What is guile in the Bible?

Answered from the commentary of The Bible Treasury, G. V. Wigram, F. B. Hole and 12 others

Guile in Scripture is deceit: cunning, craftiness and plotting to deceive, most often tied to a person's words. It is artifice, and it is not the same as guilt, for guilt is the state of a man who has transgressed and found no answer to his sin. Guile is sin, yet much sin is not guile; it is hypocrisy, vain pretence, unreality, and a want of uprightness and honesty. It always follows guilt, as it did at the beginning, when the first parents sought to hide from God and to lay the blame on another, and every fallen man does the same. So in Psalm 32:2 guile is the deceit of trying to cover up one's sins. "No guile" there means a frank and honest facing of one's guilt before God, laid bare in His sight. That comes only by confession: the acknowledging of sin to God with no excuse, the exact opposite of guile. A confessing spirit is a guileless spirit. Guile is taken out of the spirit by forgiveness. Because God does not impute iniquity, the heart is open, has nothing to hide, and does not want to excuse what has been put away. Grace sets the soul right and makes it able to judge its sin honestly. For this reason no man is free of guile until his conscience is washed in the blood of the Lamb. Nathanael (John 1:47) is the example: he was not without sin, but he was without guile, honest before God, and most likely he had been confessing under the fig tree. His guilelessness was the guilelessness of Psalm 32, not a matter of natural temper. Jacob, by contrast, was a crooked man full of guile, seeking by craft what God meant to give him by grace.

Among believers guile is something to be laid aside (1 Peter 2:1). It seeks to hide what we are, it goes along with malice, and it is the opposite of the transparent truthfulness to which Christians are called. It may stop short of telling a lie and still speak or act so as to leave a wrong impression, which makes it an underhand lie. Guile is not wanting to be read through and having something sinister behind; to be without it is to be transparent. Christ is the pattern, for no guile was found in His mouth (1 Peter 2:22) and no evil motive ever lay hidden under fair speech. The Pharisees showed guile when they asked an innocent-looking question in order to entangle Him. Deceit is the resource of weakness, and in Him there was none. The one who would see good days must therefore keep his lips from speaking guile (Psalm 34:13; 1 Peter 3:10), and that includes guile used to excuse oneself. Paul's preaching had no guile that hides the truth, nor any intent to deceive (1 Thessalonians 2:3). The words "being crafty, I caught you with guile" (2 Corinthians 12:16) were the charge of his adversaries, which he rejects, and they give no warrant for a Christian to use guile.

Verses: John 1:47, Psalms 32:2, 1 Peter 2:1, 1 Peter 2:22, 1 Peter 3:10, Psalms 34:13, Revelation 14:5, 2 Corinthians 12:16, 1 Thessalonians 2:3, Psalms 55:11, Exodus 21:14, Isaiah 53:9, Mark 7:22, Romans 1:29

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

G. V. WigramNotes of a Gospel Address

"In whose spirit there is no guile." (v. 2.) Guile has nothing to do with guilt; guilt is the condition of a man having transgressed who has not found an answer to his sin. Guile is artifice. While David was trying to patch himself up, he was forgetting that his sin was all exposed before his people. To think that he could try to be before God as an unruined creature, when he, the man after God's own heart, had taken the place of a model sinner! It would not do. God says, "I know all the iniquity, but I do not impute it; why and is at My right hand." Am I in this place? What further discovery can come out, if to my mind the blood of the Lord Jesus shed on Calvary is the measure of my sins and the iniquity of my nature? If God wants a people, whom does He choose? A righteous people? No; a people who, when all earth shall be under the power of darkness and sin, shall be able to slip Satan, and live for God in spite of what they are. God has a people who find they cannot get along unless they know their ruin, and how God has even turned that to His own glory, and know God as a refuge from their ruin. There is a height in Him altogether beyond the creature ken to measure. Who could have thought of such a thing as that the unruined God should come in and say, "I know how to turn your very ruin to my glory. I am altogether above you in the range of my thoughts. I shall do as I choose. 'I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy.'" Who is to say to God, Stop? He is the only one who can say, "I will;" and it will stand. What else does it show? God as the God of resources! What seemed utterly impossible, has been accomplished. The attributes of His being could so blend as to meet the sinner. But He was a God of resources. He had one Son, and in Him on the cross all the rays of the character of God could be shown out; and God stands forth inviting, attracting, alluring, commanding the ruined creature not to stand out for the first Adam, but to come to God and give his sinnership, his sins, on the ground of the Person and work of Him whom God delighteth to honour. The beauty of the Lamb, who sits on the throne of God, is part of my felicity as a poor sinner. Is that aground that will break down?

The Bible TreasuryThe Gospel of Mark

Deceit. — This word is often translated "guile" in the New Testament, and is expressive of cunning, of craftiness, of plotting to deceive, while it is usually associated with a person's words. There was no guile found in the mouth of Christ (1 Peter 2:22), nor will guile be in the mouth of the future Jewish remnant who follow the Lamb (Rev. 14:5), of whom Nathanael was a figure (John 1:47). But it was by guile that the Jewish council sought to arrest Jesus and put Him to death (Matt. 26:4; Mark. 14:1). Elymas the sorcerer was full of it, for it was part of his nefarious stock-in-trade (Acts 13:10). While it is declared of Jew and Gentile alike that "with their tongues they have used deceit [guile]" (Rom. 3:13), the apostle Peter quotes the Psalmist who says, "He that would love life and see good days, let him refrain his tongue from evil, and his lips that they speak no guile" (Ps. 34:13; 1 Peter 3:10).

F. B. HoleChrist: Sacrifice, Blesser, Centre, Builder, Leader, Judge, Administrator

In verse 47 we discover that Christ is not only the Leader but the JUDGE. When Nathanael came into His presence the Lord showed him that He knew everything about him by saying, "Behold an Israelite indeed in whom is no guile." That is not equivalent to saying "In whom is no sin." Guile is sin it is true, yet there is much sin that is not guile. Guile is hypocrisy, vain pretence, unreality, lack of uprightness and honesty. Nathanael was a man who though a sinner was honest. Beneath the fig tree he had doubtless been confessing his sins to God, and Jesus, knowing that, said, "Here is a true Israelite who is without hypocrisy and not like the rest carrying on their religious ceremonials to keep up appearances." The mass were making believe that all was going on quite well though they had not got the beautiful glory cloud, for the divine presence had left them. Still they kept up a round of religious observances when God was not there, and the power was gone and it was an empty shell without a kernel. Nathanael was not like that; I hope we are not like that. Now the Lord Jesus showed Himself to be the Critic and the all-discerning Judge, and if He approves, well you really need not be much concerned that men blame you.

F. B. HoleGrace, Guidance, and Government

Next comes guile. This means deceit, hypocrisy, lack of straightforwardness and honesty. It always follows guilt, always has done so from the beginning, as Genesis 3 bears witness. Directly our first parents incurred guilt they sought to hide from God, and also to put the blame upon somebody else. Every soul of man does just the same. It is a deeply rooted instinct of our fallen race.

W. T. P. Wolston4 His Letters - 1

Then having got this new life, Peter informs us that there are things to be laid aside which used to mark the old life. "Wherefore laying aside all malice, and all guile, and hypocrisies, and envies, and all evil speakings, as new-born babes, desire the sincere milk of the word, that ye may grow thereby: if so be ye have tasted that the Lord is gracious" (1 Peter 2:1-3). Guile is not liking to be read through: having something sinister behind. How beautiful is the Lord's word about Nathanael, "Behold an Israelite indeed, in whom is no guile" (John 1:47). Without guile is to be transparent. Was the Lord ever double? He was as transparent as the light, for He was "the light."

William Kelly1 Peter

Next, "guile" follows with no less moral truth, and "all guile" because of its manifold aim, and the desire with which men shun its discovery. For however much addicted to deceive others, they are inwardly ashamed of a habit so base. "Guile" naturally succeeds "malice" in order to do the man deadly mischief, and withal escape detection. It is the reverse of that transparent truthfulness to which we are called as representing Him Who is the truth, just as Satan is a liar and its father.

Leslie M. GrantComments On Epistle Of 1 Peter

Since the Word of God is the solid foundation of all, eternal blessing for us, it surely follows that we should gladly lay aside all that is contrary to It. Indeed, these evils listed in verse I will greatly hinder any true enjoyment of that Word. Malice may not be on the surfaces but its hard, bitter feelings against another will deaden any true desire for the Word. Guile may not be speaking a lie, yet it is so acting or speaking to give a wrong impression, so It Is an underhand lie. Hypocrisy is a pretense of being what one is not, and generally connected with spiritual matters. Envies may be silent also, yet cannot remain covered. All of these may very likely issue in the last mentioned, evil speaking. Let us learn to abhor such evil. and turn decidedly to what is positively good.

Hamilton SmithThe First Epistle of Peter

(1 Peter 2:1). Having been born of the word, and thus having a new nature with new desires, and having the truth whereby we can purify our souls, the Apostle warns us against some of the evils of the old nature which would hinder love to one another, as well as our spiritual growth. We are to lay aside malice that entertains evil thoughts of others, guile that seeks to hide what we are, hypocrisy that pretends to be what we are not, and envy that leads to slandering the one of whom we are envious. Guile and hypocrisy ever accompany malice. The one speaking maliciously of his brother may seek to hide his malice under the plea that he is acting for the good of his brother — this is guile; further, he may profess that he has nothing in his heart but love for his brother — this is hypocrisy. Behind malicious words there is envy, which is the real motive for evil speaking. Truly the wise man says, “Wrath is cruel, and anger is outrageous; but who is able to stand before envy?” (Proverbs 27:4).

F. B. HoleJohn

Again Jesus took the initiative and by His opening exclamation as to Nathanael revealed Himself as the Discerner of the hearts of men. Here was an Israelite, not without sin, but without guile; that is, without deceit or dishonesty. Here was a man who was straight and honest in his spirit before God; and Jesus knew this, as He showed by His answer to Nathanael's startled question, "Whence knowest Thou me?" The Lord was showing Himself to be the JUDGE of all, before whom all men are naked and open, who can put every man in his proper place. Nathanael came to see Jesus of Nazareth, and he discovered One who knew all about him and read him through and through like an open book. Who could this Jesus be?

F. B. HoleGrace, Guidance, and Government

The groaning must continue until confession takes place. Sin must be acknowledged. The iniquity that had been hidden away in most careful concealment must be dragged into the light of God's presence. Transgressions must be confessed not to man merely, or firstly, but "to the Lord." This, you see, is the exact opposite of guile. It is the complete reversal of the former attitude, the abandonment of all deceit and hypocrisy. It is straightforwardness and honesty in the sight of God.

Verses

  • John 1:47Jesus saw Nathanael coming to him, and says of him, Behold [one] truly an Israelite, in whom there is no guile.
  • Psalms 32:2Blessed is the man unto whom Jehovah reckoneth not iniquity, and in whose spirit there is no guile!
  • 1 Peter 2:1Laying aside therefore all malice and all guile and hypocrisies and envyings and all evil speakings,
  • 1 Peter 2:22who did no sin, neither was guile found in his mouth;
  • 1 Peter 3:10For he that will love life and see good days, let him cause his tongue to cease from evil and his lips that they speak no guile.
  • Psalms 34:13Keep thy tongue from evil, and thy lips from speaking guile;
  • Revelation 14:5and in their mouths was no lie found; [for] they are blameless.
  • 2 Corinthians 12:16But be it so. I did not burden you, but being crafty I took you by guile.