Why does God test us?
God does not run experiments to find out something He doesn't know. Scripture uses the language of testing for something else — a deliberate proving of what He Himself has planted in His people — and the writers below trace why He does it, what it costs, and what it yields.
Testing Is Not Enticement to Evil
The same Bible says that God tempts no one and that God tested Abraham. The difference lies in what the word means in each place.
J. T. Mawson"Let no man say when he is tempted, I am tempted by God: for God cannot be tempted with evil, neither does He tempt any man: but every man is tempted when he is drawn away by his own desires and enticed" (James 1:13-14). Yet we are also told in the same Scriptures that "God did tempt Abraham" when He told him to offer up Isaac (Gen. 22:1). This must have been some other kind of temptation than the one James speaks of; it was certainly not an enticement to do evil. It could not have been, for it is as impossible that God should tempt a man in that way as it is impossible for Him to lie. It was a testing of what was in Abraham; his faith was put into the crucible and came out of it, as we know, as gold tried by fire.
To Show Us Ourselves — and Him
Trouble exposes what comfort hides. It brings the working of sin in us into the light, and at the same time it shows us what God is toward us.
J. N. DarbyThe soul is tested by afflictions as to how far self-will is active; they make manifest the working of sin in us, that we may be able to detect it. God searches us. By this means we learn on the one hand what we are, and on the other what God is for us in His faithfulness and daily care. We are weaned from the world, and our eyes become better able to discern and appreciate what is heavenly.
The humbling has a destination. It is aimed at our good further down the road.
J. N. DarbyHe humbles us and proves us, that we may know what is in our heart — feeds us with the bread of faith; but it is to do us good in the end.
Because Faith Is Worth Refining
Refining is not punishment of the metal. It is the measure of its worth.
F. B. HoleWhy does that goldsmith take such pains and spend time over his crucible in which gold is being refined? Because it is such a valuable thing; he wants to remove the impurities and have it of the finest quality. God permits His people to be put into the crucible and tries them, even by fire, but it is because faith in His estimation is a thing of exceeding value... The fact of the matter is, if we Christians suffer no testings we shall never be anything but weaklings in a spiritual sense. It is the very testings that make us spiritually strong.
God Is Testing His Own Work
What comes out under pressure is not raw human grit but what God had already put there.
An Outline of Sound WordsIn times of trial God is testing His own work, so that His glory and our blessing might be secured. The obedience of faith that came out in Abraham, the endurance of faith that came out in Job, the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ that was ministered to Paul, the holiness of God and the peaceable fruits of righteousness that were to be produced in the Hebrews — all are results from the testing of God's own work in His saints.
Measured, and Never Beyond Us
Testing is limited by God's faithfulness, though the relief promised is often misread.
A. J. PollockNote, God does not promise a way of escape from the trial, but a way of escape in the trial for the deeply tried mind and heart, so that through this ministry of grace the trial may be borne to the glory of God.
The Overflow to Others
What we receive from God under pressure does not stop with us.
Arno C. GaebeleinTrials, afflictions, sorrows and sufferings make God a greater reality to the believer and display His gracious favour toward His beloved people... In all his distress and tribulation he had drawn near to God, and God had not failed him, but ministered to his need. The blessing and encouragement he had received from God fitted him to comfort those who are in trouble.
The Day the Question Is Answered
Not every "why" is answered now. One writer points to the moment it will be.
H. J. VineThe proving of our faith is much more precious. Gold is for present use, and fire purifies it. The trial of our faith yields for the future something that will not perish... In a coming day the full answer to one question — why these many trials? — will be displayed in glorious splendour. Not one pang will be regretted then. Not one sorrow will be repented of then. Not one tear or trial — passed for ever — will be considered useless then.
Summary
- Not tempted. God never entices anyone to evil; when He tests, He is proving what is in a person, as with Abraham.
- Not punished. Testing is refining, and gold goes into the crucible because it is valued — untested faith stays weak.
- Not guessed. The furnace shows us what we are and what God is in His daily care, humbling us for our good in the end.
- Not alone. God's faithfulness sets the limit, giving a way through the trial rather than around it, and what we receive there we hand on to others.
- Not wasted. Every pang finds its answer at the appearing of Jesus Christ; not one tear will be counted useless then.