John 10:10 Commentary
"The thief cometh not, but for to steal, and to kill, and to destroy: I am come that they might have life, and that they might have it more abundantly."
John 10:10 stands at the hinge between the Lord's presentation of Himself as the Door (vv. 7–9) and His declaration as the Good Shepherd (vv. 11–18). In the first half He exposes what all false leaders bring; in the second, He declares what He alone came to give.
The Thief: Stealing, Killing, Destroying
J.N. Darby sets the verse against the whole context of Israel's failed leadership:
J.N. Darby"The thief" (all else were so), "cometh not, save to steal, and kill, and destroy." It was for himself, not the sheep, he came.
The thief's motives are entirely selfish — he comes for his own gain, not for the welfare of the flock. Frank Hole identifies these false leaders historically:
Frank HoleThese thieves and robbers were men such as those mentioned by Gamaliel, in Acts 5:36-37; self-seeking imposters who brought in destruction and death.
Men like Theudas and Judas of Galilee drew followers after themselves by false pretensions, only to bring ruin. William Kelly presses the point further, tracing it to its ultimate source:
William Kelly"The thief cometh not but to steal and slay and destroy." This Satan loves, and his servants are many.
In his larger commentary on John, Kelly expands on the moral principle at work:
John_pt2Outside Christ is sin and misery. Such is the world; and of all the world no part so delusive, so selfish, so fatal to itself and all governed by it, as the religious world and its leaders, the leaders now of infidelity as well as of superstition. Here is the testimony of Christ, of Him Who is the truth; "the thief cometh not unless that he may steal, and slaughter, and destroy." No creature can rise above his level; what, then, can the creature do that is steeped in unremoved evil and selfishness? It may sink indefinitely; it cannot possibly rise above itself.
H.H. Snell, writing in the Bible Treasury, draws out the contrast concisely:
H.H. SnellAs to the thief, he came to steal, to kill, and to destroy. His object was to benefit himself, and that by covetous and dishonest means, and by inflicting suffering and loss on the sheep.
Leslie Grant summarises the thief's work plainly:
Leslie GrantThe thief (a false spiritual leader) had the object of stealing, killing and destroying, causing the ruination of God's work (v. 10).
"I Am Come That They Might Have Life"
The second half of the verse turns from destruction to gift, from the thief to the Shepherd, from death to life. Darby draws out the condition of the sheep before Christ came:
Darby"I am come that they might have life, and that they might have it more abundantly." They were sheep who were alive within the fold, but their life was feeble and restrained. They longed for this liberty of life (so now Messiah, when He comes, shall give it more abundantly, give liberty to them in bondage, glorious liberty to the children of God).
Under Judaism, the sheep possessed life but in a limited, restrained form. Christ came to replace that feeble condition with something far greater. Kelly identifies this "abundant" life with the power of resurrection:
Kelly"I came," says the Lord, "that they [believers] might have life, and have it abundantly." Here He makes a brief transition to His death and resurrection, that the saved might enjoy life, as they do now, in the power of His resurrection.
In his fuller commentary, Kelly develops this with characteristic depth:
John_pt2How blessed the contrast of Christ! "I came that they might have life, and have abundantly." He was the life, and life was in Him — not light only, but life. All outside Him lay in darkness and death. He not only was sent of the Father, but came, and came that the sheep might have life; and He would give it abundantly, as was most due to His personal glory and His work — a work ever before Him here. Hence it was only in resurrection that He breathed into the disciples. As Jehovah God breathed on Adam, and the man became a living soul, after a different sort from every other living thing on earth; so did He, Who was alike the risen Man and true God, breathe a better life into those who believed on Him. It is life eternal, and this, after all question of sin and law, was settled for faith by His death.
F.W. Grant in the Numerical Bible sees the "abundant" life as the full fruit of Christ's death, resurrection, and the gift of the Spirit:
F.W. GrantThe thief comes only to steal and to kill and to destroy. He on the contrary comes to give life, and that abundantly. Here a power beyond all creature power is seen; a need which is beyond all that the figure would imply. The theme of John's Gospel discloses itself once more: life, which is eternal and His gift, without whose work none could have it.
Grant then explains what "abundantly" means in practice:
FWG_Numerical_Bible24bIts character was manifested as a life of divine acquaintance and communion; but for this communion to be enjoyed aright, it needed to be freed from many great and terrible hindrances: the Cross had to be accomplished; the resurrection of Christ from the dead must give the answer on God's part to the claim of righteousness there made good, that now as risen with Christ we might be possessors of a life triumphant over death, and justified from all that had brought in death, in a recognized place of nearness to God unknown before. There in the place of sons with God, and with the Spirit of sonship to give the enjoyment of the place, the life eternal would at last have its true abundance.
Hole brings the two halves of the verse together and connects the "abundant" life with the full revelation of God in Christ:
HoleThe true Shepherd brought in life; laying down His own life in order to do so. If He had not come and died, there would have been no life at all for sinful men; having done so, life is made available, and it is bestowed in abundant measure upon His sheep. We live in the light of the abundant revelation of God which has reached us in the Word made flesh, hence we have life abundantly. The life given to saints in all ages may be intrinsically the same, yet its fulness can only be known as God is fully revealed. This is indicated in 1 John 1:1-4.
Hamilton Smith draws out the practical enjoyment of this life:
Hamilton SmithAll these blessings lead the sheep into the enjoyment of life, that life of communion with divine Persons that leads to fulness of joy (1 John 1:4). This indeed is the life abundant in contrast with the natural life which even at its best is the life deficient, the life in which the joy fails (John 2:3).
Leslie Grant emphasises that the life always depended on Christ, even before His incarnation:
Leslie GrantChrist, the true Shepherd, came that the sheep might have life and have it more abundantly. What a contrast! For He Himself is the source of life, the living God, on whom the sheep are totally dependent. Of course true believers had life before ever Christ came into the world, but that life was even then dependent on Him, and manifested to be so when He came. He Himself being the full manifestation of eternal life, then in Him, come into the world, the sheep find abundant fullness of life.
Snell adds the resurrection dimension:
SnellAnd in Him who is raised from the dead God has given us life — risen life — life more abundantly than could have been given to man before.
J.G. Bellett captures the pastoral scene — the blind man of chapter 9, cast out by the Pharisees, now taken up by the true Shepherd:
J.G. BellettHad he been left where he was, he would have become a prey to those who were stealing, and killing, and destroying; but that now he was found and taken up of One Who, to give him life, would lay down His own.
Synthesis
The verse divides into two absolute contrasts. Every leader who comes apart from Christ — however impressive, however religious — brings only theft, slaughter, and ruin, because no creature can rise above its own fallen level. But Christ came with a wholly different purpose: to give life. Not merely to sustain what already existed under the old covenant — a life "feeble and restrained," as Darby puts it — but to give it abundantly. That abundance is not vague spiritual enthusiasm. It is the concrete result of the cross and resurrection: sins cleared, the veil removed, the Spirit given, and believers brought into the place of sons with the Father. The life is intrinsically the same eternal life that Old Testament saints possessed by faith, but its conditions have changed — freed now from every hindrance, it can be known and enjoyed in full communion with the Father and the Son. This is the "abundant" life: not more of the same, but life in resurrection power, in the light of full revelation, in the liberty of sonship.