What are the decrees of God?
Scripture speaks of the "decrees," "counsels," and "purposes" of God — those settled determinations made in eternity, before the foundation of the world, according to which He has ordered all things for His own glory. These terms are closely related but carry distinct shades of meaning, and the writers represented here are careful to distinguish what Scripture actually reveals from what human systems of theology have attempted to build upon them.
God's Purpose Is Eternal and Self-Originated
The great starting-point is that God's purposes originate in Himself — not in response to anything in the creature. They are "eternal" in the fullest sense: formed before the world began, rooted in God's own nature and good pleasure.
J.N. Darby traces how, in the Epistle to the Ephesians, the Spirit begins entirely with God — His thoughts and counsels — rather than with man's condition:
J.N. DarbyHe begins here entirely with God, His thoughts and His counsels, not with what man is. We may lay hold of the truth, so to speak, by one or the other of two ends — by that of the sinner's condition in connection with man's responsibility, or by that of the thoughts and eternal counsels of God in view of His own glory. The latter is that side of the truth on which the Spirit here makes us look. Even redemption, all glorious as it is in itself, is consigned to the second place, as the means by which we enjoy the effect of God's counsels.
The assembly (church) itself, Darby notes, was "the special object of His eternal purpose":
ephesians3Here was a kind of wisdom altogether new; a thing outside the world, hitherto shut up in the mind of God, hid in Himself so that there was no promise or prophecy of it, but the special object of His eternal purpose; connected in a peculiar way with the One who is the centre and the fulness of the mystery of godliness.
He further affirms:
1878_102_Gods_PurposesI do not doubt that God's purposes are in their nature eternal, and He purposed the mystery in Christ Jesus.
The Three-fold Object of God's Purpose
A writer in The Bible Treasury lays out the scope of God's declared purpose with remarkable clarity, showing that it embraces three distinct spheres — all converging upon Christ:
1880_155_Declared_PurposeIn the Bible there are three distinct objects about which God has a purpose: first, the material world and man in general; secondly, Israel, as a chief and special people on and for the earth; and thirdly, the saints destined for heaven, including the church, of which Christ is the Head, and which is also the habitation of God by the Spirit. These are three different lines, yet connected, and converging to one point.
The same writer traces this purpose back to God's fundamental desire to be known — not only as Creator, but as Saviour:
There we learn His purpose before the world was made to manifest Himself, not only as a God that can create, and judge or destroy, but also as a God that can save. ... Every doctrine contained in it, every fact therein recorded, each and all are subservient to this one great unchanging purpose. God will be a Saviour-God.
And the grand culmination:
1880_155_Declared_PurposeIn eternity, when the new heavens and the new earth shall have been created, when Christ shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father, that God may be all in all ... then will the full and blessed accomplishment of His eternal counsel be celebrated, and there will be an intelligent and redeemed creation chanting the praises and the glories of a Saviour-God. A word was sufficient to create; but to make a sinful yet an intelligent and responsible creature a worshipper, required the work and the blood of His own Son.
Election and Predestination — What God Has Decreed for His Own
William Kelly opens up Ephesians 1 to show that God's purpose for the individual believer has two aspects — election (chosen to be holy and blameless before Him) and predestination (appointed to the relationship of sons):
William KellyElection is to fitness for His presence in a nature like His own. Predestination is to a relationship, as like as possible to His Son's. But scripture carefully excludes any such human inference as God's predestination to hell fire. ... Their own sins fitted those vessels of wrath to destruction.
And concerning the scope of God's purpose for His people:
purposeBut at a time of utter evil it suited God to divulge the secret of His purpose. From before the foundation of the world He chose us Christians, in Christ, that we should be holy and blameless before Him in love. He would surround Himself above with beings like Himself: holy in nature, blameless in ways; and love, their animating principle as it is His own.
No Decree of Reprobation
A marked feature of these writers is their unanimous rejection of the doctrine of reprobation — the idea that God decreed certain persons to damnation.
C.H. Mackintosh is particularly emphatic in his paper "One-sided Theology":
C.H. MackintoshThere is no such thing set forth in scripture as any decree of God consigning a certain number of the human race to eternal damnation. Some may be judicially given over to blindness because of deliberate rejection of the light. ... All who perish will have only themselves to blame. All who reach heaven will have to thank God.
He points to a careful distinction in Scripture itself:
ONESIDEDIn speaking of the "vessels of wrath," He says "fitted to destruction" — fitted not by God surely, but by themselves. On the other hand, when He speaks of the "vessels of mercy," he says, "which He had afore prepared to glory." The grand truth of election is fully established; the repulsive error of reprobation, sedulously avoided.
Frank Hole makes the same point:
Frank HoleIs it likely that God will tell us, who are but His creatures, the motives that underlie His decrees? If He did explain, would our finite minds be able to grasp the explanation? We may rest assured that all His decrees are in perfect harmony with the fact that "God is light" and "God is love."
And regarding the suggestion that some are excluded by a fatalistic decree:
ElectionDoes a sinner wish to insinuate that he is very anxious to believe, but that God will not give him ability to do so because of certain fatalistic decrees? Tell him plainly it is not true. He is leaving sober fact for the nightmare of fallen reason.
A writer in The Bible Treasury on "The Sovereignty of God" (taking Pharaoh's case) underscores the same principle:
1873_345_Sovereignty_God_Pharaohs_CaseMan is always held for a responsible being, and is judged and condemned for his own sins, and not by any predetermined decree of God.
In the case of the wicked, so far from being elected to eternal misery, we find that God endures them — vessels of wrath — with much longsuffering, fitted not by Him but by their own deeds for destruction. The word Katartizo means to correct, repair, mend; then in its participial form fitted, prepared. The word does not suppose a decree of God, but a work of man.
Sovereignty and Responsibility Held Together
L.M. Grant captures how the counsels of God in grace are sovereign yet do not override human responsibility:
L.M. GrantGod had purposed in eternal counsel the blessing of Gentiles on an equal basis with Jews, as it is this day. ... These chapters are of utmost importance to a right understanding of prophecy and all God's dispensational ways.
Frank Hole wisely counsels that the two truths must be held in faith, not flattened into a logical system:
Frank HoleAfter all, these are matters which lie beyond the reach of finite minds. Is it likely that God would reveal to us such secrets of His high and eternal counsels as must lie on the plane of infinity? If He did, should we be any the wiser? No! It is well for us to call a halt here and say with the Psalmist, "Such knowledge is too wonderful for me: it is high, I cannot attain to it."
In summary, what Scripture reveals about the decrees of God is this: God's purposes are eternal — formed before the foundation of the world, not in reaction to events. They originate in His own good pleasure, not in anything foreseen in the creature. They encompass three great spheres — the material creation, Israel as God's earthly people, and the church as His heavenly people — all to be headed up in Christ. At their heart is God's desire to be known as a Saviour-God: not merely Creator and Judge, but the One who, at the cost of His own Son's blood, brings sinful creatures into the intimate relationship of sons, holy and blameless before Him in love. Yet Scripture is equally clear that there is no decree of reprobation: election is unto blessing, and those who perish do so through their own rejection of the light, not by any divine decree. The two truths — God's sovereign purpose and man's moral responsibility — stand side by side in Scripture and are both to be believed, even where finite minds cannot fully reconcile them.