What does it mean that a man's heart plans his ways, but the Lord directs his steps (Proverbs 16:9)?

Answered from the commentary of William Kelly, L. M. Grant, Hamilton Smith and 3 others

It means that a person may plan what he intends to do, but the Lord directs his steps, so he is not in control of the way he goes. Planning is right when it is subject to God: plans should leave room for Him to change them, and should be brought into line with His will. The Lord’s direction calls for dependence on Him and obedience to His Word, rather than trusting one’s own way.

Most plainly, the counsel is to trust the Lord to direct the way; one commentary warns against relying on human plans, while another says believers should plan with their plans kept flexible before Him. Even when plans fail or are mistaken, the Lord can overrule them for blessing. Circumstances by themselves do not show whether a person is following the Lord’s will.

Verses: Proverbs 16:9, Proverbs 16:1, Proverbs 19:21, Proverbs 20:24, Proverbs 16:3, James 4:13, James 4:14, James 4:15, Jeremiah 10:23, Psalms 37:23, Psalms 37:24, Proverbs 3:5, Proverbs 3:6, Romans 8:28

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

L. M. GrantProverbs

"A man's heart plans his way, but the Lord directs his steps" (v. 9). A man may spend hours in planning what he will do, but the believer might well spare himself such hours of planning, and rather depend on the Lord to direct him in the way that is good. Of course we should not act without considering the way we go, but it is vital that a believer should take the Lord into his plans, leaving those plans flexible enough to allow the Lord occasion to change them if He will, and with the full confidence that the Lord will direct us rightly.

William KellyProverbs

The heart of man away from God is lawless; and, shaking off the restraint of Him to whom he belongs and must give account, is fruitful of devices. As he loves his own way, so he changes it according to the object before him, or, it may be, some passing fancy. Jehovah alone can direct his steps; but this supposes dependence on Him and obedience to His Word, when it is His way, and not the man's own. So Moses (Ex. 23:13), when Israel forsook him and bowed down to the golden calf, prays, Show me Thy way.

Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe Book Of Proverbs

Comforting to faith is the ninth verse. We may devise, plan, and often worry as we make our plans but behind it stands the LORD and in spite of our failures and mistakes "He directeth" the steps of the righteous.

Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe Book Of Proverbs

The name Jehovah (LORD) appears eleven times in this chapter of Proverbs. The Lord has the final word, for to man belong the preparations (or plans) of the heart; but from the LORD is the answer of the tongue. It is the same thought as in our English proverb--"Man proposes--God disposes." Man loves to justify himself, his ways are clean in his own eyes; but the LORD weigheth the spirits; He is the judge of ways and motives. Our works are to be committed (literal: rolled upon) unto the LORD, then establishment and blessing will follow. It is strange that these three verses were omitted in the Septuagint version of the Old Testament.

VariousOn Giving

Perfection of order is of God, and system is God's plan. It is only when man makes a system, which interferes with God's system, and shuts out the action of the Spirit, that it is wrong. It is right to plan, if it be in subjection to the will of God. (See James 4:15.)

Michael VogelsangHow the Gospel came to Europe

We all have to make plans — in our daily lives as well as in the service of the Lord. The apostle also had plans or ideas about what he wanted to do. But we can learn a vital lesson from him: he was always dependant on the guidance of his Lord. He was sensitive to see when the Lord clearly wanted to change his plans and guide him in another direction.

A. J. PollockThe Tabernacle's Typical Teaching

Thus God would teach us the lesson of dependence, and how we should ever seek His guidance. We are not sufficient of ourselves to map out our own paths, whether as individuals, or in relation to the Church of God. How full of thoughtful care are all God's ways. We may well trust Him to do far better for us than we can do for ourselves.

C. H. MackintoshNumbers 9 - 16, Section 2 of 3

Now this will, assuredly, involve the surrender of our own will, our own plans, our own management altogether. We must follow the cloud; we must wait ever — wait only upon God. We cannot say, "We shall go here or there, do this or that, to-morrow, or next week. "All our movements must be placed under the regulating power of that one commanding sentence — often alas! lightly penned and uttered by us — "If the Lord will."

A. J. PollockDoes God Plan Our Lives?

How true it is that God orders our lives, if we will only trust Him step by step.

J. N. DarbyPilgrim Portions

The steps of a good man are ordered by Jehovah. This is a vast and precious blessing. … A young Christian may, in confiding zeal, not see so much the value of this … but when one has seen the world, what a pathless wilderness it is; it is beyond all price that the Lord directs our steps.

Verses

  • Proverbs 16:9The heart of man deviseth his way, but Jehovah directeth his steps.
  • Proverbs 16:1The purposes of the heart are of man, but the answer of the tongue is from Jehovah.
  • Proverbs 19:21Many are the thoughts in a man's heart, but the counsel of Jehovah, that doth stand.
  • Proverbs 20:24The steps of a man are from Jehovah; and how can a man understand his own way?
  • Proverbs 16:3Commit thy works unto Jehovah, and thy thoughts shall be established.
  • James 4:13–1513Go to now, ye who say, To-day or to-morrow will we go into such a city and spend a year there, and traffic and make gain, 14ye who do not know what will be on the morrow, ([for] what [is] your life? It is even a vapour, appearing for a little while, and then disappearing,) 15instead of your saying, If the Lord should [so] will and we should live, we will also do this or that.