Where is God now? Where is God when it hurts?
God in the Furnace
The question presses hardest in the darkest moments — when sorrow is real and relief is nowhere in sight. C.H. Mackintosh takes us straight to the furnace of Nebuchadnezzar in Daniel 3, where three men were cast in bound and a fourth was seen walking free among the flames:
C.H. MackintoshBut there was a deeper reality: God was there. This changed everything: it "changed the king's word," changed the furnace into a place of high and holy fellowship — changed Nebuchadnezzar's bondmen into God's freemen.
God was there! — there, in his power, to write contempt upon all man's opposition — there, in His deep and tender sympathy with His tried and faithful servants — there, in His matchless grace, to set the captives free.
And then Mackintosh poses the question that overturns every human instinct:
DISCIPLPAnd, my beloved reader, is it not worth passing through a fiery furnace to enjoy a little more of the presence of Christ, and the sympathy of His loving heart? Are not fetters, with Christ, better than jewels without Him? Is not a furnace where He is better than a palace where He is not? Nature says, "No!" Faith says, "Yes!"
Not the Day of His Power — the Day of His Sympathy
Mackintosh goes further still, pressing into why God does not simply remove the pain:
DISCIPLPIt is well to bear in mind that this is not the day of Christ's power; but it is the day of His sympathy. When passing through the deep waters of affliction, the heart may, at times, feel disposed to ask, 'Why does not the Lord display His power, and deliver me?' The answer is, This is not the day of His power. He could avert that sickness — He could remove that difficulty — He could take off that pressure — He could prevent that catastrophe — He could preserve that beloved and fondly-cherished object from the cold grasp of death. But, instead of putting forth His power to deliver, He allows things to run their course, and pours His own sweet sympathy into the oppressed and riven heart, in such a way as to elicit the acknowledgment that we would not, for worlds, have missed the trial, because of the abundance of the consolation.
He Heals the Brokenhearted
Hamilton Smith addresses those whose hearts are simply broken — by grief, by loss, by the weight of a world steeped in sorrow. He points to Psalm 147:
Hamilton SmithThe number of the stars is too great for us to tell; the sorrow of a broken heart too deep for us to fathom; but God can count the stars in heaven and heal the broken hearts on earth.
Smith then turns to the widow of Nain in Luke 7 — a mother burying her only son — and draws out the remarkable order of what Jesus did:
How beautiful is the way the Lord takes to heal her broken heart. Moved with compassion, He first dries her tears, and then removes the cause of her sorrow. Had we the power we should probably have first raised the dead, and then said to the woman, "Weep no more." But Jesus takes another way — a better way — that makes the story so full of comfort for us all. He first says to the brokenhearted mother, "Weep not," and then He raises the dead. Thus the woman would have been able to say, "In my great sorrow He came so near to me, that He wiped away my tears. He not only took me out of my sorrowful circumstances, but He walked beside me in them."
And then this:
"In my great sorrow He came so near to me, that He wiped away my tears. He not only took me out of my sorrowful circumstances, but He walked beside me in them."His compassions go before His mercies. We have the comfort of His love while we wait for the display of His resurrection power.
In All Their Affliction He Was Afflicted
William Kelly, writing on the Gospels, draws from Isaiah 63:9 and Isaiah 53:4 to show that Christ did not merely observe human suffering — He bore it on His own spirit:
William KellyThe very aim of that prophetic oracle was to announce that, before He suffered atoningly, He entered into all that troubled His people even in their bodies, and as we see in the Gospels from Satan's more immediate power. And this He did not in power only but in the tenderest bearing of the burden on His spirit, while He took it away; as it is said elsewhere by the same prophet, "In all their affliction He was afflicted."
The Shepherd in the Valley
H.H. Snell meditates on the unwearied faithfulness of Christ as Shepherd through every dark passage:
H.H. SnellHe will never fail nor forsake us; He leads in paths of righteousness for His name's sake, though it may be in the midst of paths of judgment; and all through the valley of the shadow of death we have nothing to fear: His rod and staff will comfort us. He knows how to feed and cheer us, and bless us with an overflowing cup in the presence of our enemies.
How sweet to think of the unwearied activities of this tender and gracious Shepherd, so patient with us, so forbearing, so pitiful and wise!
The Powerscourt address on Psalm 23 brings Isaiah 43:2 into view — the promise spoken not to people in comfort, but to people in fire and flood:
Powerscourt addressWe are in a world in which we know not what a day may bring forth; we may have to pass through rivers of tears, furnaces of temptation, or it may be only waters of perplexity and cares. Be it what it may, he says to the children, "Fear not, I am with thee: when thou passest through the waters, I will be with thee: and through the rivers, they shall not overflow thee; when thou walkest through the fire, thou shalt not be burnt, neither shall the flame kindle upon thee, for I am the Lord thy God, thy Saviour."
Strength Made Perfect in Weakness
Paul begged God three times to remove a painful thorn, and received instead something better. The Bible Treasury comments:
Bible TreasuryThere is something more blessed than the mere setting aside of the trial, and that is the power of divine grace which enters into it, and lifts us above it, the distress, it may be, continuing, the sorrow going on, the thorn not removed, but ourselves raised entirely above it.
And on 2 Corinthians 1, where Paul catalogues his afflictions:
"We are troubled on every side, yet not distressed; we are perplexed, but not in despair; persecuted, but not forsaken; cast down, but not destroyed." The poor vessel may be troubled, but not in despair, for God is there. It may be persecuted, but not forsaken, for God is there.
And this striking summary of why God permits suffering at all:
It may be persecuted, but not forsaken,He creates a void in order to fill it... We learn and prove this love in the wilderness, in a way we never can in heaven: our very need brings it out to us. This world is a terrible house to live in, but an excellent school to learn in.
Synthesis
The answer is twofold. First: God is there — in the furnace, in the valley, beside the brokenhearted widow, in the sleepless night. He has not withdrawn. Christ entered into every form of human suffering and did not merely observe it but bore it on His own spirit: "In all their affliction He was afflicted." Second: this is not the day of His power but the day of His sympathy. He does not always remove the pain — but He pours Himself into it, so that His people discover something richer than deliverance: His presence. The furnace becomes a place of fellowship. The valley of shadow becomes a path walked with the Shepherd. The thorn remains, but grace rises above it. And in the end, those who have known Him there would not trade the trial for anything, "because of the abundance of the consolation."