True Bible Answers

What is the significance of Jesus eating with sinners?

The Gospels record a striking and repeated charge levelled against Jesus by the religious leaders of His day: He ate with sinners. Far from being incidental, this was one of the central controversies of His earthly ministry — and one that reveals the very heart of His mission.

The Charge and Its Repetition

J.T. Mawson traces the fourfold accusation as it builds across Luke's Gospel — the Gospel of grace:

In chapter 5:30 they murmured against His disciples, saying, "Why do ye eat and drink with publicans and sinners?"

In chapter 7:34 they grow abusive and say, "Behold a gluttonous man, and a wine-bibber, a friend of publicans and sinners."

In chapter 15:2 they say with bitter enmity, "This man receives sinners and eats with them."

And again in chapter 19:7 "they all murmured, saying, That He was gone to be guest with a man that is a sinner."

J.T. Mawson

Mawson then makes this piercing observation:

They spoke the truth in their hatred, and that which they thought was His shame was His glory, as a countless host of sinners saved by grace will declare in His eternal praise.

Why He Came: Grace, Not Self-Righteousness

In his second address on this theme, Mawson explains what lay behind the Pharisees' indignation — and what it reveals about the nature of God's grace:

The self-righteous religionist always did and always will murmur against the grace of God, but what folly is this, for where should the doctor be but among the folk that are sick, and where should the great Saviour be but among sinners. It was for this He came — to call sinners to repentance. We are glad that His foes called Him "the Friend of sinners"; they gave Him a name that shines out with an imperishable lustre and countless multitudes will rejoice in the glory of God for ever because He befriended every individual soul of them, when apart from Him they were hopeless and lost.

He draws out how the Pharisee's disdain actually placed Jesus within reach of the sinner — the woman weeping at His feet in Simon's house:

There were two great powers conspiring together that day to bring her into the place of blessing; her great need was driving her and His great love was drawing her, and between the driving power of her need and the drawing power of His love she was forced into the most blessed place in the universe of God, at the feet of Jesus.

Not a Doctor for the Well, but for the Sick

Frank Hole, commenting on Matthew 9 and the feast in Matthew's house:

It was in his house that Jesus sat at meat with publicans and sinners and His disciples; so now he was disbursing money instead of receiving it. The whole proceeding outraged the Pharisees, but this gave occasion for the concise statement as to His mission. The Pharisees had overlooked the word of the Lord through Hosea, that He preferred the exercise of mercy to the offering of ceremonial sacrifices — a word which many a modern Pharisee overlooks — and they were ignorant of His mission to the spiritually sick, in calling sinners to repentance. Had He come to call "the righteous," the Pharisees no doubt would have come forward in crowds; only to be rejected to a man, since "the righteous" according to the Divine standard do not exist.

Frank Hole

The Revelation of Jehovah in Grace

J.N. Darby, in his Synopsis on Matthew 9, sees in this eating with sinners nothing less than the presence of Jehovah Himself — come not to find righteousness, but to bring grace:

The pardon then was there, and grace toward sinners. He was there in this character. He goes and eats with the tax-gatherers after having called Matthew who was one of them. It was not the outside which guided His walk. God was there, and the work was to be the effect of His presence and of His grace, not to depend on what He found.

Therefore He is there forgiving sins and eating with sinners; but it is Jehovah who heals (Psalm 103). The revelation as to the work goes farther. It could not be put into the old Jewish forms, nor could one take what was found in them as vessels containing it. A tax-gatherer was to be an apostle; a Pharisee at most to learn that he must absolutely be born anew.

J.N. Darby

Wisdom Justified of Her Children

C.H. Mackintosh highlights the contrast between John the Baptist and Jesus — and the refusal of that generation to accept either:

The stern and distant minister of righteousness, with the axe of judgement in his hand, and the lowly, gentle Minister of divine grace, with words of tenderness and acts of goodness, were alike rejected by the men of that generation. But wisdom's children will ever justify her, in all her doings and in all her sayings. The Lord be praised for this rich mercy! What a privilege to be of the favoured number of wisdom's children! To have an eye to see, an ear to hear, and a heart to understand and appreciate the ways and works and words of divine Wisdom!

C.H. Mackintosh

The Shepherd Seeking the Sheep

H.J. Vine, preaching on Luke 15, shows that the Pharisees' complaint was the very occasion for Christ to reveal the heart of the triune God:

In answer to their taunt when they said, "This Man receiveth sinners and eateth with them," the Son of God spake this parable to show that God Himself not only received sinners, but that He actually and diligently sought them, that they might be found, saved and brought home to Himself with rejoicing. This is the chapter of divine merrymaking over the returning one.

The three parts of this one "parable" in Luke 15, tell the wonderful story of the great joy of God the Son, God the Holy Ghost, and God the Father over the repentance and home-coming of "one" wanderer.

H.J. Vine

"I Will Have Mercy, and Not Sacrifice"

William Kelly, commenting on Matthew's parables, underscores the Lord's own answer:

Did any wonder at the Lord eating with sinners and the disreputable? His answer was, They that are strong have no need of a physician, but those that are sick. But go and learn what that is, I will have mercy, and not sacrifice; for I came to call not righteous but sinners.

William Kelly

Synthesis

The significance of Jesus eating with sinners goes far deeper than social unconventionality. In the ancient world, to share a meal was to extend fellowship — an act of intimate acceptance. The Pharisees understood this perfectly, which is why they were outraged. Jesus was not merely tolerating sinners; He was receiving them at His table, and in doing so, He was enacting the very grace of God.

What the religious leaders intended as an insult — "a friend of publicans and sinners" — turned out to be one of the most glorious titles ever spoken of Christ. It revealed that God had not come to congratulate the righteous but to heal the sick, not to find worthiness but to bring grace where there was none. As Darby put it, "It was not the outside which guided His walk. God was there, and the work was to be the effect of His presence and of His grace, not to depend on what He found."

The three parables of Luke 15 — the lost sheep, the lost coin, the lost son — were spoken precisely in answer to this charge. They reveal that heaven itself rejoices when a sinner repents, and that the Father, Son, and Spirit are all actively seeking the lost. The Pharisee who stands aloof, certain of his own goodness, is the one truly in danger — while the broken sinner at the feet of Jesus finds, as Mawson put it, "the most blessed place in the universe of God."