Because you cherished perpetual enmity and gave over the people of Israel to the power of the sword at the time of their calamity, at the time of their final punishment,
Ezekiel 35:5 · ESVView all translations

God turns from promises of restoration for Israel to a word against Mount Seir, the land of Esau's descendants. Why does He single out this one nation among Israel's many enemies, and why does He date their crime so exactly?

Who Mount Seir is

Mount Seir is Edom's land, and the Edomites came from Esau. Their long record with Israel stands behind this charge. Their words at Jerusalem's fall show the mood.

The prophets keep pointing to Edom's dealings with Israel, and God judges Edom for its perpetual hatred of them. Ezek. 35:5. God once stirred up the king of Edom to punish Israel (1 Kings 11:14). Later He strengthened Israel to punish Edom. 2 Chr. 25:10-11. Some of the prophecies however extend to the future. Edom took pleasure in the punishment of Judah when judgment was falling upon it. Of Jerusalem they said, "Lay it bare, lay it bare, down to its foundations!" Ps. 137:7, showing, as other passages do too, the hatred and jealousy of the descendants of Esau.

Morrish Bible Dictionary

The root of the grudge

Where did such deep bitterness come from? One writer traces it back to what God gave Israel.

This threat is all the more solemn because it stands in contrast with the promise of goodness and mercy to Israel just before it. It was this very blessing, given by God's grace to the chosen people, that from the beginning stirred the growing bitterness of their relatives. They looked with resentment on the blessing promised to Israel, and they looked from their own heights of proud self-confidence.

William Kelly

If the grudge targets what God gave, the real quarrel is not with Jacob's family.

This is where the Edomite's lasting grudge and hatred against the Israelite comes from. And that hatred is really against God, against God's thoughts and ways. So no wonder it gets special attention here, just when Israel comes into his blessing. That is also the time when God casts Edom out for good.

F. W. Grant

Striking while God was chastening

The verse does not only say what Edom did; it says when. God was disciplining His people, and Edom used the opening.

God notices the feelings of the heart, and He makes distinctions in judgment, as He does in everything else. Israel had many proud enemies. Which of them was not willing to harm the people of Jehovah's choice? But He fixes His eyes on "the old enmity" of Edom. He fixes them on a hardness that was crueller than usual in the day of Israel's disaster, "at the time of the iniquity of the end." There was not a scrap of generosity in it. Natural family feeling had turned bitter as poison. His own people had shamefully dishonoured Him, and He was chastening them in measure. Who were the Edomites to take advantage of that, to crush without measure and destroy without mercy?

William Kelly

Two horizons

One writer was asked how far this prophecy reaches. His answer: the chapter has a near setting and a far one.

There is no doubt that Edom is the special object of judgment in the last days. But the passages you quote refer to the time when Israel will be in their land, and the Lord has come down to judgment. Ezekiel 35 does point directly to the time of the Babylonian captivity, when Edom, Jacob's rival, gloated over the ruin of Jerusalem. It also goes on to the final desolation of Mount Seir.

J. N. Darby

Enmity comes back on the one who keeps it

God's sentence answers the crime in kind. The lesson reaches far past Edom.

The enmity a man nurses in his soul will end up pursuing him. And when that enmity is against God and against His grace, however he may disguise it, God must judge it as such, and the end is sure.

F. W. Grant

The Edomite spirit today

The warning is not only for ancient nations. One writer sets Jeremiah and Daniel against the Edomite spirit.

Let us take the lesson to heart, for we can easily fall into the same spirit as the Edomite. Jeremiah saw the failures and sins of God's people, but he wept over them. Daniel and other godly men confessed those sins as their own. The spirit of the Edomite is different: bitter hatred against people who are still the people of God, however they may have failed. That spirit is especially displeasing to Him.

The Bible Treasury

Summary

- Grudge — Edom's hatred was old and never let go. It grew out of resentment at the blessing God's grace gave Jacob's line.

- Target — the grudge aimed at God's choice, so it was really enmity against God, not just against Israel.

- Timing — God was chastening His people in measure, and Edom seized that very moment to destroy without mercy.

- Sentence — the enmity a man nurses ends up pursuing him, and enmity against God's grace brings a sure end.

- Mirror — weep like Jeremiah and confess like Daniel over the failures of God's people; never gloat like Edom.

Reviewed by Orion on September 4, 2026