelief inside, not the enemy outside.

- Faith — Trickery, intimidation, accusation and violence came in turn. Only faith could have stood against them, and the people had none.

- Faithfulness — God does not appear in the chapter, but He is not absent. He waits for the moment to raise up a power the enemy cannot resist.

Reviewed by Orion on September 6, 2026