What makes a room or building a sanctuary?

Answered from the commentary of Arno Clemens Gaebelein, Edward Dennett, A. J. Pollock and 8 others

A room or building is not a sanctuary because of its stones, design, or being set apart as a sacred building; a sanctuary is made by the presence of God among His people. In the Christian gathering, it is the believers, built together as God’s habitation through the Spirit, and the Lord present among them, that give it this character. So the place itself is nothing; worship is spiritual, and the Christian’s place of worship is the presence of God. Where God dwells, holiness belongs to His house, and those gathered there must be suited to His presence. The authors differ on whether to call a meeting place a sanctuary: most plainly deny that any earthly building is one, while a smaller number use “sanctuary” for the gathered people or their meeting as God’s dwelling.

Verses: Exodus 25:8, Exodus 29:42

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

Morrish Bible DictionaryBible Dictionary S 1

This is 'holy [place],' and is applied in the O.T. both to the tabernacle and to the temple as a whole, and to the 'holy [place]' and 'most holy' in distinction from the other parts: "Thy way, O God, is in the sanctuary." Ps. 77:13. The sanctuary was where, in retirement from man and the world, God's glory was seen, and His mind apprehended; it was where the sacrifices were offered, and God was worshipped.

In the N.T. also the word sanctuary is applied to the holy and most holy parts of the tabernacle. Heb. 9:1-8; Heb. 10:19; Heb. 13:11. Here it is called 'worldly,' (κοσμικός) in reference possibly to its order, and its contrast to the true tabernacle which the Lord pitched, and not man. The word 'sanctuary' in Heb. 8:2 is literally holy (places or things); of these Christ is minister. The sanctuary for the Christian consists in the light of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ. God is revealed without a veil.

J. Wilson SmithGod’s Temple

The idea of a temple is a sacred edifice, a space “cut off” from others, where God may be worshipped, and from whence things secular, such as commerce, trade, etc., are excluded. With all this we are of course familiar by the ordinary usage of the day. The question is, does such custom comport with the Christian idea of a temple of God? Sincerity as to it cannot make the practice of it right, if indeed the word of God supply no sanction.

A. J. PollockGod’s Dwelling Place

But in the verses before us we have the Christians looked at as “an holy temple in the Lord” and “a habitation of God.” The figure is changed. This sets before us the great truth of God dwelling in the midst of His people on this earth. But not only does God dwell in this habitation, but the word temple carries the thought of a shrine, a dwelling place indeed, but connected with the thought of holiness, because of who it is that dwells. It is a sanctuary, a sphere of priestly activity, a place of worship—a place made by the persons who compose it, not by stones and mortar. “God … dwells not in temples made with hands” (Acts 17:24).

A. J. PollockEphesians 2:21

But in the verse before us we have the Christians looked at as “an holy temple in the Lord.” The figure is changed. This sets before us the great truth of God dwelling in the midst of His people on this earth. But not only does God dwell but the word temple carries the thought of a shrine, a dwelling place indeed, but connected with the thought of holiness, because of who it is that dwells. It becomes a sanctuary, a sphere of priestly activity, a place of worship—a place made by the persons who compose it, not by stones and mortar. “God … dwells not in temples made with hands” (Acts 17:24).

A. J. PollockAn Holy Temple in the Lord

But in the verse before us we have the Christians looked at as “an holy temple in the Lord.” The figure is changed. This sets before us the great truth of God dwelling in the midst of His people on this earth. But not only does God dwell but the word temple carries the thought of a shrine, a dwelling place indeed, but connected with the thought of holiness , because of who it is that dwells. It becomes a sanctuary, a sphere of priestly activity, a place of worship—a place made by the persons who compose it, not by stones and mortar. “God . . . dwelleth not in temples made with hands” (Acts 17:24).

VariousChrist and the Assembly

But in the verse before us we have the Christians looked at as "an holy temple in the Lord." The figure is changed. This sets before us the great truth of God dwelling in the midst of His people on this earth. But not only does God dwell but the word temple carries the thought of a shrine, a dwelling place indeed, but connected with the thought of holiness, because of who it is that dwells. It becomes a sanctuary, a sphere of priestly activity, a place of worship - a place made by the persons who compose it, not by stones and mortar. "God … dwelleth not in temples made with hands" (Acts 17:24).

A. J. PollockThe Tabernacle's Typical Teaching

Sanctuary, typical of God's dwelling place among His people, a Holy Place set apart for God's pleasure. "Let them make me a Sanctuary; that I may dwell among them" (Ex. 25:8).

The Bible TreasuryScripture Imagery

1890 47 "Let them make me a sanctuary that I may dwell among them:" (Ex. 25:8, etc.) the primary principle of worship was enunciated in that word "sanctuary." The dignity and majesty of God is of such nature that no worship can be acceptable that is not holy; and, as there was no word in human language that would convey the true meaning of this, it has to be conveyed by physical types, ordinances and emblems.

Scripture QuarterlyArticles by T. Oliver

In Ex. 25:8, the further thought is conveyed in the words:—"let them make Me a sanctuary that I may dwell among them." Then a minute description is given of the golden vessels to be placed therein. The constitution of the tabernacle is described in Exodus 26:1-6, as being formed of a curtain of various significant colours. There are various other curtains and structures, but these are all subsidiary to the first mentioned curtain. The Tabernacle contained the Sanctuary, thus the former term was more comprehensive than the latter which was descriptive of the inmost shrine, where God's presence and majesty were displayed. That distinction was confirmed in the New Testament in Hebrews 9:2-3. Obviously the sanctuary was where God could derive pleasure from having His people dwelling with Himself, consistent with the display of His own attributes. He could not satisfy the desire apart from being consistent with His eternal characters of righteousness and holiness.

A. J. PollockLessons from the Tabernacle

Could anything be more wonderful—God desiring to dwell among His redeemed people? But if this be so, it must be a sanctuary—a holy dwelling place, suited to His own nature. It must be agreeable to Him.

Verses

  • Exodus 25:8And they shall make me a sanctuary, that I may dwell among them.
  • Exodus 29:42It shall be a continual burnt-offering throughout your generations at the entrance of the tent of meeting before Jehovah, where I will meet with you, to speak there with thee.