What is the second heaven?

Answered from the commentary of C. Crain, Morrish Bible Dictionary, A. J. Pollock and 6 others

The second heaven is the starry heaven: the vast expanse beyond the air we breathe, where the sun, moon and stars are set. The authors reach it by counting backward from the "third heaven" of 2 Corinthians 12:2, which implies a first and a second. They reckon three: first the atmospheric heaven of clouds, winds and birds; then the stellar heavens; then the third heaven, the dwelling place and throne of God. This was a reckoning the Jews would understand. It is not merely a Jewish idea but of God, because the New Testament speaks of Paul being caught up into the third heaven. The second heaven is therefore the "heaven of the stars, planets, and other astronomical objects", or "the astronomical heaven". It is "the firmament or wide expanse in which are seen the sun, moon, and stars" (Genesis 1:14-17). Unlike the first, it is a region where "it is impossible for men to live", spaces where the atmosphere is so thin that human life cannot exist.

Like the first heaven, it is a physical and created heaven. It is therefore quite different from the third, which belongs to God and is not one of the two physical heavens. Some find both created heavens in Genesis 1:1, where the word "heaven" is dual: the atmospheric heaven and the stellar heavens. On this reading the third heaven is not among the things created there, and "the heaven" of that verse is what we would call the stellar heavens. Several authors also see the three heavens figured in the tabernacle. The court answers to the first heaven, the holy place to the second, and the holiest to the third, where God dwells. So the priest passed through the first and second into the third, the scene of God's special presence. In the same way Christ, having "passed through the heavens" (Hebrews 4:14), did not stop in the first heaven or in the second but went into the third and highest. He has indeed "ascended up far above all heavens" (Ephesians 4:10), beyond the created sphere into the presence of God Himself.

Verses: Genesis 1:1, 2 Corinthians 12:2, 2 Corinthians 12:3, 2 Corinthians 12:4, Genesis 1:14, Genesis 1:15, Genesis 1:16, Genesis 1:17, Deuteronomy 10:14, 1 Kings 8:27, Nehemiah 9:6, Psalms 148:3, Psalms 148:4, Deuteronomy 4:19, Genesis 1:6, Genesis 1:7, Genesis 1:8, Genesis 1:20, Psalms 19:1, Psalms 19:2, Psalms 19:3, Psalms 19:4, Psalms 19:5, Psalms 19:6, Genesis 15:5, Isaiah 13:10, Matthew 24:29, Ephesians 6:12, Ephesians 2:2, Isaiah 14:13, Psalms 8:3, Jeremiah 8:2, Ephesians 4:10, Hebrews 4:14

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

A. J. PollockEventide—Eothen

But there is another description in Scripture of a positive nature. For fourteen years the Apostle Paul kept the secret of his having been translated to the third heaven. The first heaven, the atmospheric heaven, is that which belongs to this earth in which men can breathe and live; the second heaven, the vast expanse beyond the atmospheric heaven, the stellar heaven, where it is impossible for men to live; the third heaven, the dwelling place of God. A messenger of Satan to buffet Paul, to humiliate him, was given in the goodness of God to keep his flesh from being puffed up.

A. J. PollockBodily Exercise and Godliness

A positive description of such a scene is found in what the Apostle tells us in 2 Corinthians 12, of how he was caught up to the third heaven. The first heaven refers to the atmospheric heavens the home of clouds and winds; the second heaven is the stellar region, where there are hundreds of millions of stars; the third heaven is the dwelling place of God.

A. J. PollockGenesis 1 and 2

It is worthy of note that the word, Heaven, in Genesis 1:1, in the Hebrew original is in the dual number. Who told Moses to write it thus? What did he know of the atmospheric heaven where life can exist, where the birds fly and the clouds form; of the stellar heaven, those vast spaces where the atmosphere is so rarified that human life cannot exist? Do we not see the hallmark of inspiration here?

It is interesting to note that the Apostle Paul was caught up to the third Heaven (2 Cor. 12:2). The Jews would understand this. The first, the atmospheric heaven; the second, the vast stellar spaces; the third Heaven, the dwelling place of God.

C. Crain2 Corinthians 12:1-6

We read in this passage of a “third heaven” into which this man was taken. But can we know, or have some right comprehension of what the third heaven is? By this I do not mean the blessedness of heaven; that, surely, we may regard as impossible. But can we form a satisfactory idea of what the third heaven is in contrast with the first and second heaven? In the first chapter of Genesis we have at least a conception of two heavens. We find there a heaven as the sphere of the clouds, and of the birds of heaven.” Then we find a heaven of the stars; in these, no doubt, we have the first and the second heavens. The sphere of the birds and of the clouds is clearly a physical and created heaven; and so likewise is the second heaven — the heaven of the stars.

William KellyThe Creation

How comes this? It is another difficulty at first sight. Did we not hear of heaven in the first verse? To be sure we did; and here we are told of heaven again. What then — contradiction? Not in the least degree; only another heaven — that is all. And is this, then, not true? Why this other heaven? Because man was about to be made. The circumambient atmosphere, extending upwards too, was essential not only to man's existence here below, but to vegetable life, to the due activity of light and heat, as well as to all forms of animated existence.

We find under the second day, then, the lower heaven. And that this is not a merely Jewish idea, but of God, is perfectly certain from the New Testament; for there we read how Paul was caught up (at any rate "a man in Christ," who, I have no doubt, was Paul) into the third heaven. We can easily understand, therefore, that at the beginning God made two heavens, and that in this case He made the lowest one. "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth." Here we find He made another, man being about to be made. And this is called heaven too. They are all called the heavens. There is the heaven of His presence; the heaven of the stars, planets, and other astronomical objects; and the atmospheric heaven necessary for man and living things here below.

F. B. HoleHebrews

In verse 14 we have the greatness of our High Priest emphasized, both as to His position and His Person. He has passed into (or, more accurately, through) the heavens. He did not stop in the first heaven nor in the second heaven when on His upward way, but into the third and highest heaven He went. Indeed, as another Scripture puts it, He "ascended up far above all heavens" (Eph. 4:10). Still, the position of our High Priest is expressed here in this way so that Jewish readers might be reminded of Aaron going into the holiest of all. In the tabernacle the court, in which stood the altar of burnt sacrifice, was typical of the first heaven. The holy place typified the second heaven, and the holiest the third heaven in which God dwells. In entering the holiest Aaron passed through the heavens as far as the type was concerned. Our blessed Saviour and High Priest has passed through the heavens, not in type but in glorious reality. He is now in a place of infinite greatness and glory.

Hamilton Smith2 Corinthians

(Vv. 1-6.) Thus he passes on to speak of "visions and revelations of the Lord." He recounts a remarkable experience he had enjoyed 14 years previously. The carnally-minded Christian would doubtless at once, and again and again, have boasted of such an experience. But the Apostle, realising that it is not expedient to boast, had refrained from any allusion to this experience for fourteen years. He has just told us of a humiliating experience as in the body; now he tells us of a wonderful experience that had been his as "a man in Christ." The one who had known what it was to be "let down" in a basket upon earth, had experienced also the immense privilege of being "caught up to the third heaven." The third heaven speaks of the dwelling-place of God. There are the atmospheric heavens, then the starry heavens, and then the third heavens wherein is the throne of God. The Apostle speaks of the third heavens as paradise, indicating the blessedness of the third heavens as a scene of joy, and beauty, and glory — a garden of delights, where no shadow of death will ever come. He is careful to tell us that it was not as a man in the flesh that he was caught up, but as "a man in Christ." Of his natural advantages as a man in the flesh, he tells us, in another epistle, that he counts them but filth: but of position and privileges as a man in Christ he can rightly glory, for all the blessings of our place in Christ we owe to Christ. Caught up into paradise he was no longer conscious of the body, with its needs and weaknesses. There he had heard things of which it would be wholly out of place to speak, even to Christians while on earth and in these mortal bodies. Nevertheless, let us remember that though we have no such miraculous experiences, as being caught up into the third heavens, yet all that was revealed to the Apostle, when caught up, belongs to the simplest believer as being "in Christ."

Samuel RidoutLecture 4

But here is a great high priest who entered in where? Not into sanctuaries made with hands, but into heaven itself, and He has passed through the heavens. The heaven of the atmosphere above us, in which the birds fly and the clouds of heaven float, is what we may call the first heaven. Above that is the starry heaven, the firmament which showeth His handiwork; but far as eye can reach, as far as telescope can discover the most distant heavenly bodies, beyond even the reach of our thoughts, our great High Priest has passed through all the outer courts into the very presence, into the very sanctuary of God, where the throne of God itself is. "Now that He ascended, what is it but that He also descended first into the lower parts of the earth? He that descended is the same also that ascended up far above all heavens, that He might fill all things" (Eph. 4:9-10).

Leslie M. GrantComments on Second Corinthians

If in chapter 11 we have seen God's grace in sustaining the vessel through all adversity, Paul now speaks of the other side of this, the grace which gives unspeakable blessedness in being "caught up" above all earthly things and occupations. He speaks of this as "visions and revelations of the Lord." It is not that he is basing any Christian teaching whatever upon this experience, but rather indicating thereby that such things may be in measure known to anyone who is "in Christ." Verse 2 is rightly translated, "I know a man in Christ." It is manifestly he himself of whom Paul speaks (as verse 7 proves); and he does not write of this until fourteen years after it happened, for it did not involve anything that, as an apostle, he was bound to communicate. The experience was simply that of "a man in Christ," and written now no doubt as an encouragement to all who are "in Christ," not as a revelation to others of the will of God. But the occasion was so sublimely that of spiritual blessedness, that he was not at all conscious of whether or not his body was present with him. This is repeated in verse 3, no doubt to press home the fact that this was something above and outside of the flesh. First it is said he was caught up to the third heaven; and this is further described in verse 4 as "paradise." This is one of three times that paradise is mentioned in the New Testament, and each indicates the presence of God, the meaning being "a garden of delights." If the first heaven is that of earth's atmosphere, and the second the astronomical heaven, then the third is higher than human intellect reaches, indescribable therefore by material comparisons.

J. N. Darby2 Corinthians

356 The third heaven here is in a different character from paradise. The third heaven is going on high - a degree of exaltation; paradise is rather the character of the thing. Our Lord went to paradise, but paradise is the character. The word "paradise" means nothing but a Persian garden; there they had beautiful gardens. The third heaven is hardly the heaven of heavens. There are the sky, the created heavens, the starry heavens, and then the heaven where the throne of God is placed, though this again is a figure no doubt. "Heaven itself" in Hebrews 9 means the reality, and not the figure. We see the same thing in Ezekiel, where he saw the covering of the cherubim and above that the throne of God or the figure of it. These have not exactly to be atoned for; but wherever any creature has been, it has to be cleansed.

Verses

  • Genesis 1:1In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.
  • 2 Corinthians 12:2–42I know a man in Christ, fourteen years ago, (whether in [the] body I know not, or out of the body I know not, God knows;) such [a one] caught up to [the] third heaven. 3And I know such a man, (whether in [the] body or out of the body I know not, God knows;) 4that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable things said which it is not allowed to man to utter.
  • Genesis 1:14–1714And God said, Let there be lights in the expanse of the heavens, to divide between the day and the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, and for days and years; 15and let them be for lights in the expanse of the heavens, to give light on the earth. And it was so. 16And God made the two great lights, the great light to rule the day, and the small light to rule the night, — and the stars. 17And God set them in the expanse of the heavens, to give light on the earth,