What is militarism?

Answered from the commentary of James Boyd, C. Knapp, The Bible Treasury and 12 others

Militarism is the spirit that sets a nation's trust and strength in armed force. It trains its people for war, so that in the end every individual must take his place among the fighting forces of his country. It is more than keeping an army. Without faith in God, the king of 1 Samuel 8 is described as a "pronounced militarist": he takes the choicest young men for his standing army and a tenth of all that is produced to support the display. In the professing Christian nations of these authors' own day, the same spirit shows itself in war cultivated as a science and in standing armies kept up where the gospel of peace is professed, and this is called a proof of the rule of the prince of this world. Iron that God put into the hills for ploughshares is forged into guns, the cleverest brains and newest science are turned to engines of destruction, and armament firms pay the biggest dividends. "If you will have peace, prepare for war" is called a cruel mockery, since preparation for war must sooner or later end in war, and the more complete the preparation the more terrible the war. Its root lies in fallen man: wars come from the lusts that war in the members (James 4:1), from lust of conquest and military glory, and from the lust of power, one of the most fruitful sources of human woe. Even patriotism, which can carry Christians along with it, is called the spirit of the world under an honourable and attractive form.

Fighting it does not cure it. While the Allies fought German militarism, every nation would find that, to safeguard its own interests, it had to nourish that very spirit in its own people. Among a minority of these writers, the iron mixed with clay in the image of Daniel 2 is read as military power alongside socialism in the last days. On this reading the nations see militarism as their only hope of existence, and dire necessity will make it inevitable, though its taxation and subjection to authority stir up discontent. Prussian militarism showed features of the beast of Revelation 13, namely arrogance, lust for power and ambition for world empire, but so did earlier powers. The full military despotism will come under that Beast, and the Satanic holy war of the end is called the apotheosis of militarism. To the kingdoms of this world, war is an unhappy necessity, and they hold what they possess by the sword. Peace societies are at best an amiable illusion. Wars will cease only when the Lord comes in judgment and nations beat their swords into ploughshares. Meanwhile the Christian is not of this world, for "if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight" (John 18:36). His weapons are not carnal but spiritual.

Verses: John 18:36, Isaiah 2:4, Micah 4:3, Psalms 20:7, Isaiah 31:1, Psalms 33:16, Psalms 33:17, Zechariah 4:6, Hosea 10:13, Matthew 26:52, Psalms 68:30, James 4:1, James 4:2, Psalms 46:9, Psalms 120:7, Proverbs 21:31, Psalms 44:6, Deuteronomy 17:16, Romans 12:18, 2 Corinthians 10:3, 2 Corinthians 10:4, Ecclesiastes 9:18, Psalms 147:10, Psalms 147:11, Hosea 1:7, Matthew 5:9

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

C. KnappSamuel the Prophet

Samuel gives them in detail a description of the king that should rule them. It was not God's ideal of what a king should be, but the manner of the king of their choice that would be given them as a punishment for their wilful rejection of God's rule through Samuel. He would be a despot, fierce, cruel, a "raiser of taxes," a binder of burdens heavy and "grievous to be borne" upon the backs of the oppressed people. Without faith in God, he would be a pronounced "militarist," taking the choicest of their young men to fill the ranks of his standing army, and require a tenth of all they produced for the support of all this pomp and empty show; for instead of using his hosts in defeating and driving out of the land the invading Philistines, they were occupied more in hunting David, the man of God's choice, "as one doth hunt a partridge in the mountains," or as David himself sarcastically puts it, "The king of Israel is come out to seek a flea!" (1 Sam. 26:20). Dignified and important occupation, indeed, for "the king of Israel!" "He will take, he will take," Samuel says repeatedly — six times in seven verses. And what did he give them in return? "He will give," Samuel says, not to them, but "to his officers and to his servants." To them it was given to pay and to yield up to his kingly requirements their "goodliest young men" and their "daughters;" the boys to be slaughtered by the uncircumcised Philistines through Saul's mismanagement, and "Zion's fair daughters" to slave it in his kitchens as "confectionaries, and cooks, and bakers."

James BoydGod and the War

And until that day there shall be no improvement in the relation of kingdoms, one to the other. The entente allies are fighting against militarism, and expecting to crush that spirit in the German nation, but instead of producing this result, every nation will find that, to safeguard its own interests, it will have to nourish and stimulate that very spirit in its own people; and every individual in every kingdom upon earth will find it to be a necessity that he should take his place among the fighting forces of his country. This war is frightful to contemplate, but it is not even “the beginning of sorrows” (Matt. 34:8). Worse is coming.

A. J. PollockThe Revived Roman Empire

Finally, I would draw attention to the fact that the ten toes of the image were partly of iron and partly of clay—an element of power and an element of weakness. This was strikingly illuminated by a remark I saw the other day that Europe was fast becoming a combination of militarism and socialism, the former standing for iron, the latter for clay. And this war will help on both in a wonderful way. Already a flood of militarism has passed over this land, where up to now it had little hold.

The nations see it is their only hope of existence. At the same time the crushing burdens of taxation it entails and the subjection to authority it involves will surly ferment discontent and socialism, which will become manifest when the patriotic wave has passed.

J. T. MawsonIs the War Fulfilling Prophecy?

One reason why people are deceived into supposing that this is the great war that shall end war is that certain features of the beast of Revelation 13 — the head of the to-be-revived Roman Empire — seem to be present in Prussian militarism and its head. But this is not singular, nor is it the first time that these features have appeared. Wherever there has been great power without the guiding wisdom from on high, and ambition for world empire, they have been present. The great characteristics of the Spanish Empire of the sixteenth century — arrogance, persecution of God's people, lust for power, and the determination to crush out or enslave all who opposed its will, are all to be fully developed in the beast. In the seventeenth century Louis the Great of France, perhaps in a lesser measure, exhibited these same features. In the nineteenth century Napoleon appeared, and though he was not a persecutor, yet he, more than any who went before him, exhibited features associated with the beast in so much that he was popularly supposed to be he; but he was not, nor is the Prussian Kaiser; indeed, his country lies outside the bounds of the Old Roman Empire over which the beast is to be head. It is interesting, and not a little remarkable, that Britain, in the providence of God, should have been the power largely responsible for the defeat of all these great forces of the past.

The Bible TreasuryPower, Religion, and Commerce

But while all show enmity, some are more expressive of the spirit that now dominates the world — the spirit of Mammon. A special phase is commerce. Commerce is influenced by covetousness, and covetousness is idolatry. For the sake of Mammon war is decried. At the same time is it not worthy of the Christian's notice that war is cultivated as a science, and standing armies are maintained in christendom where the gospel of peace is professed? What a proof of the rule and power of the prince of this world! The crust of peace spread over the civilized world is very thin. Underneath are armed millions and new warlike inventions. Nations are saying Peace, peace, and yet preparing for war, and rumours and signs of it are not wanting. How blessed that amid all the commotions and strifes of this world, believers can look beyond and say, "we, receiving a kingdom that cannot be moved!" But, whatever the dominating spirit, all men who have not the truth are hoping and seeking to maintain the present system of the world. And they dream that they will perpetuate it, and they will continue to dream, until the judgment of God awakens them. Then in their alarm they will call on the mountains and rocks to hide them from the wrath of the Lamb.

William KellyJoel

Thus, instead of peace being brought about before the day of Jehovah comes, such a wide-spread gathering for war is to be as the world will have never yet seen. The desire to do great things, impatience of obligations, lust of conquest and military glory, will bring on men such a taste for war ere long that no restraints will suffice to keep them within bounds, especially as jealousy of each other will have led to the accumulation of vast stores for military purposes. So the closing scenes of this age will be found to be described in scripture. I repeat, if one's conclusion were drawn from the thoughts of men, much might be said for the contrary. Some might think the age had gained better sense, that they had too deep a conviction of their forefathers' sin and folly in this respect, and that henceforth remonstrance and arbitration would gradually supersede the more savage diplomacy of "blood and iron." But in vain is it hoped thus to control the passions and will of man. The time of peace is not yet. Men may think that they are going to succeed, but it will be with the Gentiles as of old with Israel. The Jews will try to get back into their land, and the political power of some nations will be used to establish them in peace. But when it is thought that all is going well, the work is arrested, and the Jews become once more an object of jealousy to the Gentiles. Before the harvest, as it is said in Isaiah 18, the fair promise of fruit is nipped in the bud and comes to nothing. Instead of having Christ to reign over them in that state, they but prepare a throne for antichrist. Such will be the speedy result of it, with unspeakable dishonour to God and unexampled ruin to all concerned. The fact is, that God means to bring His people Himself into His land. We see all through the Old Testament the people's blessing in the land He gave them. All attempts to anticipate the time, or change the methods of God for human means, are not only vain, but will involve ruin as the direct consequence of such presumption.

The Bible TreasuryScripture Sketches: 18. Othniel

Happy is the country that has no "history" — that is, in the vulgar sense of the word, a record of wars, treaties, and conflicting dynasties. Happy is the country when a ruler's long reign can be written in two or three clauses thus: An arduous and heroic enterprise; a mighty and effectual salvation; a wise and tranquil reign. The curse of an earthly deliverer usually is that, when he has saved his nation, and finds himself with a great military force in his power, his ardour of battle and lust of conquest is so great that he then goes about carrying fire and sword into other nations; he likes a spirited foreign policy, until either he inflicts every horror of war wherever his foot treads, or else the people in a frenzy of hatred and despair combine to cast him off the face of the earth. They hurl him at last from Moscow to St. Helena. But Othniel had evidently no more lust of conquest than a Hampden or a Washington. To one like this, "the next dreadful thing to a battle lost is a battle won." He now shows himself as wise and strong to govern his own people and keep them in peaceful development, as he has already been to conquer their oppressors.

The Bible Treasury"Peace on earth" — "Peace in heaven"

That the most sincere and hearty endeavours will never avail to establish peace among men, we have the lamentable proof before our eyes. What a cruel mockery is the saying, 'If you will have peace, prepare for war.' A far truer one would be, 'If you would have peace, beat your swords into ploughshares, and your spears into pruning-hooks.' Preparation for war must sooner or later end in war. And the war will be all the more terrible as the preparation shall have been more complete. Much as this is to be deplored, it is unavoidable. How long will this state of things last? As long as God permits fallen and rebellious man to govern this world, for he is branded with this awful character, "their feet are swift to shed blood: destruction and misery are in their ways." There will be even worse days than the present, bad enough as they are, and ominous enough too as a prelude.

A. J. PollockThe Christian and Socialism

Here we get a forecast of the last days—iron foreshadowing the strength of military power; the clay setting forth Socialism in its inherent weakness. Necessity, dire necessity, will make the military power inevitable, but all the time there will be the uprising of Socialism, never quite to succeed, for it has no elements of true success in it. By its very nature it is ready to split into parties, led by visionaries with different aims. The labour leader applauded today may be howled down tomorrow.

Things are shaping themselves towards the fulfilment of prophecy. The first and second Great World Wars have helped in this direction. The great cry today is for a new World Order. To this end arrangements will be made with the aim to prevent war, to see that little nations have their rights, to get rid of the necessity of armies and navies, to deliver the nations from the incubus of the taxation the present state of things renders necessary, to establish an international force, powerful enough to keep the whole world in order and introduce a peaceful millennium. This all sounds very delightful.

A. J. PollockThe Christian and Socialism

Three unclean spirits, like frogs, will come out of their mouths. These we are told are the spirits of demons working miracles, and by their demoniacal power they will influence the whole world, work up a Satanic holy war on a scale never before known in the history of the world. Here is the apotheosis of Spiritualism and Militarism and Socialism—strange bedfellows indeed.

Verses

  • John 18:36Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world; if my kingdom were of this world, my servants had fought that I might not be delivered up to the Jews; but now my kingdom is not from hence.
  • Isaiah 2:4And he shall judge among the nations, and shall reprove many peoples; and they shall forge their swords into ploughshares, and their spears into pruning-knives nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more.
  • Micah 4:3And he shall judge among many peoples, and reprove strong nations, even afar off; and they shall forge their swords into ploughshares, and their spears into pruning-knives nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more.
  • Psalms 20:7Some make mention of chariots, and some of horses, but we of the name of Jehovah our God.
  • Isaiah 31:1Woe to them that go down to Egypt for help, and depend on horses, and confide in chariots because [they are] many, and in horsemen because they are very strong; and who look not unto the Holy One of Israel, neither seek Jehovah!
  • Psalms 33:16–1716The king is not saved by the multitude of [his] forces; a mighty man is not delivered by much strength. 17The horse is a vain thing for safety; neither doth he deliver by his great power.
  • Zechariah 4:6And he answered and spoke unto me, saying, This is the word of Jehovah unto Zerubbabel, saying, Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit, saith Jehovah of hosts.