Is raising the dead still possible today?

Answered from the commentary of C. Knapp, A. J. Pollock, The Christian's Friend and 10 others

Yes, God can raise the dead, for resurrection is the sovereign act of His power, and He could work a miracle at any time. But raising the dead is not to be expected as a present-day sign: the signs of the early Church were withdrawn after their purpose was fulfilled, and Scripture gives no warrant to expect their revival. The passages differ in how they state this: some affirm plainly that God can still act, while more speak of the miraculous signs as having ceased or give no warrant to expect them today.

Verses: John 11:25, Acts 9:36, Acts 9:37, Acts 9:38, Acts 9:39, Acts 9:40, Acts 9:41, Acts 9:42, Acts 20:7, Acts 20:8, Acts 20:9, Acts 20:10, Acts 20:11, Acts 20:12, 1 Corinthians 12:9, 1 Corinthians 12:10, 1 Corinthians 12:28, 1 Corinthians 12:30, 1 Corinthians 14:1, 1 Corinthians 14:12, 1 Corinthians 14:39, James 5:14, James 5:15, James 5:16, Matthew 10:7, Matthew 10:8, Matthew 17:19, Matthew 17:20, Mark 16:17, Mark 16:18, Luke 9:1, Luke 9:2, Luke 10:8, Luke 10:9, John 14:12, John 14:13, John 14:14, John 16:23, John 16:24, Acts 3:1, Acts 3:2, Acts 3:3, Acts 3:4, Acts 3:5, Acts 3:6, Acts 3:7, Acts 3:8, Acts 3:9, Acts 3:10, Acts 4:29, Acts 4:30, Acts 4:31, Acts 14:8, Acts 14:9, Acts 14:10, Acts 19:11, Acts 19:12, Hebrews 2:3, Hebrews 2:4, 1 Kings 17:17, 1 Kings 17:18, 1 Kings 17:19, 1 Kings 17:20, 1 Kings 17:21, 1 Kings 17:22, 1 Kings 17:23, 1 Kings 17:24, 2 Kings 4:18, 2 Kings 4:19, 2 Kings 4:20, 2 Kings 4:21, 2 Kings 4:22, 2 Kings 4:23, 2 Kings 4:24, 2 Kings 4:25, 2 Kings 4:26, 2 Kings 4:27, 2 Kings 4:28, 2 Kings 4:29, 2 Kings 4:30, 2 Kings 4:31, 2 Kings 4:32, 2 Kings 4:33, 2 Kings 4:34, 2 Kings 4:35, 2 Kings 4:36, 2 Kings 4:37, 2 Kings 13:20, 2 Kings 13:21, Luke 7:11, Luke 7:12, Luke 7:13, Luke 7:14, Luke 7:15, Luke 7:16, Luke 7:17, Luke 8:49, Luke 8:50, Luke 8:51, Luke 8:52, Luke 8:53, Luke 8:54, Luke 8:55, Luke 8:56, John 11:1, John 11:2, John 11:3, John 11:4, John 11:5, John 11:6, John 11:7, John 11:8, John 11:9, John 11:10, John 11:11, John 11:12, John 11:13, John 11:14, John 11:15, John 11:16, John 11:17, John 11:18, John 11:19, John 11:20, John 11:21, John 11:22, John 11:23, John 11:24, John 11:26, John 11:27, John 11:28, John 11:29, John 11:30, John 11:31, John 11:32, John 11:33, John 11:34, John 11:35, John 11:36, John 11:37, John 11:38, John 11:39, John 11:40, John 11:41, John 11:42, John 11:43, John 11:44, Revelation 11:3, Revelation 11:4, Revelation 11:5, Revelation 11:6, Revelation 11:7, Revelation 11:8, Revelation 11:9, Revelation 11:10, Revelation 11:11, Revelation 11:12, Revelation 11:13

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

Leslie M. GrantComments On Mark

The last verse speaks of the following work of God in disciples as seen in the book of Acts, but does not mention the coming of the Spirit of God. The preaching of Christ is seen to be accompanied by His own working with the disciples and confirming His Word with signs following. This fulfils what the Lord said in verses 17 and 18, and is declared also in Hebrews 2:4. This being fulfilled, there is no reason for us to expect such miracles today. The service of the Lord Jesus continues, but that service is seen in His own servants.

The Christian's FriendNotes of Readings on 1 Corinthians

278 As to the signs, we read, "confirming the word with signs following," as a promise. Moses wrought miracles, and Elijah too, in the midst of apostate Israel. But not so the other prophets. Isaiah and Jeremiah worked no miracles, nor John Baptist. When God is introducing something new, you have them - wherever the thing was to be made good in testimony for our poor hearts to sanction the truth. I see no restoration of miracles, or of anything indeed. There will be miracles at the end on the devil's part: power, and signs, and lying wonders. There was no statement to the church that it must lose them at a certain time, nor that they must go on for a certain time. Some ask as to the continuance of apostles and elders. This was what they said to me in Switzerland: "How can you think of God setting up a church with elders and apostles, and yet making no provision for their continuance?" I said, It is so, because God did not mean the church to continue. We see this to be the way God used miracles. Of course, He could work a miracle at any time.

J. N. DarbyNotes of Readings on 1 Corinthians

278 As to the signs, we read, "confirming the word with signs following," as a promise. Moses wrought miracles, and Elijah too, in the midst of apostate Israel. But not so the other prophets. Isaiah and Jeremiah worked no miracles, nor John Baptist. When God is introducing something new, you have them - wherever the thing was to be made good in testimony for our poor hearts to sanction the truth. I see no restoration of miracles, or of anything indeed. There will be miracles at the end on the devil's part: power, and signs, and lying wonders. There was no statement to the church that it must lose them at a certain time, nor that they must go on for a certain time. Some ask as to the continuance of apostles and elders. This was what they said to me in Switzerland: "How can you think of God setting up a church with elders and apostles, and yet making no provision for their continuance?" I said, It is so, because God did not mean the church to continue. We see this to be the way God used miracles. Of course, He could work a miracle at any time.

Raymond K. CampbellThe Church Of The Living God

In the latter part of the New Testament we read little about miracles, less and less as time passes on. Miracles in the Old Testament never continued, but were exceptional events at the beginning of a new work of God. So doubtless these miraculous powers were temporary gifts to the early Church. With the Church in disorder, division, and rebellion today, the Spirit is grieved and cannot act in full manifestation of mighty signs and thus put His outward seal on such a mass of confusion. We are aware that various ones claim to possess these gifts today, but the true marks of the Spirit's work are missing and we cannot accept their claims as genuine.

Samuel RidoutLecture 4

In this same epistle (chapter 14) we are told that the gift of tongues is not for ordinary use, but as a special sign. The same is true, I doubt not, with the other supernatural gifts, of miracles and healing. They are the sign-gifts for the special authentication of the messenger. I do not dwell, therefore, at length upon these sign-gifts, not only for the reason already stated, as to their being more particularly connected with the founding of Christianity, but because they, as distinct signs of divine approval, would ill accord with the present state of division in the Church. God cannot authenticate what is contrary to His will; and while I do not doubt He meets faith in the individual, and even heals the sick in answer to the prayer of faith, I do not judge that Scripture warrants us to look for these special manifestations in a day of ruin and declension like this.

William J. HockingSpeaking with Tongues

It is impossible, however, to discover in this second chapter of the Acts any suggestion that there would be a continuance of these miraculous signs in the assembly to the present time. No believer would question that such a thing is impossible, for “with God all things are possible.” This is a fundamental and unchanging truth. But we must inquire, not what God can do, but whether the revelation of His ways warrants us to believe that He will do a certain thing. In this case, we find no such evidence, but we do find that tongues with other signs marked the commencement of a new era which was in sharp contrast with its predecessor. Pentecost initiated the period during which Christ is on high and the Spirit on earth, in which grace succeeds law and faith succeeds works, and in which the overtures of mercy and salvation are extended to the ends of the earth. As soon as the body of the disciples of Christ had assumed its cosmopolitan character, and the gospel had secured believers, and consequently fresh witnesses, throughout the world (Col. 2:6), the need for supernatural signs disappeared, and the display of New Testament miracles appears to have ceased.

Numerical Bible NotesThe Gospels

Thus we are brought very near to the actual condition of things that obtains in Christendom today. Nor do the Lord's words make that condition a hard matter to reconcile with them. The signs did follow, and fulfilled the object for which they were designed. As Christianity became known; and the truth came to get hearing, the miraculous accompaniments ceased, after the manner of all such whenever their purpose was fulfilled. Miracles have always been temporary, gathering around certain crises in the divine history of mankind, times of special divine intervention, and then passing away; and Christianity is no exception to the rule. As to power for conviction; where the word of God is once fairly before men; the Lord Himself has assured us that, if they believe not Moses and the prophets, neither will they be persuaded, though one rose from the dead.

Hamilton SmithMark

The Lord tells His disciples that signs should follow them that believe. In Christ's name they would cast out demons, speak with tongues, and heal the sick. It is to be noticed that the Lord does not say that these signs would follow all that believe, or that they would continue for all time. It is well to distinguish between the sign-gifts referred to by the Apostle in 1 Corinthians 12:29-30, and the nourishment gifts of Ephesians 4:11. The sign-gifts in Corinthians were given to the early church for a public testimony, to attract the attention of an unbelieving world. The gifts for the nourishment of the body came from the ascended Head. Seeing that the church has entirely broken down in responsibility, the Lord ceases to call attention to a ruined church by outward and miraculous signs. But though the church is shorn of her outward ornaments, the Lord does not cease to love and nourish His body; thus the gifts of Ephesians go on to the end.

William KellyThe Christian Annotator 1854

The power of working miracles, p. 142. — It is evident that your correspondent does not know that the onus probandi lies upon those who assert such a power, and not upon those who deny it. All that the close of Mark 16 can be made legitimately to prove is, that certain miraculous signs were to follow them that believe. And they did, as is shown in the Acts of the Apostles. The Lord does not here or anywhere else guarantee their continuance to the end. What makes this the more striking is, that in Matt. 28 He does promise to be with His disciples alway, even unto the end of the age; but there is no promise that He would give signs till then.

The Bible TreasuryA Letter on Faith-Healing

That Lazarus was both a testimony and a figure of the Lord's ways with His earthly people, can hardly be questioned; yet is it no less an encouragement to the believer, in the feelings and sympathy of Jesus, before the display of His power, as the Son of God, in raising the objects of His affection from the dead. It is incontestable that many miracles and cures were done by the apostles after the Lord Jesus ascended. Acts 3 is specially chosen to encourage those advocating faith-healing. This, if looked into, will be seen to be a special and further testimony to those who had crucified their Messiah, giving evidence to the loving power in the name of Jesus. "Ye men of Israel," etc. If convinced by it, and bowing to God's object in it, by judging themselves, and owning their sin, then the promised times of refreshing would come, and Jesus return from heaven, and earthly blessedness dawn under the rule of their Messiah. It was, like others, a sample of the powers of the age to come, as spoken of in Hebrews 6:5. Compare it with what is said in Heb. 2 of God bearing witness to the great salvation, spoken first by the Lord, and confirmed by those who had heard, and afterwards received the Holy Ghost sent down from heaven.

That signs were given, and wonders wrought in the early moments of the church is most unquestionable; but were these to continue any more than the apostles themselves? This would be to lose sight of much unfolded in later inspiration, in those Epistles particularly which mark the corruption and apostasy of the last days. If the Lord Jesus is the same, and the presence of the Spirit ever-abiding, yet who would contend that the ways of God, as to outward power, are the same at the close of the church's history as at the beginning? It was not so with Israel even in Ezra's day — much less at a later; and shall it be expected of the church in its present ruin state, however truly God's purpose and our moral responsibility remain unchanged?

Verses

  • John 11:1–441Now there was a certain [man] sick, Lazarus of Bethany, of the village of Mary and Martha her sister. 2It was [the] Mary who anointed the Lord with ointment and wiped his feet with her hair, whose brother Lazarus was sick. 3The sisters therefore sent to him, saying, Lord, behold, he whom thou lovest is sick. 4But when Jesus heard [it], he said, This sickness is not unto death, but for the glory of God, that the Son of God may be glorified by it. 5Now Jesus loved Martha, and her sister, and Lazarus. 6When therefore he heard, He is sick, he remained two days then in the place where he was. 7Then after this he says to his disciples, Let us go into Judaea again. 8The disciples say to him, Rabbi, [even but] now the Jews sought to stone thee, and goest thou thither again? 9Jesus answered, Are there not twelve hours in the day? If any one walk in the day, he does not stumble, because he sees the light of this world; 10but if any one walk in the night, he stumbles, because the light is not in him. 11These things said he; and after this he says to them, Lazarus, our friend, is fallen asleep, but I go that I may awake him out of sleep. 12The disciples therefore said to him, Lord, if he be fallen asleep, he will get well. 13But Jesus spoke of his death, but they thought that he spoke of the rest of sleep. 14Jesus therefore then said to them plainly, Lazarus has died. 15And I rejoice on your account that I was not there, in order that ye may believe. But let us go to him. 16Thomas therefore, called Didymus, said to his fellow disciples, Let us also go, that we may die with him. 17Jesus therefore [on] arriving found him to have been four days already in the tomb. 18Now Bethany was near Jerusalem, about fifteen stadia off, 19and many of the Jews came to Martha and Mary, that they might console them concerning their brother. 20Martha then, when she heard Jesus is coming, went to meet him; but Mary sat in the house. 21Martha therefore said to Jesus, Lord, if thou hadst been here, my brother had not died; 22but even now I know, that whatsoever thou shalt ask of God, God will give thee. 23Jesus says to her, Thy brother shall rise again. 24Martha says to him, I know that he will rise again in the resurrection in the last day. 25Jesus said to her, I am the resurrection and the life he that believes on me, though he have died, shall live; 26and every one who lives and believes on me shall never die. Believest thou this? 27She says to him, Yea, Lord; I believe that thou art the Christ, the Son of God, who should come into the world. 28And having said this, she went away and called her sister Mary secretly, saying, The teacher is come and calls thee. 29She, when she heard [that], rises up quickly and comes to him. 30Now Jesus had not yet come into the village, but was in the place where Martha came to meet him. 31The Jews therefore who were with her in the house and consoling her, seeing Mary that she rose up quickly and went out, followed her, saying, She goes to the tomb, that she may weep there. 32Mary therefore, when she came where Jesus was, seeing him, fell at his feet, saying to him, Lord, if thou hadst been here, my brother had not died. 33Jesus therefore, when he saw her weeping, and the Jews who came with her weeping, was deeply moved in spirit, and was troubled, 34and said, Where have ye put him? They say to him, Lord, come and see. 35Jesus wept. 36The Jews therefore said, Behold how he loved him! 37And some of them said, Could not this [man], who has opened the eyes of the blind [man], have caused that this [man] also should not have died? 38Jesus therefore, again deeply moved in himself, comes to the tomb. Now it was a cave, and a stone lay upon it. 39Jesus says, Take away the stone. Martha, the sister of the dead, says to him, Lord, he stinks already, for he is four days [there]. 40Jesus says to her, Did I not say to thee, that if thou shouldest believe, thou shouldest see the glory of God? 41They took therefore the stone away. And Jesus lifted up his eyes on high and said, Father, I thank thee that thou hast heard me; 42but I knew that thou always hearest me; but on account of the crowd who stand around I have said [it], that they may believe that thou hast sent me. 43And having said this, he cried with a loud voice, Lazarus, come forth. 44And the dead came forth, bound feet and hands with graveclothes, and his face was bound round with a handkerchief. Jesus says to them, Loose him and let him go.