Who can be saved?
Answered from the commentary of F. B. Hole, J. N. Darby, William Kelly and 18 others
As far as man is concerned, no one can be saved, but as far as God is concerned, anyone can, for "with men it is impossible, but not with God" (Mark 10:27). The authors stress that the word is not "difficult" but "impossible". The reason is that man is lost and there is no good in him. Whatever he has and trusts in, whether riches, morality or position, is only a hindrance. The poorest man is as exposed to this as the richest, since the danger lies in trusting in riches, not in having them. Salvation therefore rests wholly on the power of God's grace, "not of works, lest any man should boast". So the one who can be saved is anyone who owns that he cannot save himself and lets God save him. He believes on the Lord Jesus Christ, or calls on the name of the Lord, acknowledging Him as his only hope (Acts 16:31, Romans 10:13). In this there is "no difference" between Jew and Gentile, for all are alike under sin and grace is for all alike. No one is too bad to be saved. Paul, the chief of sinners, was saved as a pattern, so "there is not a sinner on earth that he cannot save" (1 Timothy 1:15-16). The dying thief shows that this is the normal way of salvation, not an exception. Yet salvation is through Jesus alone, for "there is none other name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved" (Acts 4:12).
On God's side the offer is to everyone, because He "will have all men to be saved" (1 Timothy 2:4). That word expresses His desire, not a decree. The invitation is "whosoever will" (Revelation 22:17), and no one can say the gospel was not for him. Not all will in fact be saved. Those who perish do so through their own will opposing the truth, not by God's will, and the authors deny that there is any reprobation in Scripture. Where they speak of election, they say it does not narrow the offer. It secures the blessing of those who would otherwise refuse it as the rest do. They reject outright the teaching that all will finally be restored. They hold that infants who die are saved through Christ's death, on the ground that "it is not the will of your Father … that one of these little ones should perish" (Matthew 18:14). The one sin never forgiven is blasphemy against the Holy Ghost, which is attributing the Spirit's power in Christ to the devil. They say plainly that anxious souls have not committed it. On the heathen who never heard the gospel, only a few speak, and cautiously. One says the heathen answer only for the light they had. Another asks whether God would not hear a heathen who bows to the testimony he has. A third says Scripture does not settle that every heathen perishes. Darby, however, insists that Scripture offers no salvation apart from the name of Jesus. All of them agree that those who hear the gospel and refuse it are more guilty than the heathen.
Verses: 1 Timothy 1:16, Matthew 18:14, Matthew 19:25, Matthew 19:26, Mark 10:26, Mark 10:27, Luke 18:26, Luke 18:27, John 3:16, John 3:17, John 3:18, Romans 10:9, Romans 10:10, Romans 10:11, Romans 10:12, Romans 10:13, Acts 2:21, Acts 16:30, Acts 16:31, 1 Timothy 2:3, 1 Timothy 2:4, 1 Timothy 2:5, 1 Timothy 2:6, 2 Peter 3:9, Ephesians 2:8, Ephesians 2:9, John 1:12, Acts 4:12, John 14:6, Romans 3:22, Romans 3:23, Romans 3:24, Titus 2:11, Revelation 22:17, Isaiah 45:22, Joel 2:32, Luke 19:10, 1 Timothy 1:15, Romans 1:16, Galatians 3:28, Acts 10:34, Acts 10:35, Acts 10:43, John 6:37, John 6:40, Matthew 11:28, Hebrews 7:25, Luke 23:42, Luke 23:43, Mark 16:16, Acts 2:38, Acts 2:39, Romans 5:8, 1 John 2:2, Ezekiel 33:11, Matthew 18:3, John 3:3, Romans 10:17, Titus 3:5
The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.
What the commentators say
The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.
The disciples, accustomed to regard riches as a sign of God's favour, were very astonished at these words; they felt that they cut the ground away completely from under our feet. So, indeed, they do. "Who then can be saved?" is a momentous question. Verse 27 gives a definite answer. Salvation is impossible with men, though possible with God. In other words it was as though the Lord said, "If it is a question of what man can do, nobody can be saved: but if a question of what God can do, anybody can be saved."
We emphasize that word. Salvation with men is not improbable, but IMPOSSIBLE. The door, as regards our own efforts is barred against us. God has opened another door however, but that is by death and resurrection, to which the Lord was now turning the thoughts of His disciples.
(Vv. 23-27). Knowing the effect of His words upon the disciples, the Lord, as He looks upon them, presses home the lesson we are to learn from this young man, by saying, "How hardly shall they that have riches enter into the kingdom of God!" These words were an astonishment to the disciples, who, with their Jewish thoughts of earthly blessing looked upon riches and possessions as a mark of God's favour. Moreover the thought in their heart, as with ourselves too often, was possibly, if only we had riches how much good we might be able to do. To meet these difficulties the Lord shows that the great danger of riches lies in the fact that men think they can secure salvation and the blessings of the Kingdom by means of riches, and thus put their trust in riches. Let us note that the Lord does not speak of a literally rich man, but of one that trusts in riches. This is a danger to which the poorest in actual possessions is exposed equally with the one who possesses most. The Lord uses a figure to show how difficult it is for a rich man to enter the Kingdom of God. With astonishment the disciples ask, "Who then can be saved?" In reply the Lord tells us, "With men it is impossible, but not with God." Their question would indicate that the thought lingered in their minds that in some measure at least their salvation depended upon themselves. They had to learn, as we all have to learn, that our salvation is wholly the work of God, and not of man at all. Neither law nor nature, riches or poverty have any part in the saving of the soul. Salvation rests wholly in the power of God's grace, and what is impossible for man is possible with God. Thus we read, "By grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: not of works, lest any man should boast." (Eph. 2:4-9).
Next, our Lord applies the same principle to the disciples; for now He has done with the outward question. We have seen nature in its best estate seeking Christ in a sense; and here is the result of it: after all the man is unhappy, and leaves Jesus, who now looks upon His disciples in their utter bewilderment, and enlarges on the hindrance of wealth in divine things. Alas! this they had thought to be an evidence of God's blessing. And if they were only rich, how much good might they not do! "How hardly," says Christ, "shall they that have riches enter the kingdom of God!" He further says to them, already astonished, "Children, how hard is it for them that trust in riches to enter into the kingdom of God. It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God." The Lord insists only the more solemnly on this lesson, so little understood even by disciples. They, beyond measure surprised, say among themselves, "Who, then, can be saved?" which gives the Lord the opportunity to explain what lies at the bottom of the whole question; that salvation is a question of God, and not of man at all. Law, nature, riches, poverty — no matter what, that man loves or fears — has nothing in the least to do with the saving of the soul, which rests entirely on the power of God's grace, and nothing else: what is impossible for man is possible with God. All turns, therefore, on His grace. Salvation is of the Lord. Blessed be His name! with God all things are possible: otherwise how could we, how could any, be saved?
Nor does this apply only to Israel. “For God so loved the world.” This love is so marvelous that the beloved, only begotten Son of the Father was given by Him as a sacrifice for the sake of the whole world. Yet its value cannot be known by anyone who does not believe in Him: this applies only to “whoever believes on Him.” No-one (Jew or Gentile) is excluded except by his own unbelief. This is true as regards the kingdom of God: either one will be blessed in it by having eternal life, or he will perish in the tribulation, and for eternity. Of course it is also true as regards those who now have opportunity to receive Christ. Either they believe Him and have eternal life, or they shall perish eternally.
Again, in this view, the evangelist can proclaim the gospel without any reserve. He can boldly tell men — all men — Christ died concerning your sins. He can unhesitatingly say, God has been so glorified about your sins by Christ's death, that on the ground of it He is now offering you salvation and is beseeching you to come and take it. You cannot refuse on the plea that the provision for salvation is only sufficient for a limited number. Every man can be told that the provision is for him, and that if he refuses it he can never say he perished because salvation was not provided for him. It is a misrepresentation of the gospel of God to say God has provided salvation only for those who actually believe. God has put no limit to the number who can be saved. He has made provision for all. While all thus can be saved, none are saved except they repent and believe the gospel.
"For this [is] good and acceptable before our Saviour God, Who desireth that all men should be saved and come unto full knowledge (or, acknowledgment) of the truth" (vers. 3, 4). The spirit of the gospel the apostle would have to permeate the conduct as well as the heart of the saint. Activity in goodness becomes those who know our Saviour God, Whose own heart goes out in compassion toward all men, not alone surely in present mercies without number, but also that they might be saved. This however cannot be unless they come to the knowledge of the truth. Hence the gospel is sent out to all the creation. Here human weakness, if it be not worse, betrays itself. Those who believe in the large grace of God too often leave no room for His positive and living links of love with the elect, once children of wrath even as others. Those who are sure of the special nearness of God's family as often overlook what is patent here and elsewhere all over scripture — that love which Christ made known personally and proved triumphantly in His cross whereby it is free to flow out in testimony to all the world.
"Now is the Son of man glorified, and God is glorified in Him" (John 13:31). Now that His character as Judge of sin is vindicated in the expiatory death of His own Son, His love can freely go out to men on the express ground that they are ungodly, enemies, and powerless (Rom. 5:6-10). He is both able and willing to save the vilest, but not without acknowledgment of truth. Therefore He commands all men everywhere to repent and believe the gospel; also the saints, while walking as members of the one body of Christ, are called to walk in love toward all, and to testify the love that can save any by the faith of Christ. If men are lost, it is through their own will opposing the truth; it is not God's will, Who, desiring their salvation, gave His Son, and has now sent His own Spirit from heaven that the glad tidings might be thus declared to them in the power of God our Saviour.
It is here that election does come in; not to limit the provision, nor to restrict in any wise the grace that bids and welcomes all, but to secure the blessing of those who otherwise would refuse and forfeit it as the rest do. The grace to all is not narrowed by the "grace upon grace" to many. The universal offer means and is based on a universal provision, and a provision of exactly the same character for all alike, in which God testifies that He has "no pleasure in the death of him that dies," but "will have all men to be saved, and to come to the knowledge of the truth." It may be asked, as it has been asked, Of what avail is a provision for all which saves not one additional to the elect number? The answer which Scripture would give is, "What if some did not believe? shall their unbelief make the faith [or faithfulness] of God without effect? God forbid." The salvation of men is from God; the damnation of men is from themselves. This all the pleadings, warnings, offers of God affirm. And grace refused is still grace, and to be proclaimed to His praise.
The gospel of God's grace in Christ Jesus is offered in perfectly good faith to all mankind. Christ is "the propitiation for our (believers') sins, and not for ours only, but also for (the sins of) the whole world" (1 Jn. 2:2). As the propitiation, Christ is the one who has by His great sacrifice fully satisfied God in regard to the question of man's sins, and the value of that sacrifice is fully avaliable for all who will receive it: it is not limited in any way. Those who refuse it will have only themselves to blame for the judgment they fully deserve. lf they could not believe, it was because they would not. As we have before seen, man is fully responsible to God, and one must receive salvation in God's way or be lost.
On the other hand, election is God's prerogative: this is His perfect right. Election is according to His foreknowledge. With perfect knowledge of all the future He chose certain people in Christ before the world existed. Nothing was left unconsidered in this choice: it was right, it was wise, it was wonderfully gracious, as every believer must heartily agree.
"G. K." If memory serves us, we have, on a former occasion, referred to the question of the salvation of all who die in infancy. Here is our authority, "Take heed that ye despise not one of these little ones; for I say to you, that in heaven their angels do always behold the face of my Father which is in heaven. For the Son of man is come to save that which is lost." The body of the infant dies because of Adam's sin; the soul of the infant is saved by the death of Jesus.
The question of the heathen, who have ne’er been favoured with the message of the grace of God, will naturally arise in the mind of the reader. That they will never have to give account to God for the way in which they have treated a Gospel which they have never heard goes without saying. It is a principle of Scripture that where little has been given, little shall be required, but to whom much has been given, from him much shall be demanded (Luke 12:48). The heathen can only have to give account for the way in which they have treated whatever light they may have had given them of God. The difficulty which arises in the minds of men in connection with their accountability to God has its origin in the fact that in the heart of each lurks the latent desire to at all costs justify himself. It is natural to him as a sinner, and is a great proof of his fallen condition.
Verses
- 1 Timothy 1:15–1615Faithful [is] the word, and worthy of all acceptation, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners, of whom I am [the] first. 16But for this reason mercy was shewn me, that in me, [the] first, Jesus Christ might display the whole long-suffering, for a delineation of those about to believe on him to life eternal.
- Matthew 18:14So it is not the will of your Father who is in [the] heavens that one of these little ones should perish.
- Matthew 19:25–2625And when the disciples heard [it] they were exceedingly astonished, saying, Who then can be saved? 26But Jesus, looking on [them], said to them, With men this is impossible; but with God all things are possible.
- Mark 10:26–2726And they were exceedingly astonished, saying to one another, And who can be saved? 27But Jesus looking on them says, With men it is impossible, but not with God; for all things are possible with God.
- Luke 18:26–2726And those who heard it said, And who can be saved? 27But he said, The things that are impossible with men are possible with God.