What is a lament in the Bible?
Answered from the commentary of Hamilton Smith, Arno Clemens Gaebelein, L. M. Grant and 17 others
A lament in Scripture is the outpouring of grief and complaint over the dead, over a ruined people, or over one's own affliction, and at its truest it is poured out before the Lord rather than before men. David's lament over Saul and Jonathan in 2 Samuel 1:17-27 is an elegy or dirge, "the outpouring of a tender and faithful heart," with no word of resentment and no note of triumph over a fallen enemy. The Lamentations of Jeremiah are "strains of anguish" over Zion's desolation by the Chaldeans, set out as alphabetic poems. They are the utterance of a broken heart that still vindicates God, owning that Jerusalem's own iniquity was her ruin. The book closes with a prayer of confession and of hope. In the Psalms the repeated cry "How long?" is called the language of faith, which clings to God and knows He will set a limit to the trials of His people. Psalm 102 is headed "a prayer of the afflicted, when he is overwhelmed, and poureth out his complaint before the Lord", and several authors hear in it the very voice of Christ in His sorrow. Israel's outward mourning carried the familiar signs of tears, sackcloth, dust and hired mourning women. In time it degenerated into a shallow professional art, and the Lord rebuked that insincerity.
The comfort these authors draw is that the heart is stilled when it pours everything out before God, doubt included, and finds relief there as nowhere else. The warning that goes with this is plain. God's word permits a groan but never a grumble, and the groan must be carried to the Lord, not spent in complaining to others. Murmuring is unbelief, a judging of God as not to be trusted. For this reason most of them judge Job's lament severely: in it he charged God as the author of his misery, and they call this his "great error" and "wretched unbelief," though God was in fact acting toward him in love. A true lament leads on to self-judgment and confession, and Joshua's lamentation is faulted for lacking this. Godly sorrow works repentance, while the sorrow of the world works death. On whether a Christian may take up the psalmists' complaint that God has forgotten him, or their cries for vengeance, the larger number say no. A believer is never forsaken, and the cry of Psalm 22:1 belongs to Christ alone on the cross. A smaller number hold that believers should still find their sympathies in these psalms, answering their fears with the promise "I will never leave thee". In every case the lament is not meant to end in despair. Jeremiah, in the depth of his dirge, remembers that the Lord's compassions fail not and says, "therefore have I hope" (Lamentations 3:21-24).
Verses: Psalms 13:1, Psalms 13:2, Psalms 13:3, Psalms 13:4, Psalms 13:5, Psalms 13:6, Psalms 22:1, Psalms 22:2, Lamentations 1:1, Lamentations 1:2, Psalms 88:1, Psalms 88:2, Psalms 88:3, Psalms 88:4, Psalms 88:5, Psalms 88:6, Psalms 88:7, Psalms 88:8, Psalms 88:9, Psalms 88:10, Psalms 88:11, Psalms 88:12, Psalms 88:13, Psalms 88:14, Psalms 88:15, Psalms 88:16, Psalms 88:17, Psalms 88:18, 2 Samuel 1:17, 2 Samuel 1:18, 2 Samuel 1:19, 2 Samuel 1:20, 2 Samuel 1:21, 2 Samuel 1:22, 2 Samuel 1:23, 2 Samuel 1:24, 2 Samuel 1:25, 2 Samuel 1:26, 2 Samuel 1:27, Psalms 42:1, Psalms 42:2, Psalms 42:3, Psalms 42:4, Psalms 42:5, Psalms 42:6, Psalms 42:7, Psalms 42:8, Psalms 42:9, Psalms 42:10, Psalms 42:11, Psalms 44:23, Psalms 44:24, Psalms 44:25, Psalms 44:26, Lamentations 3:19, Lamentations 3:20, Lamentations 3:21, Lamentations 3:22, Lamentations 3:23, Lamentations 3:24, Lamentations 3:25, Lamentations 3:26, Habakkuk 1:2, Habakkuk 1:3, Habakkuk 1:4, Jeremiah 20:14, Jeremiah 20:15, Jeremiah 20:16, Jeremiah 20:17, Jeremiah 20:18, Job 3:1, Job 3:2, Job 3:3, Job 3:4, Job 3:5, Job 3:6, Job 3:7, Job 3:8, Job 3:9, Job 3:10, Job 3:11, Psalms 6:1, Psalms 6:2, Psalms 6:3, Psalms 6:4, Psalms 6:5, Psalms 6:6, Psalms 6:7, Psalms 6:8, Psalms 6:9, Psalms 6:10, Psalms 10:1, Psalms 77:1, Psalms 77:2, Psalms 77:3, Psalms 77:4, Psalms 77:5, Psalms 77:6, Psalms 77:7, Psalms 77:8, Psalms 77:9, Psalms 77:10, Psalms 77:11, Psalms 77:12, Psalms 142:1, Psalms 142:2, Matthew 27:46, Lamentations 5:19, Lamentations 5:20, Lamentations 5:21, Lamentations 5:22, Ezekiel 19:1, Psalms 130:1, Psalms 130:2, Romans 12:15, Revelation 6:10
The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.
What the commentators say
The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.
The Lamentations are the expression of a heart full of love for the earthly people of Jehovah, a people punished for their sins by loosing their kingdom, their land, their city and their sanctuary. Jeremiah considers himself as part of these people but thereby repents and puts his hope in spite of all mourning in God.
The Lamentations. It is self-evident that this book is from the pen of Jeremiah. The Septuagint has the following passage: — "And it came to pass after that Israel was taken captive, and Jerusalem was laid waste, that Jeremiah sat weeping and lamented this lamentation over Jerusalem." These strains of anguish uttered over the success of the Chaldean attack upon Jerusalem, and the consequent desolation of city and people, are most touchingly expressed. The death of the godly Josiah (2 Chron. 35:24-25) was the immediate occasion of these strains of unrivalled pathos, as the last hope of Israel died in the death of the godly monarch.
Coming to Jeremiah, we are with a Man of Sorrows. The entire Lamentations are the outpouring of grief as rivers of waters. But amid the tears, faith lays hold of a Saviour. So we have very definite prophecies of the restoration of the people.
That Jeremiah was the writer of the book has been generally acknowledged, and internal evidence of it is afforded in the allusions to his own history it contains. He loved Jerusalem well; for, though Anathoth in Benjamin was the city of his birth, understanding as he did what Jerusalem was in God's counsels, how could he have helped loving her, and that dearly? Her troubles then were a grief of heart to him; and, though he had endured such ill treatment in the city from those high in office, he did not exult over her fall, but tears filled his eyes as he saw the destruction of the daughter of his people, and his heart only found a fitting vent for its feelings in the lamentations he poured forth as dictated by the Spirit of God. Gracious it was of the Lord to allow his afflicted servant this relief, gracious however not to him only, but to others, as surely will be acknowledged some day, when the secrets of all hearts shall be disclosed, and all the ways of God in the times that will then be past, shall be meditated on to His glory.
Bearing these two thoughts in mind, the refusal of the flesh and the setting aside of human government we have in David's lament over Saul and Jonathan, a most fitting and exquisite close to the sad life whose course we have been tracing. Personally, nothing could be more lovely than that David should put the crown upon the course of his own forbearance and lowliness in thus laying a wreath upon the grave of his bitter enemy. It was no formal act, no perfunctory or official threnody which he composed, but the outpouring of a tender and faithful heart which showed even at this time the love which he had evidently had for poor Saul throughout his entire history. Nowhere does the character of David shine out more clearly than it does in the subdued light of this elegy. Unselfishness, the ignoring of Saul's evil, the entire absence of personal resentment and of the slightest note of triumph, all are here present. The love, too, for Jonathan, deeper and sweeter than could possibly be had for Saul, finds here fitting expression. The very brevity of the elegy shows all the more its beauty.
David's lament is the touching expression of the affections of this man of God. A heart full of love has no room for resentment or complaints. If in the past David had wept at unjust accusations and hatred, he has now forgotten everything. There is no word of reproach against the man whose bones now lay under the tamarisk at Jabesh. But it is not enough for this noble heart to merely forget. He loves to remember. He recalls that Saul had been the Lord's anointed, the bearer of His testimony, that he had led His people to victory. He recognizes the natural gifts that had made him pleasant during his life and had attracted Israel's love to him. He sees him magnificently dressing the daughters of his people. His song expresses respect for and grief over the man who had always hated and persecuted him. His lament is Israel's lament — Israel against whom in a day of weakness he had thought to fight by joining himself to the Philistines. David now identifies himself with Israel and shares in its tears. Joy may be the portion of the daughters of the uncircumcised, but never will David share in it. Let the mountains of Gilboa, the witnesses of God's people's defeat, be accursed!
The Prince of Life passed onwards to the house of death. Mourners were already there, making a great tumult with their weeping and wailing. It is a divine injunction to "weep with those that weep," and examples are not wanting in scriptural history. The house of, Joseph and his brethren mourned for the death of Jacob with a "very great and sore lamentation" at Abel-mizraim (Gen. 50:10-11). Job's three friends wept for him in his sorrow, with loud voices, rending their mantles and sprinkling dust on their heads, and then sat with him in silence for seven, days (Job 2). Jeremiah lamented the death of king Josiah (2 Chron. 35:25), and also for the desolation of Jerusalem and of the temple in the book of his Lamentations.
These examples possessed sincerity, but genuine mourning which arises from neighbourly sympathy became perverted into shallow professionalism. Lamentation degenerated into an art, in which some acquired eminence by reason of their skill (Amos 5:16). Mourning women held themselves in readiness to come and take up a wailing for the departed (Jer. 9:17-18), sometimes expressing themselves in elegies (2 Chron. 35:25).
It was the habit of the Hebrews, as it still is in the East, to make a great demonstration of their mourning. They would beat their breasts, cover their heads, fast, put dust and ashes on their heads, neglect their hair, wear dull-coloured garments, rend their clothes, wear sackcloth, etc. For Asa and Zedekiah there was 'great burning' of odours at their death, which was most probably copied from the heathen. 2 Chr. 16:14; Jer. 34:5. At a death professional mourners were hired, mostly women. "Call for the mourning women . . . . let them make haste, and take up a wailing for us, that our eyes may run down with tears, and our eyelids gush out with waters." Jer. 9:17-18; cf. 2 Sam. 14:2; Amos 5:16. Musicians also attended at deaths, who played mournful strains. Matt. 9:23. God does not desire those who are bereaved to be without feeling: the Lord wept at the grave of Lazarus, but He would have reality in all things. He had to say to His people, "Rend your heart, and not your garments." Joel 2:13.
But it is beautiful to see how Abraham flings it all out — doubt and all, casts it down before God. "Pour out your hearts before Him," says the Psalmist; "Be careful for nothing," adds the apostle; "but in every thing by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known unto God." In these very requests, what a multitude of things unworthy of Him! but He who has known them in the heart before would have us pour them out in His presence, and oh the relief that the heart gets so! How many of these workings of unbelief do the psalms thus give us! but they are poured out before God, and the soul stills itself in that blessed presence as no where else can it be stilled. What! we have been asking God if He is God! "O thou afflicted, tossed with tempest, and not comforted," peace! He is indeed the "God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ."
Psalm 142 is the expression of extreme distress, refuge failing him - no man caring for his soul. He cried unto Jehovah with his voice. This, as we have seen, is more than trusting Him. God is known in the revelation of Himself; so we look to the Lord and to a Father's love. But in crying with the voice there is confession of His name, and open acknowledgment of dependence and confiding in the Lord. The heart can open itself out before the Lord, not be careful, but make its requests known. It is a sure sign of confidence, making our trouble known - a great thing to leave such with God. But there is another comfort here; he was in the path of God. And from this grew the sense, of immense importance in the times of trial, that God knew, acknowledged, and had His eye on, as accepting it, the faithful man's path. This is a fountain of strength and comfort. It supposes faith - that realizing that one's way is pleasing to God suffices. The spirit may be overwhelmed by the pressure of enmity and desertion, but the soul is in peace, resting in the approbation of God.
Verses
- Psalms 13:1–61(To the chief Musician. A Psalm of David.) How long, Jehovah, wilt thou forget me for ever? how long wilt thou hide thy face from me? 2How long shall I take counsel in my soul, with sorrow in my heart daily? how long shall mine enemy be exalted over me? 3Consider, answer me, O Jehovah my God! lighten mine eyes, lest I sleep the [sleep of] death; 4Lest mine enemy say, I have prevailed against him! [lest] mine adversaries be joyful when I am moved. 5As for me, I have confided in thy loving-kindness; my heart shall be joyful in thy salvation. 6I will sing unto Jehovah, for he hath dealt bountifully with me.
- Psalms 22:1–21(To the chief Musician. Upon Aijeleth-Shahar. A Psalm of David.) My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? [why art thou] far from my salvation, from the words of my groaning? 2My God, I cry by day, and thou answerest not; and by night, and there is no rest for me