What does it mean that God is spirit?
God is spirit — that is Jesus' answer to a woman who wanted to know which mountain was the right place to worship. The statement is about what God is in His own being, and Jesus draws a direct line from that nature to the kind of worship God accepts.
What "spirit" says about God's being
The words describe God's essence, not just one quality among others. One writer draws out what follows for God's presence:
William J HockingIt refers to His being, to the Person. He has no bodily shape. He is not confined as we are, and He is an omnipresent spirit, so that though He is in heaven, He is here, and we, being spirit, are in His presence.
(Hocking was working from an older translation reading "God is a Spirit.")
Because He has no body, He cannot be measured or contained:
W. H. WestcottIt stands to reason that no one has ever seen God. We can take account of a thing if it is twenty miles long or wide, and if it is a solid substance that can be weighed. But can we imprison the wind to measure it, or say where the light ends? God is a Spirit; and heaven, and the highest heaven cannot contain Him. He is everywhere present throughout this vast universe, greater than all He has created, not subject to change or break-up.
Why no image can represent Him
If God is spirit, then carving Him into gold or stone is doubly absurd — the material is His own creature, and the shape is human invention.
William KellyIt is in the immaterial side of his nature that man is God's offspring. His soul and spirit alone come from God's inbreathing... The sculpting of these material substances by man's skill and imagination only adds absurdity to absurdity. For the material was itself a creature of God; and the shape given to each was man's fancy and manufacture.
Israel's own worship guarded this. In the innermost place of the tabernacle, above the mercy seat where God met His people, there was no figure of God at all:
Samuel RidoutHow perfectly in keeping with all His truth it is that, in those days of partial revelation, of type and shadow, God should have most jealously guarded the idea of His infinitely glorious being from any likeness or representation, so common among the surrounding nations.
The end of sacred places
The woman asked about Gerizim, the Samaritan mountain, or Jerusalem. Jesus set aside both — and did not replace them with a third site.
Samuel RidoutIn their place He put nothing of earth; only spirit and truth was to mark all worship — it was to be according to the nature of God.
The same principle reaches every ceremony built from material things:
C CrainHe is emphasising the fact that, since God is of a spirit substance, it is unsuitable to worship Him with material things — with shadows. He should be worshipped in spirit and reality.
"Must" — a necessity, not a preference
Jesus does not recommend spiritual worship as the better option. He says worshippers must worship this way, because worship has to match the One being worshipped.
William J HockingThis is not a matter of choice, but of necessity. But apart from the working of the Spirit within us, and apart from that truth which Christ has expressed in His life and in His death, we cannot worship Him in this way. How simple, yet how solemn!
Worship "in spirit and in truth"
The two words cut in opposite directions, ruling out both empty ceremony and mere human reasoning:
F. B. HoleWorship must be "in spirit," the very opposite of being "in flesh," as ritualism supposes. It must be "in truth" (that is, in godly recognition of all that God is as perfectly revealed in Christ, for "truth" connects itself with the knowledge of God), in contrast to being "in nature" or "in reason," as rationalism supposes.
This is not something a person can generate by effort. It requires a nature that matches God's own:
William KellyIt is a necessity of His nature, and of theirs too, since believers have become partakers of it by His grace... If you are true worshippers, see to it that your worship is, according to His will, "in spirit and truth," not in forms or falsehood.
The God who is spirit is revealed as Father
Jesus does not leave the woman with an abstraction. The invisible God is made known in a relationship.
F. B. HoleThe law had tied people down very strictly to a holy place where Jehovah's name was set; hence the long dispute between Jew and Samaritan. He lifted her thoughts to God who is a Spirit, revealing Him as Father.
Summary
- Nature. God is spirit in His very being — no body, no shape, contained by nothing, present everywhere.
- Therefore no image. Nothing carved, weighed or measured can represent Him; even the mercy seat carried no likeness of God.
- Therefore no place. Gerizim and Jerusalem both fall away, and nothing on earth is put in their place.
- Therefore this way only. Worship must answer to His nature — "in spirit," not in flesh; "in truth," according to God as revealed in Christ.
- And so, this Father. The One who cannot be seen is made known as Father, and He is the one seeking worshippers.