What is incarnational ministry / incarnational theology, and is it biblical?

Answered from the commentary of J. T. Mawson, William Kelly, J. G. Bellett and 4 others

Incarnational ministry or theology, if it means that the Word became flesh and dwelt among us, is biblical: God came near in Jesus, who lived among people full of grace and truth and made God known. His real humanity was essential to His work, but the incarnation was not itself the atonement or a union of Christ with all humanity; redemption rests on His death and resurrection.

Christians are called to represent Him in the world: to bear witness to Him in word and life, and to serve others in love, grace and truth. His lowly, self-giving mind is their pattern, though His person and work remain unique. The passages do not use “incarnational ministry” as a label; they affirm ministry that follows Christ’s example, while rejecting the claim that incarnation alone joins humanity to God or makes the church a continuation of the incarnation.

Verses: John 1:14, John 20:21, 1 Peter 2:21, 1 John 2:6, 1 Corinthians 2:2, Galatians 5:11

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

C. H. MackintoshThe Christian's Mission

We need to he reminded, in days like the present, that every child of God, every member of the body of Christ, whatever be his position or sphere of action, has a mission to fulfil — a work to do for Christ. He may not be called to be an evangelist, a pastor, or a teacher: but he is called to live Christ — to represent Him — to be a channel of communication between His loving heart and every form of need, in this poor dark, cold, selfish world. This is the Christian's mission: may every Christian seek to fulfil it!]

C. E. StuartThe Gospel of John

Judaism knew of nothing like that. Under the law men were taught to take heed to themselves, that they might continue in the enjoyment of blessings dependent on their obedience. Expansiveness towards others was not the characteristic of that dispensation. God hedged them round with laws and ordinances to keep them apart from the nations about them. In Christianity, on the other hand, a different spirit is to be displayed; for believers, in the enjoyment of spiritual blessings themselves, should seek to minister spiritual blessings to others. May we not here ask, Is this commonly understood? Are not many contented to get good for themselves, and there to rest? But the Christian was never intended to be like a sponge, taking in, but not giving out. From him should flow rivers of living water. Observe the Lord does not speak as moderns would of a ministerial class so acting. Every believer is viewed by Him as a channel for blessing to others. It was so in early days, when "they that were scattered abroad went everywhere preaching the Word" (Acts 8:4). Living water was flowing through them abundantly; and when those simple-hearted Christians of Cyprus and Cyrene, reaching Antioch, spake to the Greeks, preaching the Lord Jesus, what a harvest there was of souls in that city! "The hand of the Lord was with them, and a great number that believed turned to the Lord" (Acts 11:20-21).

Arend Remmers"The Sermon on the Mount"

Yet in many ways the teaching of the New Testament has been degraded to something merely earthly and social. Instead of repentance and faith in the Lord Jesus, only charity is preached, and this often with a political flavour. This, however, is not the meaning of the “Sermon on the Mount” or the gospel of the grace of God! On the other hand it is no testimony to the grace and mercy of our God if one thinks that preaching the gospel is the only task of a Christian with regard to the world. As our Lord Himself helped those in their different needs to whom He presented the good tidings, we too can tell our neighbours of Him and at the same time show them the power and blessing of our faith practically.

Truth & TestimonyVolume 2 - 8

Yet in many ways the teaching of the New Testament has been degraded to something merely earthly and social. Instead of repentance and faith in the Lord Jesus, only charity is preached, and this often with a political flavour. This, however, is not the meaning of the “Sermon on the Mount” or the gospel of the grace of God! On the other hand it is no testimony to the grace and mercy of our God if one thinks that preaching the gospel is the only task of a Christian with regard to the world. As our Lord Himself helped those in their different needs to whom He presented the good tidings, we too can tell our neighbours of Him and at the same time show them the power and blessing of our faith practically.

J. T. MawsonHe Dwelt Among Us

What an amazing fact is revealed to us in this short sentence. He who WAS when time was not, at whose fiat the pendulum of time began to swing, who set all the forces of nature into motion, and made the universe pulsate with life; Who is Himself personally the exact expression of the infinite thoughts and eternal glory of the Godhead — the ever-existing Word — He became flesh and dwelt among us, taking part in flesh and blood that He might come near to us without making us afraid; it is this that fills the souls of those who have received Him with wonder and worship.

He did not come as a king might come to visit His subjects in their cottage homes, speaking a kindly word to them, and then passing on and forgetting them: He dwelt among us. There was no aloofness about Him; He entered into the circumstances of life; He entered into the joys and sorrows of men, as well as into their houses. He came near to them, became infinitely accessible to even the poorest and the worst, He dwelt among us full of grace and truth.

J. T. MawsonEmmanuel

What an amazing fact is revealed to us in this short sentence. He who WAS when time was not, at whose fiat the pendulum of time began to swing, who set all the forces of nature into motion, and made the universe pulsate with life: Who is Himself personally the exact expression of the infinite thoughts and eternal glory of the Godhead — the ever-existing Word — He became flesh and dwelt among us, taking part in flesh and blood that He might come near to us without making us afraid: it is this that fills the souls of those who have received Him with wonder and worship.

He did not come as a king might come to visit His subjects in their cottage homes, speaking a kindly word to them, and then passing on and forgetting them; He dwelt among us. There was no aloofness about Him: He entered into the circumstances of life: He entered into the joys and sorrows of men, as well as into their houses. He came near to them, became infinitely accessible to even the poorest and the worst. He dwelt among us full of grace and truth.

J. T. MawsonMiscellaneous Writings

What an amazing fact is revealed to us in this short sentence. He who WAS when time was not, at whose fiat the pendulum of time began to swing, who set all the forces of nature into motion, and made the universe pulsate with life; Who is Himself personally the exact expression of the infinite thoughts and eternal glory of the Godhead—the ever-existing Word—He became flesh and dwelt among us, taking part in flesh and blood that He might come near to us without making us afraid; it is this that fills the souls of those who have received Him with wonder and worship.

He did not come as a king might come to visit His subjects in their cottage homes, speaking a kindly word to them, and then passing on and forgetting them: He dwelt among us. There was no aloofness about Him; He entered into the circumstances of life; He entered into the joys and sorrows of men, as well as into their houses. He came near to them, became infinitely accessible to even the poorest and the worst, He dwelt among us full of grace and truth.

VariousEternal Life

"The Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us." From the manger to the cross "the life" was in manifestation, as He dwelt among men, showing out in living power the nature—the moral glory of God.

William KellyJohn 1 - 6

From the revelation of the Word in His own intrinsic nature, we now turn to His actual manifestation as man here below. The Incarnation is brought before us, the full revelation of God to man and in man. "And the Word became flesh and tabernacled among us (and we beheld His glory, glory as of an only-begotten from beside a father), full of grace and truth." Here it is not what the Word was, but what He became. He was God; He became flesh18 and dwelt among us, full of grace and truth.

It was no transient vision, however momentous, as on the holy mount. It was a contemplation19 of His glory vouchsafed to His witnesses, not of an earthly conqueror, nor Messianic even, but glory20 as of an only-begotten from beside ( παρὰ ) a father.21 No sword girds His thigh, no riding to victory, no terrible things in righteousness: the incarnate Word dwelt among us, full of grace and truth. Such is He that was in and from the beginning, and thus known. He was the King undoubtedly, but not so portrayed here. He is infinitely more than King, even God, yet God on earth, man dwelling among men, full of grace and truth. So only could God be displayed, unless in judgment which had left no hope, but only destroyed to the bitter end at once and unreservedly. For infinitely different purposes had He come, as this passage itself declares in due season, perfectly knowing and feeling the universal evil of man. He tabernacled among us full of grace and truth. It was not a visit or a theophany, as in O.T. experiences. So He here manifested God, Who is love. But grace is more; it is love in the midst of evil, rising above it, going down under it, overcoming it with good.

J. N. DarbyThe Gospel of John

Now the Word is looked at as become flesh. In verse 14 a new part commences. Before, it was what He was; now, what He became (what He began to be). The Word became flesh and dwelt among us; it was a real thing, not like God visiting Abraham; but He dwelt among us, tabernacled there "and we beheld his glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth, and of his fulness have all we received, and grace for grace." His own incarnate character and our connection with it. The part about John the Baptist comes in in the middle. But there is the statement, "the Word was made flesh": and then you get the aspect He had. We beheld His glory, not of the Son as such, but as of an only-begotten with a Father. He had all the title of that excellency and value in everything. All that that was to the Father was with Him. It is His personal glory made visible in flesh. When He was made flesh, we get a witness of John (v. 15), just as before, saying, "This was he of whom I spake, He that cometh after me is preferred before me, for he was before me."

Verses

  • John 1:14And the Word became flesh, and dwelt among us (and we have contemplated his glory, a glory as of an only-begotten with a father), full of grace and truth;
  • John 20:21[Jesus] said therefore again to them, Peace [be] to you as the Father sent me forth, I also send you.
  • 1 Peter 2:21For to this have ye been called; for Christ also has suffered for you, leaving you a model that ye should follow in his steps
  • 1 John 2:6He that says he abides in him ought, even as he walked, himself also [so] to walk.
  • 1 Corinthians 2:2For I did not judge [it well] to know anything among you save Jesus Christ, and him crucified.
  • Galatians 5:11But I, brethren, if I yet preach circumcision, why am I yet persecuted? Then the scandal of the cross has been done away.