What is the immaculate conception?

Answered from the commentary of A. J. Pollock, Fritz Ridenour, Arno Clemens Gaebelein and 4 others

The immaculate conception is the Roman Catholic dogma that Mary was conceived or born without original sin, the sinful nature common to Adam’s race, and was without sin. These passages reject that dogma: they say Mary was a sinner who needed God as her Saviour. They distinguish this from the miraculous conception of Jesus: by the power of the Holy Spirit, He was born of Mary holy and without sin.

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

A. J. PollockIs Roman Catholicism of God?

THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION

It is a dogma of the Church of Rome that the Virgin Mary was miraculously born without a taint of sin, that original sin, the sinful nature common to all of Adam’s race, was entirely wanting in her by an act of Divine grace, that her humanity was as pure and sinless as that of her Divine Son.

A. J. PollockMary—“Blessed … Among Women”

We turn now to the side of the Ritualist. The Virgin Mary was born with a sinful nature. That she was the subject of the gracious work of the Spirit of God in her soul, there is no doubt. She was indeed a saint and a prepared vessel for this great honour put upon her. Her outburst of praise to God—a veritable mosaic of Old Testament quotations, proving her intimate knowledge of Scripture, in the presence of Elizabeth, the expectant mother of the forerunner of the Messiah, John, the Baptist, is a beautiful testimony to us.

She exclaims, “My spirit has rejoiced in God MY Saviour” (Luke 1:47). Like all who are taught of God she recognised her sinful estate and that she needed a Saviour, and had found One in God Himself. How can such a dogma as the immaculate conception, viz: that the Virgin Mary was born sinless, be promulgated in the face of her own confession of sinnership in the finding of God as Saviour?

C. E. StuartLeviticus

The spiritual teaching of this for us we have already referred to. But this chapter is especially important in these days, for it gives the lie to one of the latest authorised dogmas of the Church of Rome — the immaculate conception of the blessed Virgin Mary. Blessed she is, but immaculate was the Virgin at no time of her life, and the ordinance appointed in this chapter (12), to which the Evangelist Luke tells us she conformed, plainly proves it. Unclean according to the law for seven days after the birth of her son, she came at the expiration of the appointed forty days with two birds, the one for a burnt-offering, and the other for a sin-offering; and the priest, whoever he was, offered them to make atonement for her. The offerings she brought — two birds — attested her poverty on the one hand, and her condition as a sinful creature on the other. The low estate of David's royal house, and direct line told a tale of the failure, great and grievous, of his offspring, who had once sat on his throne. Her burnt-offering and sin-offering spoke clearly of her condition as a child of Adam, but also of God's grace, which could meet it by sacrifice. Her immaculate conception! How would she have recoiled at the bare idea of it! Mercy, favour too, unsought and undreamt of, she frankly and fully owned. But to the figment of her conception without a stain her offerings unmistakeably give the lie. What a position was hers that day. Her need of atonement by blood she confessed, as she stood before that altar and witnessed the death of the birds, but the occasion which thus called it forth was the birth of Him, by whom that atonement was to be really, fully, and finally accomplished. He was perfectly holy, and this law said nothing about the child. She was unclean as a mother, and nothing but blood-shedding could atone for her.

A. J. PollockThe Fundamentals of the Christian Faith

Modernists have sought to assail this great fact, and assert that it matters little if our Lord had a sinful father as well as mother. The Roman Catholics, on the other hand, believing in the Virgin Birth, have added an article of faith to their creed, viz., that of the Immaculate Conception. By this the Roman Catholic Church teaches that the Virgin herself was sinlessly conceived, a pure assumption, and without any support from Scripture.

Mary, the mother of our Lord according to the flesh, “blessed among women” surely, chosen for the highest honour possible in a woman, in her Magnificat says, “My spirit has rejoiced in God MY SAVIOUR” (Luke 1:47). Now, if Mary had been sinless she had no need of a Saviour, for surely need of a Saviour she had, like the rest of us.

A. J. PollockIs Roman Catholicism of God?

Now if the Virgin, “blessed among women,” had a Saviour, she must have needed a Saviour. And if she needed a Saviour, she must have been a sinner, like every member of the fallen human race.

To be consistent, if Romanists believe the Virgin was sinless, then death could not have been her portion, for “the wages of sin is death.” So they claim that she miraculously ascended to Heaven without dying on the 15th August, A.D. 45. There is not a single line of Scripture for the dogma of the Immaculate Conception, nor for her translation to Heaven without dying.

W. H. WestcottGod Speaking in the Son

His Birth (Luke 1:35).

"That holy thing that shall be born of thee shall be called the SON OF GOD." We have the birth of a Babe foretold here, conceived of the Holy Ghost, born of Mary the Virgin. He is here called Son of God as born in time. Though seen in the weakness of infancy, and so partaking in humanity perfectly, yet is He sinlessly holy; and He does not forfeit His Sonship by accepting human conditions. Had His mother been divine, He had not been human. She was woman, singularly favoured because chosen out of all the virgins of Israel to be the mother of the Lord; yet the more we make of Mary, the less do we make of the divine miracle of this holy birth. The body in which He appeared was prepared for Him (Heb. 10); and in it was He to effectuate all the will of God. It was guarded from every taint of sin in the Virgin's womb; not by any immaculate conception of the Virgin herself (as affirmed by Rome), which could be supposed to free her from taint of sin, but by the power and wisdom of God the Holy Ghost. The fable of the Virgin's immaculate birth, had it been true, would have required the same miracle in her parentage and birth which Scripture declares with regard to the Babe in David's royal city.

Church HistoryChurch History

It is surely more than evident from these quotations, that Mary is addressed as not only an intercessor with her Son but the first and highest object of worship. And these are calm and sober specimens compared with the wild language of a chivalrous adoration, which is to be found in hymns, psalters, and breviaries. The attributes of Godhead are assigned to her, and she is represented as the Queen of Heaven, and sitting between cherubim and seraphim. The dogma of the Immaculate Conception was the natural result of this growing adoration of Mary. It has been re-asserted as an article of faith in the Romish church by the present pope and generally accepted.

Fritz RidenourSo What's The Difference?

Protestants note that the superveneration has grown through the centuries, beginning with tradition taught as early as the fourth century that Mary's virginity continued after the birth of Jesus and that she never had any more children. Other doctrines that grew out of tradition include the Immaculate Conception (she was conceived without sin and lived a sinless life), proclaimed dogma in 1854 by Pope Pius IX, and the doctrine of the Assumption (that she was taken up body and soul directly to heaven), proclaimed dogma in 1950 by Pope Pius XIL

A. J. PollockMary—“Blessed … Among Women”

The Ritualists, in other words the Roman Catholics, exalt the Virgin Mary to be “the mother of God,” to whom worship and prayer are to be made. Further on her behalf a papal decree has falsely set forth that hers was an “immaculate birth,” that is the Virgin Mary was born sinless, and without a trace of the fall.

Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe Gospel Of Luke

The marvelous outburst of praise which comes from Mary's lips is a beautiful echo of the Old Testament Scriptures. The pious Virgin knew the Word of God; her heart was filled with it and the Holy Spirit used the Word in the expression of her praise. Many Psalms are touched upon, but especially are we reminded of Hannah's inspired song. (1 Samuel 2.) Notice also Mary's deep humility and her acknowledgment of the need of a Saviour. The invention of Rome, of the sinless and immaculate person of Mary, is disproved by everything in the Word of God.

Verses

  • Luke 1:28And the angel came in to her, and said, Hail, [thou] favoured one! the Lord [is] with thee [blessed art thou amongst women].
  • Luke 1:30And the angel said to her, Fear not, Mary, for thou hast found favour with God;
  • Luke 1:34–3534But Mary said to the angel, How shall this be, since I know not a man? 35And the angel answering said to her, [The] Holy Spirit shall come upon thee, and power of [the] Highest overshadow thee, wherefore the holy thing also which shall be born shall be called Son of God.
  • Luke 1:41–4241And it came to pass, as Elizabeth heard the salutation of Mary, the babe leaped in her womb; and Elizabeth was filled with [the] Holy Spirit, 42and cried out with a loud voice and said, Blessed [art] thou amongst women, and blessed the fruit of thy womb.
  • Luke 1:46–4946And Mary said, My soul magnifies the Lord, 47and my spirit has rejoiced in God my Saviour. 48For he has looked upon the low estate of his bondmaid; for behold, from henceforth all generations shall call me blessed. 49For the Mighty One has done to me great things, and holy [is] his name;