Does God have a sense of humor?

Answered from the commentary of F. B. Hole, Truth & Testimony, J. G. Bellett and 11 others

Scripture does not credit God with a "sense of humour." Where it says that God laughs, the laughter is derision of those who set themselves against Him. Scripture seldom pictures God laughing. It does so three times in the Psalms and once in Proverbs, and each time the same thing is in view: those who refuse His mercy, mistreat His people and deny Him and His Anointed will be judged and brought down so as to look supremely ridiculous. So in Psalm 2:4 the nations rage on earth while God laughs in heaven. In Psalm 37:13 He laughs at the wicked because He sees that his day is coming. In Psalm 59:8 the laughter shows the hostility of the nations to be ridiculous. In Proverbs 1:26 He laughs at the calamity of those who scorned His warnings.

This is human language, used to convey heaven's contempt for man's folly. It is not light, either. One writer calls it "one of the most dreadful statements in the word of God", and another, "The derision of Jehovah! awful thought!". One writer draws the distinction directly: God's laughing the heathen to scorn is "altogether different" from saying He has "a good sense of humour," and that idea, applied to the Lord Jesus, is "more than Scripture allows". He adds that the Lord is never recorded as showing humour or joining in any jesting. Christ wept, but He did not laugh. Jesting is unsuitable for saints, who are to imitate God.

This does not make God joyless. "A God of love is a God of joy". He will rejoice over His restored people with joy and singing, as in Zephaniah 3:17. It was God who gave Isaac the name "laughter." Abraham laughed in faith and was approved, while Sarah's laugh of unbelief was rebuked. Later Sarah owned, "God hath made me to laugh," a laugh of joy and gladness that He gave her (Genesis 21:6). The laughter Scripture speaks of thus carries two ideas, happiness and contempt. God gives His people the first, and He turns the second on His enemies, but neither is humour.

Verses: Psalms 2:4, Psalms 37:13, Psalms 59:8, Proverbs 1:26, Genesis 21:6, Genesis 18:12, Genesis 18:13, Genesis 18:14, Genesis 18:15, Genesis 17:17, Genesis 21:3, Job 8:21, Psalms 126:2, Ecclesiastes 3:4, Zephaniah 3:17, Numbers 22:28, Numbers 22:29, Numbers 22:30, 1 Kings 18:27, Jonah 4:6, Jonah 4:7, Jonah 4:8, Jonah 4:9, Jonah 4:10, Jonah 4:11, Matthew 19:24, Matthew 7:3, Matthew 7:4, Matthew 7:5, Matthew 23:24, Luke 6:21, Proverbs 17:22, Isaiah 40:22, Job 40:15, Job 40:16, Job 40:17, Job 40:18, Job 40:19, Job 40:20, Job 40:21, Job 40:22, Job 40:23, Job 40:24, Job 41:1, Job 41:2, Job 41:3, Job 41:4, Job 41:5, Psalms 104:26, Mark 3:17, John 1:46, John 1:47, John 1:48

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

Truth & TestimonyVolume 3 - 12

The Lord Jesus is never recorded in the New Testament as giving expression to a sense of humour or taking part in any foolish jesting. We have God revealing that He will laugh and have the sinful heathen in derision, but that is altogether different to attributing “a good sense of humour” to the Lord Jesus. This is more than Scripture allows, and the circumcised heart should confine itself to the facts that Scripture gives and not give place to fleshly notions or speculations regarding the Christ of God that are all too prevalent in Christendom today.

The Word of God shows that in this world the Son of God was an outcast, the Man of sorrows and the one acquainted with grief. He was here, sowing in tears, weeping over Jerusalem and all who had fallen victim to Satan's subtlety. Strong crying and tears marked His course. Scripture shows Him as a sociable Man, serving all and being available to every one who was in need. He served the poor and weak. His ministry was to do good and to deliver. His oral ministry was of such quality that common people heard Him gladly. The inexpressible sweetness of His words is degraded by thoughts of Christ telling jokes. No trivial utterance left His lips, nor was any joke ever told by Him. He warned His hearers that they would be judged for every idle word spoken. Matters of eternal weight and importance were the subject of His speech — all that the Father gave Him to speak. There was first hand knowledge of heavenly things and these and like themes comprised the subject matter of His conversation. No man on earth ever walked in such a narrow path as the Lord Jesus Christ; and none had such a large heart as He. He was the Blessed (Happy) God, yet here a mourner and a homeless stranger among the sad and weary. The joy He brought was full and lasting; it was not expressed in a fleeting jest.

F. B. Hole"Why do the heathen rage?"

The Scriptures do not often represent God as laughing. Three times in the Psalms they do so, and once in Proverbs, and in each case the same thing is in view. If men refuse His mercy, if they maltreat His people, if they lawlessly deny Him and His Anointed, deriding His authority and His Word, they will be judged in due season. And not only judged, but cast down in such a way as to make them supremely ridiculous, the objects of derision to all created intelligences. The "laugh" will be on God's side in that day. Divine wrath and displeasure will be then poured out as verse 5 says; and the Son will execute that wrath, as the last verse indicates. Only He will not need to exert Himself. When His wrath is kindled but a little they will perish. The little finger of His wrath will be much thicker than the loins of their combined strength.

The Bible TreasuryScripture Imagery

It is remarkable that it was God who gave the name Isaac ("laughter") to the son of the promise. We are apt to think that gloom and austerity are the characteristics of devotedness, but Abraham laughed in God's presence, and so far from being rebuked for it, his laughter, being an expression of faith, is approved in the naming of his son. The laughter of Sarah is the amused expression of unbelief, and she is sharply rebuked. Though the Oriental peoples are habitually grave, there is a great deal about laughter in the Bible, and mostly it expresses these two notions of happiness and contempt. "Blessed are ye that weep now: for ye shall laugh" are the comforting words addressed to His suffering disciples. But very different in meaning is the expression, "He that sits in the heavens shall laugh: the Lord shall have them in derision."

Numerical Bible NotesThe Psalms

Then a brief section puts in contrast the parties opposed. On the one hand the enemies, like a pack of dogs, howling with disappointment, as they roam about in the evening gloom, the words upon their brave lips swords, because they apprehend no hearer. But on the other side is One who hears nevertheless, and, if He keep silence does so as counting all the restless attempts of men for His dethronement at their proper worth. He "laughs" at them: His appreciation of their folly being put, as commonly, in strong human language. Here, then, are the contestants in this strange, abhorrent warfare of the creatures with their God.

The Bible TreasuryPsalms 2 and 8

But vain man opposes to his own ruin. God notes his puny efforts and smiles at them all. "He that sitteth in the heavens shall laugh: the Lord shall have them in derision" (ver. 4). This is man's day, and too often he does not scruple to laugh and deride, but soon the tables will be reversed. Righteousness suffers and iniquity is exalted; but the day is not far distant when the reverse will be the case. "Then will he speak unto them in his wrath, and vex them in his sore displeasure" (ver. 5). Now He speaks to men in His grace and sends them the gospel of His Son, then His attitude will be entirely changed.

Hamilton SmithThe Psalms

(vv. 4-6) From a world in revolt we pass to the calm of heaven to learn God's thoughts of man's vain efforts. The great men of the earth — its political leaders, its scientists, its philosophers — may combine to cast off all recognition of God, but, unmoved by all their efforts the Christ of God “sits in the heavens,” and holds man's revolt in derision. Men rage on earth; God laughs in heaven. Human ideas are employed to convey to us heaven's contempt of man's folly.

L. M. GrantThe Psalms

Though the hostility of the nations against God and His Anointed Christ) is both concerted and determined, "He who sits in the heavens shall laugh; the Lord shall have them in derision" (v.4). Well might the God of heaven and earth laugh at their stupidity! For they are like little children gathering against their national government to tell the authorities, “We are canceling all the laws you have ever enacted and will refuse to obey anything you say." Of course, this would be only laughable, for they have no ability to carry out their schemes. But is amazing how long God bears with this evil before summarily judging it.

J. N. DarbyGenesis

Can any doubt the blessed beauty of the covenant-sacrifice of the Son, though there be more in principle in it, i.e., being a principle, it contains more. Thus God's relinquishment, i.e., Christ's of Jewish laughter, to have resurrection joy - and the Church's also - bitter as it may seem, all hang on this example of God, shown in the sacrifice and surrender of Christ. So Sarah's laughter of unbelief is God's laughter of joy, for He chooses the weak things.

Other AuthorsH. P. Barker

What an insight we get here into the very heart of God Himself, Israel's God and ours! Again and again He had mourned over the unfaithfulness and sin of His people. He had, times without number, entreated and warned them. But they had turned a deaf ear, and had run eagerly in the paths of pride, lust and idolatry. But at length God takes His place "in the midst" and shows Himself mighty, not to judge, but to save. Instead of mourning over His wayward people, He will rejoice over them with joy. Instead of continually entreating them, He will be silent (as the margin reads) in His love. It is the deep silence of a love that is perfectly satisfied, a silence broken only by the sound of joyful singing. Whose joyful singing? Ours? Israel's? Nay: God Himself "will joy over thee with singing."

No doubt this too is Christ. We have thus viewed Him, as Zephaniah presents Him, in the midst of His people in three different ways: As the just Jehovah, acting for righteousness' sake, maintaining truth. As Israel's King, acting for His people's sake, ensuring their unspeakable blessing. As Jehovah-God, acting for His own sake, bringing to pass His designs of grace that He might satisfy His own love, and rejoice over the objects of that love with singing.

Edwin N. CrossWhat Manner of Man is This?

The Lord Jesusis never recorded in the New Testament as giving expression to a sense of humour or taking part in any foolish jesting. We have God revealing that He will laugh and have the sinful heathen in derision, but that is altogether different to attributing "a good sense of humour" to the Lord Jesus. This is more than Scripture allows, and the circumcised heart should confine itself to the facts that Scripture gives and not give place to fleshly notions or speculations regarding the Christ of God that are all too prevalent in Christendom today.

The Word of God shows that in this world the Son of God was an outcast, the Man of sorrows and the one acquainted with grief. He was here, sowing in tears, weeping over Jerusalem and all who had fallen victim to Satan's subtlety. Strong crying and tears marked His course. Scripture shows Him as a sociable Man, serving all and being available to every one who was in need. He served the poor and weak. His ministry was to do good and to deliver. His oral ministry was of such quality that common people heard Him gladly. The inexpressible sweetness of His words is degraded by thoughts of Christ telling jokes. No trivial utterance left His lips, nor was any joke ever told by Him. He warned His hearers that they would be judged for every idle word spoken. Matters of eternal weight and importance were the subject of His speech-all that the Father gave Him to speak. There was first hand knowledge of heavenly things and these and like themes comprised the subject matter of His conversation. No man on earth ever walked in such a narrow path as the Lord Jesus Christ; and none had such a large heart as He. He was the Blessed (Happy) God, yet here a mourner and a homeless stranger among the sad and weary. The joy He brought was full and lasting; it was not expressed in a fleeting jest.

Verses

  • Psalms 2:4He that dwelleth in the heavens shall laugh, the Lord shall have them in derision.
  • Psalms 37:13The Lord laugheth at him; for he seeth that his day is coming.
  • Psalms 59:8But thou, Jehovah, wilt laugh at them; thou wilt have all the nations in derision.
  • Proverbs 1:26I also will laugh in your calamity, I will mock when your fear cometh;
  • Genesis 21:6And Sarah said, God has made me laugh all that hear will laugh with me.
  • Genesis 18:12–1512And Sarah laughed within herself, saying, After I am become old, shall I have pleasure, and my lord old? 13And Jehovah said to Abraham, Why is this, that Sarah laughs, saying, Shall I indeed bear, when I am become old? 14Is [any] matter too wonderful for Jehovah? At the time appointed I will return to thee, at [this] time of the year, and Sarah shall have a son. 15And Sarah denied, saying, I did not laugh; for she was afraid. And he said, No; but thou didst laugh.