True Bible Answers
Log inSign up

What does it mean that God is transcendent?

The answer begins with the very first verse of the Bible. "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth" — and from this one sentence the meaning of transcendence unfolds.

God Is Above and Before Creation

A. J. Pollock gives one of the clearest definitions in all these writings:

We read, however, "In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth." It is clear from this first verse in the Bible that God existed before the creation that He is transcendent, that is to say, as to God's being He is supreme, beyond all limitations, distinct from all that creation which has proceeded from Him.

A. J. Pollock

He adds in another paper:

If God created He existed before He created. The carpenter must exist before he can make a table. God is transcendental, that is, He exists before and outside the universe, which is the result of Divine mental conception, so that through faith we understand that the worlds were framed by the word of God, so that "things which are seen were not made of things which do appear" (Heb. 11:3).

Transcendence vs. Pantheism

Several writers stress that transcendence is the opposite of pantheism — the idea that God is merely the spirit of nature, dissolved into His creation. F. B. Hole draws this contrast sharply from Genesis:

The Pantheist professes a god who is immanent in Nature but not transcendent above it. The God of verse 1 is clearly One outside of Nature and infinitely above it, seeing He made it, and therefore existed before it. From Him all that which we call Nature proceeds.

And from his commentary on Genesis itself:

God is outside and above all that He created and made. Thus, on the seventh day when creation was what we may call "a going concern," God is said to have rested. Thus Pantheism — the idea that God is only to be conceived of as immanent in creation, pervading all nature — is wholly denied. He may indeed act in nature, but He is transcendent, essentially above it in Person and Being.

This is a crucial distinction. The pantheist's god is trapped within his own creation. The God of Scripture stands above and apart from all that He has made. Even the name Elohim in Genesis 1:1 carries this force, as Pollock observes:

Genesis 1:1 alone is decisive, for who could be the transcendent creator but the Supreme Being?

Pollock

The Paradox: Transcendence and Nearness

What makes Scripture's teaching so arresting is that this transcendent God is also a God who draws near. Isaiah 57:15 is one of the great texts on this subject, and A. J. Pollock devotes a whole paper to it:

"For thus says the high and lofty One that inhabits eternity, whose name is holy: I dwell in the high and holy place, with him also that is of a contrite and humble spirit, to revive the spirit of the humble, and to revive the heart of the contrite ones."

A. J. Pollock

He reflects:

There is an immense contrast! A Being so great as to fill all things, to inhabit eternity, yet so gracious, so condescending as to stoop down and dwell in the humble and contrite spirit.

And then this remarkable passage:

God inhabits eternity. He fills all things. He is everywhere. He is the uncreated, self-existent source of all things, yet knowing no source for Himself. He created all things out of nothing. Such a conception satisfies because it is beyond conception. We bow before this glorious Being with holy joy. Our hearts trust Him, for He is utterly beyond the littleness and frailty and sinfulness of men.

C. H. Mackintosh touches on the same wonder with characteristic warmth:

How amazing that the High and Mighty One, who inhabits eternity, should so value the love and remembrance of a poor worm of the earth! Yet so it is, and we ought to bear it more in mind.

C. H. Mackintosh

Transcendence in the Book of Job

Samuel Ridout points to the Book of Job as the great Old Testament treatise on God's transcendent greatness. Commenting on Elihu's address in Job 35, he writes:

He would have Job look up into those very heavens which he thought were against him, and ponder the character of One who is infinitely perfect, unaffected by the puny activities of men on earth, who are as grasshoppers in His sight. How could such an One, infinitely holy, divinely sufficient unto Himself, act unjustly toward one whose conduct may and does affect himself and his fellow-men, but cannot penetrate those serene heights?

Samuel Ridout

Elihu's argument is that God's transcendence is not cold indifference — it is a guarantee of His perfect justice.

Transcendence and the Incarnation

The deepest marvel is that the transcendent God entered His own creation. Samuel Ridout captures this:

This is the wondrous meaning of "Emmanuel," (God with us); not merely as omnipresent, filling heaven and earth and transcending all the bounds of His vast universe, but (amazing thought!) in the person of One who emptied Himself and took a servant's form and was made in the likeness of men — of One who was perfect Man in the fullest sense of the word, spirit, soul and body — "the Man Christ Jesus."

Samuel Ridout

He adds:

We do not go further into details of this transcendent fact which God has been pleased to reveal to us. "Will God in very truth dwell with man?" — there had been glimpses of this, but now it is an accomplished fact.

To say that God is transcendent, then, is to say that He exists before, above, and apart from everything He has made. He is not a force dissolved into the universe. He made the universe and stands infinitely above it in His own Person and Being. Yet the glory of Scripture is that this same God — "the high and lofty One that inhabiteth eternity" — stoops to dwell with the contrite heart, and has entered His own creation in the person of His Son. Transcendence, far from making God remote, is what makes His nearness in grace so breathtaking.

What does it mean that God is transcendent? | True Bible Answers