What did God create on the second day of creation?

On the second day of creation week God spoke again, and a space opened up in the middle of the waters — an expanse He named Heaven. The record raises real questions: which "heaven" is this, if heaven was already made in verse 1, and why is the usual verdict "it was good" missing from this day alone?

The work itself

The day's work was a second act of dividing, and it produced the air that wraps the planet.

On the second day a "firmament," or "expanse," was called into being. As a result of this a further division took place; not now of light from darkness but of waters from waters. God called this expanse, Heaven... As the result of the work of the second day the earth was surrounded with an atmosphere. It was accomplished by His word, "God said … and it was so."

F. B. Hole

Which heaven

Heaven was already named in the opening verse, so the second day's "Heaven" looks like a repetition. Commentators answer that Scripture speaks of more than one heaven.

We find under the second day, then, the lower heaven. And that this is not a merely Jewish idea, but of God, is perfectly certain from the New Testament; for there we read how Paul was caught up (at any rate "a man in Christ," who, I have no doubt, was Paul) into the third heaven... There is the heaven of His presence; the heaven of the stars, planets, and other astronomical objects; and the atmospheric heaven necessary for man and living things here below.

William Kelly

Expanse, not a metal dome

The older English word "firmament" has been used to accuse the Bible of picturing a hard vault overhead. The Hebrew word does not carry that idea.

It is now generally known, as it had long been laid down by the most competent Hebraists before modern science existed, that "expanse" is the real force of the original word, instead of "firmament" which came to us through the Latin Vulgate... Now the usage of the word even in the chapter itself (vers. 15, 17, 20, 28) sufficiently proves that the word conveys the idea of the open transparent sky.

William Kelly

Waters above and waters below

The two bodies of water separated that day are not the same kind of water, and the difference serves us daily. (Where the writer says "firmament," the ESV reads "expanse.")

God makes a division now between these waters and the vapors above. There is marked distinction between them. The waters upon the earth are the salt, bitter waters of the ocean; while those above, though drawn from the ocean, are perfectly fresh. It is beautiful to see how these waters in vast and inconceivable volume are suspended in those "balancing clouds" which lift them above the earth and yet hold them in connection with it, ever ready to pour down in beneficent rain the treasures which they hold.

Samuel Ridout

Take that arrangement away and nothing on earth could live.

Man's attention was impressively drawn to His considerate and almighty goodness Who then separated "waters from waters," which otherwise had filled space above the earth with continual vapour and without that due mixture of gases which constitutes the air essential to all life on the globe... a black sky had otherwise cast its constant pall over the earth.

William Kelly

Why no "and God saw that it was good"

Every other day of the week closes with God's approval. One explanation ties the omission to the kind of work done.

Nothing was made the second day, i.e., any new thing; the separation of waters above and below, leaving the heavens free as a firmament between, was not a new substance created, hence it is not said to be very good.

J. N. Darby

A day, not an age

Whatever long periods may lie behind Genesis 1:2, the writers hold that each day's work was quick.

There is no real reason to doubt, but plain and positive scripture to believe, that the work done on the several six days was not of long ages, but really within the compass of the literal evening and morning. How unnatural to suppose an age for light to act on the first day! And why suppose otherwise on the second day or any other?

William Kelly

What the day pictures

Commentators differ on the spiritual picture. Some see in it the two lines of God's dealings, heavenly and earthly; others read it as a lesson in dependence.

If the first day symbolizes God's beginning His work in a soul by new birth, the second day illustrates the fact that one is caused to look up to recognize that true blessing comes from above, and therefore that authority also is from above. "The heavens do rule" (Dan. 4:26)... yet in being refreshed by the pure water of God's word from above in true subjection to the Lord Jesus, the believer's life may be greatly changed from disorder into calm, orderly obedience, even when surrounded by the swelling seas of the world's confusion.

L. M. Grant

Summary

- Spoken — God said, and it was so; the expanse came by His word alone, with no material needed.

- Divided — the one act of the day split waters from waters, salt seas below, fresh clouds above.

- Named — He called the expanse Heaven: not the heaven of His presence, nor of the stars, but the air we breathe.

- Unpronounced — alone among the days it lacks "it was good," which Darby links to nothing new being created that day.

- Depended on — the sky He hung that day still sends the rain, and still teaches that blessing and rule come from above.

Reviewed by Orion on August 24, 2026