Why was Paul in prison?

Answered from the commentary of Arend Remmers, J. N. Darby, Hamilton Smith and 12 others

Paul was a prisoner for Christ's sake and not for any wrong he had done. The reason given most often is that he had preached the gospel of God's grace to the Gentiles. That gospel put Gentile and Jew on the same footing before God, and the Jews would not bear it, so it was Jewish antagonism to his going to the Gentiles that brought him into bonds. This is why in Ephesians 3:1 he calls himself "the prisoner of Jesus Christ for you Gentiles". In the Jews' estimation a man who could talk of going to the Gentiles was not fit to live (Acts 22:21-22).

At Rome Paul told the Jews that "for the hope of Israel" he was bound with his chain, meaning the promised Messiah. Seen this way, his only crime was his faith in God's promises to Israel through the Messiah (Acts 28:20). The two accounts are held together: the real offence was his stand for the hope of Israel, while the grace shown to Gentiles was what had roused the Jews' hatred. A smaller number place the question in the resurrection, which Paul named as the matter for which he was being judged.

The outward course of events ran from Jerusalem. While Paul was purifying himself in the temple, Jews from Asia seized him on the mistaken supposition that he had brought Trophimus, a Gentile, into the holy place. The Romans rescued him from being killed and held him in custody, bound. Several hold that his compliance with the elders' advice to go into the temple was a mistake that led him into this trouble.

The charges brought against him were false. Lysias, Felix, Festus, Agrippa and the governor's council were all convinced of his innocence. He remained a prisoner because his judges were unrighteous. Felix kept him two years hoping for a bribe, and then left him bound to please the Jews. Festus, also wishing to please them, proposed sending him to Jerusalem, so Paul appealed to Caesar as a Roman citizen. That appeal is what took him to Rome, and he might have been set at liberty had he not made it.

Over all of this stood God's purpose that Paul should bear witness at Rome. His imprisonment turned out for the furtherance of the gospel, since it became known that his bonds were in Christ and not for evil-doing.

Earlier, at Philippi, Paul and Silas were beaten and imprisoned. This followed his casting the spirit out of a slave girl: her masters lost their gain and brought false charges against them (Acts 16). In his last imprisonment, being a Christian had itself been declared a crime.

Verses: Acts 21:27, Acts 21:28, Acts 21:29, Acts 21:30, Acts 21:31, Acts 21:32, Acts 21:33, Acts 24:5, Acts 24:6, Acts 26:6, Acts 26:7, Acts 26:19, Acts 26:20, Acts 26:21, Acts 28:17, Acts 28:18, Acts 28:19, Acts 28:20, Acts 23:6, Acts 23:29, Acts 24:21, Acts 25:7, Acts 25:8, Acts 25:10, Acts 25:11, Acts 25:12, Acts 25:18, Acts 25:19, Acts 26:31, Acts 26:32, Acts 22:21, Acts 22:22, Acts 22:23, Acts 22:24, Acts 16:16, Acts 16:17, Acts 16:18, Acts 16:19, Acts 16:20, Acts 16:21, Acts 16:22, Acts 16:23, Acts 16:24, Acts 20:22, Acts 20:23, Acts 21:10, Acts 21:11, Acts 21:12, Acts 21:13, Ephesians 3:1, Ephesians 6:19, Ephesians 6:20, Philippians 1:7, Philippians 1:12, Philippians 1:13, Philippians 1:14, Colossians 4:3, 2 Timothy 1:8, 2 Timothy 1:11, 2 Timothy 1:12, 2 Timothy 2:8, 2 Timothy 2:9, Philemon 1:9, 2 Corinthians 11:23

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

Arend RemmersThe Epistles of the Apostle Paul

Hostile Jews seized Paul soon after his arrival in Jerusalem. He nearly became the victim of their fury - had not the Romans intervened and helped. The Romans then took him into protective custody. He remained a prisoner because of the false accusations made by his compatriots. He stayed in Jerusalem and then, for two years, in Caesarea. When the Roman governor Felix handed over his office to Porcius Festus [2] in 60 AD a new hearing was arranged during which Paul - being a Roman citizen - appealed to Caesar (Acts 25:11-12; 26:32). Afterwards Paul was sent to Rome where he finally arrived after a perilous journey and where according to the final report of Acts he remained prisoner for two years in relative freedom (around 61 to 63 AD; Acts 27 to 28).

J. N. DarbyChapter 3

Paul was a prisoner for having preached the gospel to the Gentiles — a circumstance that brought out his particular ministry very clearly. Thus ministry in the main is presented as in Colossians 1. Only in the latter epistle the whole subject is treated more briefly, and the essential principle and character of the mystery according to its place in the counsels of God is less explained, is viewed only on a special side of it, suited to the purpose of the epistle, that is, Christ and the Gentiles. Here the apostle assures us that he had received it by a special revelation, as he had already taught them in words which, though few, were suited to give a clear understanding of his knowledge of the mystery of Christ — a mystery never made known in the past ages, but now revealed by the Spirit to the apostles and prophets. Here it will be observed that the prophets are most evidently those of the New Testament, since the communications made to them are put in contrast with the degree of light granted in the previous ages. Now the mystery had been hidden in all former times; and in fact it needed so to be; for to have put the Gentiles on the same footing as the Jews would have been to demolish Judaism, such as God had Himself established it. In it He had carefully raised a middle wall of partition. The duty of the Jew was to respect this separation; he sinned, if he did not strictly observe it. The mystery set it aside. The Old Testament prophets, and Moses himself, had indeed shown that the Gentiles should one day rejoice with the people: but the people remained a separate people. That they should be co-heirs, and of the same body, all distinction being lost, had indeed been entirely hid in God (part of His eternal purpose before the world was), but formed no part of the history of the world, nor of the ways of God respecting it, nor of the revealed promises of God.

Leslie M. GrantComments On The Epistle To The Ephesians

"For this cause" -- because of the marvelous greatness of the work God had accomplished for and in His saints -- Paul preached "the unsearchable riches of Christ" (v.8). He was the prisoner, not of Rome, but of Jesus Christ. Men sought to confine him and his ministry, but the Lord Jesus used even his imprisonment for good . Thus he was a prisoner "for you Gentiles," for it was Jewish antagonism against his going to the Gentiles that led to his imprisonment.

Hamilton SmithEphesians

It was, then, the carrying out of this special service, which proclaimed the Gospel of the grace of God to the Gentiles, that raised the malice of the prejudiced Jew and brought the Apostle into prison. In the estimation of the Jew, a man who could talk of going to the Gentiles was not fit to live (Acts 22:21-22). Paul, however, did not view himself as a prisoner of men for any wrong-doing, but as a prisoner of Jesus Christ because of his service of love in making known the truth to the Gentiles.

Arend RemmersThe Epistles of the Apostle Paul

Paul in these letters writes of himself as being a prisoner for Christ's sake. The reason for his imprisonment was the fact that he had preached the gospel of the grace of God in Christ to the nations (heathens). According to this world-wide gospel both the former nations and the hitherto people of God (the Jews) are lost sinners. But by faith in the gospel they both possess the same privileges as children of God and members of the one body of Christ (which is the assembly of the living God) through Christ Jesus.

The New Testament does not contain any further indications regarding the life of the apostle Paul than what is said in the Pastoral Epistles. The end of Acts however would indicate that Paul has been released after two years of imprisonment in Rome. Afterwards he wrote the First Epistle to Timothy in 63/64 AD and the Epistle to Titus wherein he does not mention anything regarding imprisonment but instead mentions various places to travel to. He visited the assembly in Ephesus where he left Timothy behind (1 Tim. 1:3). He himself went on to Macedonia. During this time he told Titus, who was another co-worker, that he had the intention to winter in Nicopolis (Titus 3:12). He once again visited Troas and maybe Ephesus as well (2 Tim. 4:12; 1 Tim. 3:14). From there he went to Milet and Corinth (2 Tim. 4:20) and was taken captive a second time. We do not know much about this though. He was brought to Rome again and condemned to death. It was from there that he wrote his last inspired testimony which was the Second Epistle to Timothy (autumn 66/67 AD). He was deserted by many but strengthened by his Lord.

Church HistoryChurch History

Along the Appian Road most probably, Paul and his company travelled to Rome. On their arrival, "the centurion delivered the prisoners to the captain of the guard: but Paul was suffered to dwell by himself with a soldier that kept him." Though he was not released from the constant annoyance of being chained to a soldier, every indulgence compatible with his position was allowed him.

Paul was now privileged "to preach the gospel to them that were at Rome also;" and proceeded without delay to act upon his divine rule — "to the Jew first." He sends for the chief of the Jews and explains to them his true position. He assures them that he had committed no offence against his nation, or the customs of the fathers, but that he was brought to Rome to answer certain charges made against him by the Jews in Palestine: and so unfounded were the charges, that even the Roman Governor was ready to set him free, but the Jews opposed his liberty. In fact it was, as he said, "for the hope of Israel I am bound with this chain." His only crime has been his firm faith in the promises of God to Israel through the Messiah.

Leslie M. GrantCommentary on the book of Acts

Word of the coming of Paul and company had reached the brethren at Rome, who came out perhaps 30 miles to meet them, an encouragement for which Paul thanked God. Coming to Rome, the centurion allowed Paul to live outside the prison, but in the custody of a soldier, though the rest of the prisoners were committed to prison. Paul was no mere usual prisoner, as their so trusting him indicated. But the soldier was virtually a captive audience for the gospel!

Having been there only three days Paul was able to call the Jewish leaders to visit him, and explained to them the circumstances of his arrest and imprisonment. He declares his innocence as regards any infraction of Israel's law, but that the Jews of Jerusalem had delivered him to the Romans as a prisoner. The Romans, after due examination, found no charge that could be substantiated, so were inclined to release him, but the Jews being opposed, Paul had appealed to Caesar. He adds, "not that I had ought to accuse my nation of." He might have accused them of their attempt to murder him in Jerusalem, but he made no issue of this. Now, he says, he desires to speak with them in Rome because it was actually on account of the true hope of Israel that he was a prisoner.

Morrish Bible DictionaryBible Dictionary P

Paul arrived at Jerusalem just before Pentecost. In order to prove himself a good Jew he was advised by the brethren to associate himself with four men who had a vow on them, and to be at charges with them. But while carrying this out he was seized by some Asiatic Jews, and beaten, but was rescued by Lysias, the Roman chief captain. After appearing before the council, and again being rescued by him, he was for safety sent off by night to Caesarea. There his cause was heard by Felix, who kept him prisoner, hoping to be bribed to release him. Two years later, when superseded by Festus, Felix, to please the Jews, left Paul in bonds. On appearing before Festus, to save himself from being sent to Jerusalem, there being a plot to waylay and murder him, Paul appealed to the emperor. His case having been heard by Agrippa and Festus, he was finally remitted to Rome. The ship, however, was wrecked at Malta, where they wintered, all on board having been saved.

On his arrival at Rome, Paul sent for the chief men of the Jews and preached to them: some of them believed, though the majority rejected God's grace (thus fulfilling Isa. 6:9-10), which should henceforth go to the Gentiles. He, though still a prisoner, abode two years in his own hired house. There he wrote the EPISTLES TO THE COLOSSIANS, the EPHESIANS, the PHILIPPIANS, and also to PHILEMON.

C. E. StuartTracings From The Acts of the Apostles

David never entered the battle with Achish. Paul never approached the brazen altar with his sin-offering. For when the days were almost ended, Jews from Asia, when they saw him in the Temple, stirred up all the people, and laid hands on him. The man who taught all men everywhere against the people, and the law, and that place was actually in the very courts of the sanctuary, and, as they supposed, had polluted the holy place, by introducing Trophimus, an Ephesian, into the part that no Gentile could enter. In this supposition they were quite mistaken. Nevertheless, now commenced an uproar. The city was moved. People ran together, and, seizing hold of Paul, dragged him out of the Temple, intending to kill him outside its sacred precincts. But ere they could accomplish their purpose, the chief captain, with centurions and soldiers, ran down into the midst of the crowd. The appearance of the military saved Paul's life. The multitude left off beating him. The chief captain took him. He was a prisoner now in the hands of the Romans, and bound with two chains.

Morrish Bible DictionaryBible Dictionary E 2, F

One of the freedmen of the Emperor Claudius, and by him appointed to be procurator or governor of Judaea, A.D. 51. Paul, when sent a prisoner to Caesarea, appeared before Felix; and again before him and his wife Drusilla; and as Paul reasoned of righteousness, temperance and judgement to come, Felix trembled, and said when he had a convenient season he would send for him. He showed his mercenary and unrighteous character in keeping Paul a prisoner two years in the hope of being bribed; and then leaving him a prisoner to please the Jews. Acts 23:24, 26; Acts 24:3-27; Acts 25:14.

Verses

  • Acts 21:27–3327And when the seven days were nearly completed, the Jews from Asia, having seen him in the temple, set all the crowd in a tumult, and laid hands upon him, 28crying, Israelites, help! this is the man who teaches all everywhere against the people, and the law, and this place, and has brought Greeks too into the temple, and profaned this holy place. 29For they had before seen Trophimus the Ephesian with him in the city, whom they supposed that Paul had brought into the temple. 30And the whole city was moved, and there was a concourse of the people; and having laid hold on Paul they drew him out of the temple, and immediately the doors were shut. 31And as they were seeking to kill him, a representation came to the chiliarch of the band that the whole of Jerusalem was in a tumult; 32who, taking with him immediately soldiers and centurions, ran down upon them. But they, seeing the chiliarch and the soldiers, ceased beating Paul. 33Then the chiliarch came up and laid hold upon him, and commanded [him] to be bound with two chains, and inquired who he might be, and what he had done.
  • Acts 24:5–65For finding this man a pest, and moving sedition among all the Jews throughout the world, and a leader of the sect of the Nazaraeans; 6who also attempted to profane the temple; whom we also had seized, [and would have judged according to our law;