What does the Bible say about forgiveness?
The very word "forgiveness" in the New Testament — the Greek aphesis — means a sending away, a release. As F. B. Hole puts it:
a sending away, a releaseIt signifies simply "a sending away" or "a release" and this is just what a guilty sinner needs as regards his sins. Let them be sent away or dismissed by the One against whom his guilt has been incurred, and what a happy release is his! Now this is just what every child of God is entitled to enjoy. "I write to you little children" said the aged apostle John, "because your sins are forgiven you [are dismissed and sent away] for His name's sake" (1 John 2:12).
The Ground of Forgiveness: The Cross of Christ
The basis of all divine forgiveness is the atoning sacrifice of Christ. God does not forgive by simply overlooking sin — He forgives righteously, on the ground that sin has been fully judged at Calvary.
C. H. Mackintosh addresses this with great clarity:
C. H. MackintoshHere, then, we have the true ground of divine forgiveness. The precious atonement of Christ forms the base of that platform on which a just God and a justified sinner meet in sweet communion. In that atonement I see sin condemned, justice satisfied, the law magnified, the sinner saved, the adversary confounded.
A just God dealt with sin at the cross, in order that a justifying God might deal with the sinner on the new and everlasting ground of resurrection. God could not tolerate or pass over a single jot or tittle of sin; but He could put it away. He has condemned sin. He has poured out His righteous wrath upon sin, in order that He might pour the everlasting beams of His favour upon the believing sinner.
Hamilton Smith makes the same point from Romans 3:
Hamilton SmithThus on the ground of the precious blood of Christ, which is ever before God in all its value, the righteousness of God is towards all proclaiming to all the forgiveness of sins; and the righteousness of God takes effect upon all that believe in clearing such from all their sins.
And on Hebrews 9:
HEBREWSThus the great conclusion is reached that "without shedding of blood is no remission." Here it is not simply the sprinkling of blood, but the "shedding of blood" — the righteous basis upon which God can proclaim forgiveness to all and proclaim all who believe forgiven.
The Extent of Forgiveness: Complete and Eternal
A recurring emphasis is that divine forgiveness is not partial — it covers all the believer's sins, once and for all.
C. H. Mackintosh writes:
C. H. MackintoshAll our sins were before the eye of infinite Justice, at the cross, and all were laid on the head of Jesus the Sin-bearer who, by His death, laid the eternal foundation of forgiveness of sins, in order that the believer, at any moment of his life, at any point in his history, at any stage of his career, from the time at which the hallowed tidings of the gospel fall upon the ear of faith until the moment in which he steps into the glory, may be able to say, with clearness and decision, without reserve, misgiving, or hesitation, "Thou hast cast all my sins behind thy back."
F. B. Hole confirms this from Hebrews:
F. B. HoleIn that great passage it is affirmed no less than six times that the sacrifice of Christ was one and offered once. It is also asserted that those who approach God as worshippers on the ground of His sacrifice are purged once, and consequently draw near with perfected consciences. ... We stand before God in an eternal forgiveness.
Forgiveness for All — but Received Only by Faith
F. B. Hole carefully distinguishes between the offer and its reception:
F. B. HoleInstead of the rejection of Christ being followed by a declaration of war, and the hurling of Heaven's thunderbolts against a rebellious world, God has, as it were, established a lengthy armistice, during which time an amnesty for all rebels is being proclaimed. If any rebel humbles himself and turns to the Saviour in faith, he is forgiven. It is true therefore that there is forgiveness for everybody; but in no sense is it true that everybody is forgiven.
Forgiveness and the Two Aspects in God's Mind
Morrish's Bible Dictionary identifies a twofold character:
Morrish's Bible Dictionary1. The mind and thought of God Himself towards the sinner whom He forgives. On the ground of the sacrifice of Christ, God not only ceases to hold those who have faith in Christ's blood as guilty before Him, but His favour is towards them. "Their sins and iniquities will I remember no more." Heb. 10:17. Thus all sense of imputation of guilt is gone from the mind of God.
2. The guilty one is released, forgiven. "That they may receive forgiveness of sins." Acts 26:18. "As far as the east is from the west, so far hath he removed our transgressions from us." Ps. 103:12.
Forgiveness Distinguished from Deliverance
J. N. Darby draws an important distinction. Forgiveness deals with what we have done; salvation goes further and takes us out of the old position entirely:
J. N. DarbyForgiveness applies to what I have done as the first man. I may sin now, surely, as a Christian, but, if I do, that is the first man — the flesh. Salvation is connected with my condition as a child of Adam. When I speak of sins, I do not say I am saved; I say I am forgiven.
What salvation has done is not the merely forgiving me my sins; forgiveness, cleansing, justifying, applies to my responsible and guilty condition in the first Adam; but salvation applies to my state in the second Man. It is a new creation.
In a separate paper he elaborates:
29011EForgiveness is not deliverance, and they have been a good deal confounded. It is a very common experience, when a person has found peace through the blood of Christ, that the pardoned and justified soul, filled with joy and gladness to find its sins gone, the conscience purged, the sense of divine goodness filling it, thinks that it has done with sin because it is at the time full of joy, and the Lord's goodness and favour; but this is not deliverance.
The Style of Forgiveness: Frank, Joyful, Full-Hearted
God does not forgive grudgingly. C. H. Mackintosh draws on the Lord's parables:
C. H. MackintoshLook, for instance, at Christ's touching word to Simon the Pharisee, in Luke 7. "When they had nothing to pay, he frankly forgave them both." ... The frankness of the style enhances, beyond expression, the value of the substance.
When the man finds his sheep, what does he do? Does he complain of all the trouble, and commence to drive the sheep home before him? Ah! no; this would never do. What then? "He lays it on his shoulders." How? Complaining of the weight or the trouble? Nay; but "rejoicing." Here we have the lovely style.
The Father's Forgiveness: Restoring Communion
Even after the once-for-all judicial forgiveness, there remains a day-by-day aspect for the believer who sins. F. B. Hole explains:
F. B. HoleWe must remember also that God, as Father, does deal with us, His children, as and when we sin. Upon confession we are forgiven and cleansed, for "we have an Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous" (1 John 1:9 – 2:1). But this is the Father's forgiveness, restoring us to communion, and not the eternal forgiveness, which we receive at the outset from Him as Judge of all.
Morrish's Bible Dictionary summarizes the principle:
Morrish's Bible DictionaryThe general principle as to forgiveness is stated in 1 John 1:9; "If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins;" and to this is added, "and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness." This involves honesty of heart, whether in a sinner first coming to God, or in a child who has grieved the heart of the Father by sinning.
Forgiving One Another
Because God has so freely forgiven us, believers are called to extend the same spirit toward others. J. N. Darby applies Ephesians 4:32 directly:
J. N. Darby"Be ye kind one to another, tender-hearted, forgiving one another, even as God for Christ's sake hath forgiven you." Did God come and clamour against you in justice? He sent His Son to give Himself for you, and has forgiven you. There is a man that wronged me; I am going to forgive him, as God forgave me, and (if I am near enough to God to do it) to show out what we have been learning is the joy of our souls.
Morrish's Bible Dictionary adds a solemn warning:
Morrish's Bible DictionaryWe are called upon to forgive one another; and if we indulge in a harsh unforgiving spirit, we must not expect our Father to forgive us in His governmental dealings. Matt. 6:14-15.
In sum, the Bible teaches that forgiveness rests on the finished work of Christ at the cross — the only ground on which a righteous God can dismiss sins. Its extent is total: every sin, past and future, dealt with by the one sacrifice. Its reception is by faith alone. Its style is frank and joyful — the heart of God delighting to forgive. And beyond this foundational, eternal forgiveness that settles the believer's standing forever, there is the Father's forgiveness that restores communion day by day through confession. Finally, the forgiven are called to forgive one another, measuring their grace toward others by the grace God has shown them: "even as God for Christ's sake hath forgiven you" (Eph. 4:32).