The king sent an answer: “To Rehum the commander and Shimshai the scribe and the rest of their associates who live in Samaria and in the rest of the province Beyond the River, greeting. And now
The accusers' letter has reached the Persian court, and here the king answers it. His polite reply stopped the rebuilding of God's house for years. How did the enemy manage that?
The Answer They Had Engineered
The reply matches the letter that caused it. One writer points to what the accusers left out:
Edward DennettThese "adversaries of Judah and Benjamin" had claimed they wanted to help build the temple, since they too sacrificed to the God of Israel. Yet in their accusation they say nothing about the temple. They speak only of the city. Their reason is obvious. The proclamation of Cyrus concerned the temple. So by accusing the Jews of building the city, they made their hinted charges of rebellion and treason look believable. The king's answer shows they had judged it right.
The Two Motives That Moved a King
Two arguments moved the king, and the palace records backed them up:
Edward DennettThe two motives urged on the king were protection against future danger and the possible loss of revenue. The appeal worked. The royal records also confirmed what the letter said about the city's past. So the king wrote, "Give the command now to make these men stop, and that this city not be built, until I give another command. Be careful not to fail in this; why should damage grow to the hurt of the kings?" (vv. 17-22). The adversaries had succeeded. They received the letter and went up at full speed, armed with royal authority. They made sure no one could go on building Jehovah's house. "They made them cease," it says, "by force and power."
Why This King Listened
The king who sent this reply was not the rightful heir to the throne:
The Bible TreasuryVerses 7-23 describe the more successful scheme in the days of the Pseudo-Smerdis. He was a Magian usurper who impersonated the true Smerdis, Cyrus' younger son, whom Cambyses had put to death... After little more than seven months the false Smerdis, the Artaxerxes of our chapter, was killed, and Darius, one of the highest Persian nobles, gained the kingdom. This may explain why the impostor knew nothing of Cyrus' policy and so listened readily to arguments against it. It also explains why, under God, the king who shared the mind of Cyrus looked seriously into the truth and stood by the measures that honoured the God and people of Israel.
What the Enemy Was Really After
Another writer finds the enemy's real aim in their own words:
H. L. RossierThey wanted to stop the remnant from gathering together. Such a gathering would take away the enemy's power over the people of God: "If this city is built and its walls are finished, you will have no portion on this side of the river." Scattered, they would easily become the prey of their enemies. In the same way Satan opposes the gathering of the children of God today. If he cannot corrupt the sheep, he makes them quarrel, seizes them, and scatters them.
The Real Hindrance
The Bible does not blame the king's letter for the work stopping. One writer presses the point:
William KellyNote this — it is a very important thing. God does not blame the stopping of the work on the king's command. The king did give in at last, and did yield to their constant pleading to stop the Israelites. The Israelites began to stop before the king's authority came. It was lack of faith, not the king's authority, that stopped the work; and, dear friends, as a rule, is it not always so? The ending of blessing among God's people is never the work of the enemy outside. It is lack of faith, and so of faithfulness, inside.
The Silence of God in the Chapter
God is not named anywhere in this chapter, and the enemy appears to win. One commentator weighs that silence:
Edward DennettAltogether it is a sad chapter — the record of Satan's activity... God does not appear in it. To human eyes it looks as if the enemy has completely won. Yet though God does not step in, He is no uninterested spectator of what is happening. Whatever His people are, He remains faithful. He will have His people fully tested. But He only waits for the right moment to raise up a power the enemy cannot withstand.
Summary
- Reply — The accusers' letter spoke of the city, not the temple. That made the charge of rebellion stick, and the king's answer followed.
- Reason — Two arguments won him: fear of revolt, and lost revenue. The palace records confirmed the city's past, so the stop order came.
- Ruler — This Artaxerxes was a usurper. He knew nothing of Cyrus' policy, so he reversed it. Darius, the next king, looked into the truth and upheld it.
- Root — The building had already stalled before the letter came. Lack of faith inside, not authority outside, is what ends blessing among God's people.
- Rest — God is not named in the chapter, and the enemy looks like the winner. He is testing His people, waiting to raise up a power the enemy cannot resist.