Do wives have to obey their husbands?
Paul's word to wives in Ephesians 5:22 is one of the most contested lines in the New Testament, and much of the confusion comes from a word that is often swapped for a harsher one. Scripture asks the wife to submit — and in the same passage it asks children and servants to obey, which raises the question of whether the difference is deliberate.
A Word Chosen With Care
The change of verb across the household instructions is not accidental. One writer draws attention to what Paul does not say to wives:
W. H. WestcottIt is often commented on that it does not say, "Wives, obey your husbands," as though they were children or servants. In Ephesians 6 you have "Children, obey your parents" — that is a question of authority, and rightly so; and then in Ephesians 5, "Servants, be obedient to your masters" comes in again. But with the wives — "Submit yourselves to your own husbands." … It is not a question of obeying exactly, but the husband regards the wife as given to him of God to be his helper in the partnership.
Why The Verb Changes
The reason lies in how each person came to be in their place. A wife is not born into her position or forced into it:
Julius A Von PoseckChildren, being born into the subordinate place, and servants — or rather slaves, since hired servants were unknown in those times — being in the same place either by birth, or purchase, or as prisoners of war, could not be told to accept or take that place by submitting themselves to their superiors, because they were already in it, independently of their own consent. It is not so with wives. They have become so by their own free consent, and knowing beforehand the character and duties of their place.
The Two Words Defined
The same writer sets out the distinction plainly, and notes that the two can come apart:
Julius A Von PoseckSubmitting myself to another means accepting and taking a subordinate place under another person's lawful authority over me. Obedience means behaving and acting according to that place — no matter whether I am in it by my own choice or through necessity — by submitting my will to the will of the one who is in authority over me. Submission and obedience, in a natural sense, are not necessarily identical. There may be an outward submission without real obedience. In the Christian sense, both are a matter of the heart, as being done to the Lord.
Obedience Is Not Absent From Scripture
Commentators differ on how far the distinction should be pressed, because another letter does use the word "obeyed" of a wife. Sarah, Abraham's wife, is held up as the pattern — and the setting of her words matters:
Leslie M. GrantShe obeyed Abraham, calling him "lord." The occasion of this is seen in Genesis 18:12, when Sarah spoke within herself, not out loud — which shows this was a willing, habitual practice, not adopted because others were listening. … But subjection is not terror; it has in it rather the calm dignity of faith and of courage, not a slavish servility.
Others therefore hold that obedience is genuinely required of the wife, while insisting it grows out of her position rather than being imposed on her:
Edward DennettThe wife is indeed told to obey, but it is on the ground of the place she occupies. … The obedience required of the wife is then seen to be what should flow out of the position in which she is set — the natural fruit of the relationship.
"As To The Lord" Changes Everything
The phrase attached to the command is what makes it bearable when a marriage is hard:
William KellyThe Christian wife may have a husband, and it may be very painful and hard to bear it all. Perhaps he makes nothing of you, and often asks what is unreasonable. But what will make the burden light, though still felt? "Wives, submit to your own husbands, as to the Lord." I am to submit to my husband as to the Lord. Let me only see the Lord in the matter, instead of his thoughtlessness and bad temper, and my path is plain. It is made a matter not of mere duty, but of confidence in the Lord as above everything in His love, care, and government.
The One Limit
Because the submission is rendered to the Lord, it stops where it would turn into disobedience to Him:
Edward DennettIf the will of the husband should interfere with the wife's individual responsibility to the Lord — should come into conflict with the Lord's will as expressed in His word — if she is forced to choose between obedience to her husband and disobedience to the Lord, then the Lord must have the supreme claim. With this single exception her submission to her husband must be complete.
Order, Not Rank
Submission says nothing about worth, and the arrangement binds the husband as much as the wife:
F. B. HoleSubjection, remember, does not mean inferiority. In business partnerships two men may be equal partners, and yet one is recognised as the senior with whom the final decision rests. … If the husband loves and honours his wife as a fellow-heir and partner, and she honours and obeys him, an ideal marriage is the result.
Summary
- Word — Children and servants are told to obey; wives are told to submit. The verbs differ on purpose.
- Consent — The reason is consent: children and slaves were already in their place, but a wife entered hers freely, knowing what it involved.
- Heart — Submission is taking the place; obedience is acting in it. Outward submission can exist without real obedience, so both must be heart matters done to the Lord.
- Limit — "As to the Lord" both fuels the submission and caps it: where a husband's will collides with God's word, the Lord's claim wins.
- Equal — Subjection is not inferiority. She is a fellow-heir and partner, and the husband is bound to love and honour her.