What is the divine council?

Answered from the commentary of Hamilton Smith, Numerical Bible Notes, L. M. Grant and 18 others

The "congregation of the mighty," or "assembly of El," in which God "judges among the gods" (Psalm 82:1), is not taken as a council of heavenly gods but as the judges and rulers of Israel, set in authority to represent God. The ground given is the Lord's own reading of the psalm: these were called "gods" as "those to whom the word of God came" (John 10:35), that is, those commissioned to represent Him. Judges in Israel were in fact habitually called Elohim. They sat in God's place, administered justice in His name, and pronounced an award that was His and not their own (Exodus 22:28). The name Elohim is likewise given to angels and judges as God's representatives. Some carry the psalm further, to "the powers that be" in every nation, since all power is ordained of God.

The psalm, then, is God calling these deputies to account. They judged unjustly and accepted the persons of the wicked, so the high place God gave them would not shield them. They would "die like men," brought down from the character of Elohim to Adam. Their failure shows that the earth waits for God Himself to arise and judge it. That rule is taken up by Christ, the one faithful steward, who will hold every office in which man has failed.

Scripture does show heavenly gatherings before God's throne, but these are assemblies of servants, not a council of advisers. In Job 1:6 the "sons of God" who present themselves before Jehovah are angels, and Satan comes among them. Several of the authors hold that this assembly includes fallen angels as well as good ones, since Satan and his host still have access to heaven until they are cast out. Micaiah's vision in 1 Kings 22:19 shows the host of heaven standing on the right and left of the throne, ready to do His will. That host is said to include evil spirits, over whom God is in perfect control. There God had already determined Ahab's fall, and the lying spirit only carried out His judgment.

Angels are messengers and "ministering spirits". They are not the depositaries of the revelation and counsels of God. God takes counsel with no creature, for there was none for Him to take counsel with. Accordingly, the "Let us make man" of Genesis 1:26 is read as counsel within the Godhead itself, a plurality that points to the Trinity. The view that it is merely a plural of majesty is mentioned only to be set aside. In Deuteronomy 32:8, the nations' bounds are said to be set "according to the number of the children of Israel," making Israel God's earthly centre. One author notes the Greek reading "angels of God" there, but he holds to the Hebrew.

Verses: John 10:35, Exodus 22:28, Psalms 82:1, Psalms 82:2, Psalms 82:3, Psalms 82:4, Psalms 82:5, Psalms 82:6, Psalms 82:7, Psalms 82:8, 1 Kings 22:19, 1 Kings 22:20, 1 Kings 22:21, 1 Kings 22:22, 1 Kings 22:23, Job 1:6, Job 1:7, Job 1:8, Job 1:9, Job 1:10, Job 1:11, Job 1:12, Job 2:1, Job 2:2, Job 2:3, Job 2:4, Job 2:5, Job 2:6, Psalms 89:5, Psalms 89:6, Psalms 89:7, Psalms 89:8, Deuteronomy 32:8, Deuteronomy 32:9, Genesis 1:26, Genesis 3:22, Genesis 11:7, Isaiah 6:1, Isaiah 6:2, Isaiah 6:3, Isaiah 6:4, Isaiah 6:5, Isaiah 6:6, Isaiah 6:7, Isaiah 6:8, Jeremiah 23:18, Jeremiah 23:22, Daniel 7:9, Daniel 7:10, Daniel 4:17, Job 38:7, Psalms 29:1, Psalms 103:20, Psalms 103:21, Psalms 148:2, Exodus 15:11, Psalms 86:8, Psalms 95:3, Psalms 97:7, Psalms 97:9, Psalms 138:1, Deuteronomy 10:17, 2 Chronicles 18:18, 2 Chronicles 18:19, 2 Chronicles 18:20, 2 Chronicles 18:21, 2 Chronicles 18:22, Zechariah 3:1, Zechariah 3:2, Zechariah 3:3, Zechariah 3:4, Zechariah 3:5, Zechariah 3:6, Zechariah 3:7, Daniel 10:13, Daniel 10:20, Daniel 10:21, Revelation 4:4, Revelation 4:10, Revelation 5:11, Ephesians 6:12, Colossians 1:16, Nehemiah 9:6, Psalms 58:1, John 10:34

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe Book Of Job

The whole scene is intensely interesting. It is not fiction but revelation, and what is here recorded actually took place, and something like it still goes on in heaven. A parallel passage is found in I Kings 22:19. The prophet Micaiah saw the Lord sitting on His throne and all the host of heaven standing by Him on His right hand and on His left. And then the Lord permitted as a judgment upon Ahab, that a lying spirit should enter Ahab's prophets to deceive Ahab.

Heaven as a place is not fiction. There is an uncreated heaven where God's throne and dwelling place have always been. From the passage here we may gather that there are certain times when all heavenly tenants, good and evil, have to assemble before the Lord. The sons of God came to present themselves before the Lord. The expression "sons of God" does not mean believers on earth (the sonship of a believer is a New Testament truth), but supernatural beings, the angels. According to this book these sons of God shouted for joy in the hour of creation (38:7). Other Scriptures speak of such heavenly gatherings. (See Psalm 89:5-7; Zech. 4, etc.) And Satan came also among them. He likewise must appear before the Lord. Satan means "adversary." In this character, as the accuser of the brethren he is seen in the last book of the Bible and according to Revelation 12 he is still active in the same capacity as in the days of Job, and has still access to the throne of God, till the hour comes when his doom begins with being cast out of heaven. Destructive criticism pronounceth Satan a Babylonian or Persian myth, a reproduction in Hebrew literature of the Persian fable of Ahriman. But even the French infidel Renan said of the Satan of the Scriptures, "This is quite a different person from the Ahriman of the Zend-Avesta. It is not the spirit of evil existing and acting for himself." He is not independent of God; as one has correctly stated it, "Satan can go only to the end of his chain." The critical assertion that the belief in a Satan originated after the exile is historically incorrect. The serpent in Genesis 3 is Satan. Originally he was Lucifer, the son of the morning (Isaiah 14), the cherub that covereth (Ezekiel 28) and this great creature of God fell by pride. (See "The History of Satan" in Studies in Prophecy Our Hope Press, and the larger work on Satan, His Person, Work Place and Destiny, by F.C. Jennings.)

W. W. FeredayModern Spiritualism

In 1 Kings, 22:19-28, we have another glimpse behind the veil. Ahab, being determined to attack Ramoth-gilead, and refusing the prophet's warning, Micaiah was permitted to draw aside the veil for a moment, that the wilful King might see that he was being allured to his destruction by spirit action working upon the minds of his servile advisers. "Hear thou therefore the word of Jehovah: I saw Jehovah sitting on His throne, and all the host of heaven standing by Him on His right hand and on His left. And the Lord said, 'Who shall persuade Ahab, that he may go up and fall at Ramoth-gilead?' And one said on this manner, and another said on that manner. And there came forth a spirit, and stood before Jehovah, and said, 'I will persuade him.' And Jehovah said to him, 'Wherewith?' And he said, 'I will go forth, and I will be a lying spirit in the mouth of all his prophets.' And He said, 'Thou shalt persuade him, and prevail also: go forth, and do so.'" Thus the disastrous expedition which cost Ahab his life was discussed and settled in the spirit world, and an evil angel dragged down to his ruin the wilful king who had long since turned his back upon his Creator.

Samuel RidoutLecture 12

Both Old and New Testaments abound with passages referring to the existence, personality and ministry of angels. They are called literally "messengers" — for this is the significance of the word both in Hebrew and Greek — and no doubt is left that they are heavenly messengers. Their estate is heavenly (see Gal. 1:8; 2 Thess. 1:7); and they are there as worshipers and servants of God (Job 1:6; Job 38:7; 1 Kings 22:19). This last passage would almost suggest the position of the cherubim: "I saw the Lord sitting on His throne, and all the host of heaven standing by Him on His right hand and on His left" — they are grouped about His throne, ready to do His will. Angels were particularly used in connection with errands of mercy and of judgment: to announce to Abraham the birth of Isaac, in due time (Gen. 18:2 with Heb. 13:2); for the rescue of Lot out of Sodom (Gen. 19:1); in ministry upon Jacob as he slept (Gen. 28:12). They were present in great multitudes at Sinai, and gave character to the ministration of the law (Ps. 68:17 with Acts 7:53; Heb. 2:2).

Numerical Bible NotesThe Psalms

He stands, therefore, in the midst of what is His own assembly, and which is now to be the seat of power upon earth, the assembly of El, the Mighty One, in truth. He is there for judgment among the "gods," a term which the Lord defines for us from this very psalm (ver. 6) as "those to whom the word of God came" (John 10:35), — that is, who were commissioned to represent Him — the judges of Israel. They were thus identified with Him whom they represented, and were responsible in the most solemn way to represent Him in His character also, both in His righteousness and in His love to men.

Hamilton SmithThe Psalms

(v. 1) God is presented as standing in the midst of the congregation of His people. He judges among the judges. The Lord, in the New Testament days, tells us that these judges, or “gods,” are those “to whom the word of God came” giving them authority to act in judgment as His representatives, and therefore referred to as “gods” (John 10:35).

Samuel RidoutLecture 6

"The Scripture cannot be broken" (John 10:35). As we have had frequent occasion to remark, the connection of passages is of great interest, and oftentimes furnishes the key to the special application or meaning. It is so here. Our Lord is quoting what some might be tempted to call an obscure passage from the Psalms (Ps. 82:6). It is to the effect that judges in Israel, because they stood for God's authority and were the executors of His Word, were called "gods" — "I said ye are gods." They were His representatives. Now, our Lord says this Scripture cannot be broken — cannot be set aside. It is simply an obvious explanation, men might say, of no great importance, and yet our Lord declares it cannot be ignored. It is a part of a perfect whole. So He goes on to apply it to His own position; how much more was it true of Him whom the Father had sanctified and sent into the world.

J. N. DarbyChapters 1 and 2

All this is so much the more instructive, from its being set before us independent of all dispensations, of all especial revelation on God's part. It is the godly man, such as one of Noah's descendants would be, who had not lost the knowledge of the true God, when sin was again spreading in the world and idolatry was setting in; but the Judge was there to punish it. Job was encompassed with blessings and possessed real piety. Satan, the accuser of the servants of God, goes to and fro in the earth seeking occasion for evil, and presents himself before Jehovah among His mighty angels, the "Bene-Elohim": and God states the case of Job, the subject of His government in blessing, faithful in his walk.

W. W. FeredayBalaam: His Words and Ways

Turning now to 1 Kings 22:14-23. Ahab — Israel's wicked and wilful king — was disposed to go to war with Syria for the recovery of Ramoth-Gilead. His misguided ally, Jehoshaphat King of Judah (pious, but weak) wished to know what Jehovah might have to say about the undertaking. In due course faithful Micaiah was brought out of prison, and in few words he described a scene in the heavenlies. Jehovah was seated on His throne surrounded by the host of heaven. His patience with Ahab being now exhausted, He called for a volunteer who would dispose the doomed man to go to war to his undoing. After much discussion, a spirit proposed to go down and put a lie in the mouths of all the King's prophets. "Go forth, and do so," said the great God. No words can adequately set forth the solemnity of this. Israel's war with Syria was thus arranged in the spirit world, as many a war since. Blinded by Satan, Ahab paid no heed to what he heard. God's faithful witness was sent back to prison, and the king rode forth to his death.

William KellyLectures on the Epistle of Jude

It appears there were at least two falls of angels; one was he whom we call Satan — when man was made, Satan tempted man through Eve. Those ordinary evil angels, of which we read in the Bible from Genesis down to Revelation, are not under everlasting chains at all. They are roving about the world continually, and so far from being in chains of darkness, in "tortures" as it is called here, they are allowed access to heaven. You will see that in a very marvellous way in the history of Job. A great many believers do not believe in the book of Job. You will see there "the sons of God" referred to. What is meant by "the sons of God" there? Why, the angels of God. The angels of God appeared before God. We learn from this that they have access, and include not only the good angels but also the Satanic angels. Satan was a fallen angel, but still he was an angel, and when "the sons of God" came, Satan was there too. So that it is evident, from the Book of Revelation more particularly, that Satan will not lose that access to the presence of God until we are actually in heaven. It has not come to pass yet. People have an extraordinary idea in their heads that whatever access Satan had before that time, he lost it — either when our Lord was born, or when our Lord died — but there is nothing of this in the Epistle to the Ephesians, where, on the contrary it is expressly stated that our wrestling is not against flesh and blood, but against wicked spirits in the heavenlies. We are not like the Israelites fighting against Canaanites. Our Canaanite is a spiritual enemy in heavenly places, that is, Satan and his host of demons or angels.

J. N. DarbyThe Psalms

This Psalm is God assuming judgment but not exercising it - calling strength to be strength in justice. The discovery of universal iniquity gives occasion to the cry, "Arise, O God" - not only the discovery, but their not knowing nor understanding that there is a "God that judgeth." It is not testimony of grace, nor of Christ standing in the midst of the Churches, but Elohim standing in the congregation of power or strength, judging accordingly - speaking to them in Spirit, as to their conduct according to His mind and, bounden righteousness in it as His representatives. But they know not neither understand, "All the foundations of the earth are out of course"; the Jew was wrong - the Gentile powers, oppression - none believed, none recognised God - they were owned as gods, as bearing His image and expressing the mind of the Most High in title and office - but they should die like men. The sorrow was, no Jewish ruler was any better, and God would take judgment into His own hands, for in this also, as in all else, the Son must be the representative, the full representative to wit, in power, of Elohim. Thus we find also judges called "Elohim" continually, sitting on the seat or throne of judgment. It is a Psalm very instructive as to the ordinance of power, and God's part or judgment of it.

Verses

  • John 10:34–3534Jesus answered them, Is it not written in your law, I said, Ye are gods? 35If he called them gods to whom the word of God came (and the scripture cannot be broken),
  • Exodus 22:28Thou shalt not revile the judges, nor curse a prince amongst thy people.
  • Psalms 82:1–81(A Psalm of Asaph.) God standeth in the assembly of God, he judgeth among the gods. 2How long will ye judge unrighteously, and accept the person of the wicked? Selah. 3Judge the poor and the fatherless, do justice to the afflicted and the destitute; 4Rescue the poor and needy, deliver them out of the hand of the wicked. 5They know not, neither do they understand; they walk on in darkness all the foundations of the earth are moved. 6I have said, Ye are gods, and all of you are children of the Most High; 7But ye shall die like men, and fall like one of the princes. 8Arise, O God, judge the earth; for thou shalt inherit all the nations.