Did God create sin?
Answered from the commentary of James Boyd, A. J. Pollock, William Kelly and 15 others
No, God did not create sin: He is not the author of sin, and evil never came from Him. His nature rules it out, because God is light and love, so no evil can arise in Him or come out of Him. That is why He cannot be tempted with evil, neither tempts any man (James 1:13). What He made He pronounced "very good" (Genesis 1:31), and He did not make the world or man as they are now. "God made man upright; but they have sought out many inventions" (Ecclesiastes 7:29). To make God the author of man's moral evil is called heinous wickedness, and even a blasphemy. Sin had its origin in the creature. The devil was the first sinner: he was created perfect "till iniquity was found in him" (Ezekiel 28:15), and his pride lifted him against God (1 John 3:8). Through him, man was led into the same independence, and "by one man sin entered into the world" (Romans 5:12). Sin is not a created substance but a departure, the corruption of a good nature. In essence it is lawlessness, a creature's will set up independently of God. So God never created a sinful being; sinfulness was acquired by self-will. The words "I create evil" (Isaiah 45:7) do not teach otherwise, since there "evil" means calamity or judgment, set against peace, and not moral evil.
Yet sin did not enter without God's knowledge and permission. Nor did it take Him by surprise. To leave man an intelligent, responsible being rather than a machine, God had to leave sin a possibility, though never a necessity. He foreknew the fall but did not decree that man must sin, and to say He secretly connived at it is a wicked aspersion on His goodness. The fall was permitted, not caused. This permission comes with God's sovereign overruling: He makes sin and Satan serve His purpose, as the wrath of man is made to praise Him (Psalm 76:10). In the cross He has dealt with sin, and in the end He will banish it from His universe. The same holds for hardening hearts, as with Pharaoh: God never makes a man bad, but judicially hardens only those who have first hardened themselves. The responsibility for sin therefore rests wholly with the creature who brought it in. The comfort the authors draw is that God, as Judge, will condemn it, while in grace He bears with it so that sinners may be freed from its consequences.
Verses: Psalms 76:10, James 1:13, James 1:14, James 1:15, Genesis 1:31, Deuteronomy 32:4, Ecclesiastes 7:29, 1 John 1:5, Habakkuk 1:13, Psalms 5:4, Romans 5:12, Genesis 3:1, Genesis 3:2, Genesis 3:3, Genesis 3:4, Genesis 3:5, Genesis 3:6, Genesis 3:7, Isaiah 45:7, Genesis 50:20, 1 John 3:8, John 8:44, Ezekiel 28:15, Psalms 92:15, Job 34:10, Lamentations 3:38, Romans 9:19, Romans 9:20, Romans 9:21, Acts 2:23, Proverbs 16:4, 1 Corinthians 14:33, Matthew 15:19, Jeremiah 17:9, Psalms 145:17
The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.
What the commentators say
The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.
Could such a Being be the Author of sin? Assuredly not. But Scripture does not enlighten us as to how sin came into existence. We have the history of its first appearance, but we are not enlightened as to the why and wherefore.
There is only one answer to be given. God is not the author of evil, but He has allowed sin for His own glory. He did not create creatures who were incapable of choosing between good and evil, else He would have created mere machines—infinitely more wonderful than motor cars and aeroplanes, but yet on the same level.
But evil never came from God — only from the creature once innocent, now fallen, that kept not his first estate, but chose to do his own will and have his own way. An angel did this first. Man was misled by him who, straying and exalting himself, beguiled others both in heaven and on earth. That creature is called Satan — the Devil. All efforts to get rid of this fact have proved utterly vain, so much so that the boasted lights of antiquity fell consequently into one or other of these notions: either that God is everything, which denies sin; or, secondly, that there is no such being as God at all; while both cases led to worshipping ever so many false gods. Witness now the two greatest philosophers of Greece who have exercised perhaps the largest and most enduring influence over civilised men outside the Bible — the one the head of Pantheism, the other of Atheism. There is what man's thought ends in when it is logically carried out. Man in his fallen estate may reason God away; yet he excludes God, not from his conscience, but in his reason; for at the bottom of the man's heart who does so there is the uneasy feeling that what he sees around him did not grow like a potato — least of all, he himself and his fellows. He feels that, though fallen, he is a moral being who will have to give an account of his action; and to whom but to God — the One who made him and all things?
It would, I am persuaded, be impossible for anyone possessing even in a feeble measure the knowledge of God, to think that anything could enter His creation unknown to Him, or that a thought could spring up in the mind of any intelligent being without His cognition. Every enlightened soul will gladly acknowledge, that from no quarter could the omniscient One be surprised by an enemy. Nothing could possibly be hid from Him, before whom hell is naked, and destruction without a covering. At the same time the faithful heart revolts with horror from the doctrine that would make the holy and righteous God the Author and Inventor of the evil which has ruined His fair creation. Evil could not enter the creation without His knowledge and permission, but He is not the author of it, the devil is that; he abode not in the truth. “He is a liar and the father of it.” And this is just what sin is; it is lawlessness, and lawlessness is departure from the truth, for the truth is the right relation of everything to God, and sin is falsehood and departure from this, and becomes manifested in the lawlessness of the rebel creature.
But although God is not the author of sin, but its Judge, He, for His own wise purposes, allowed it to enter His dominions. He will make it serve Him, and He will get glory to His great and holy name through it, and in the end banish it from His sight forever; and we may be sure enough of this, that were it not destined to serve the purposes of His heart, it could have gained no entrance. But it does serve Him, not willingly, but in spite of the fact that it is an enemy it is made to serve Him, as is every other creature, be that creature good or evil, be it the horrible invention of the wicked mind of angel or of man, or be it the offspring of the goodness of God Himself, everything must serve in the carrying out of the purposes of His love; and in nothing shall the creature be triumphant, for dust must be the serpent’s meat, and every proud spirit must be humbled, and in the end come to learn, in the bitterness of eternal defeat, destruction and death, that all its profound plotting and restless wickedness have only been helping on the end the blessed God had in view from the beginning.
God did not make man in the condition in which he is now; He did not throw the world into its moral confusion, not to speak of its physical misery. He that can conceive a divine being to have made man as he is, and the world as it is, must have the notion of a demon, an Ahriman, instead of the true God. That infinite power should create man to be the victim of such sorrow, to have his heart distracted with varied, intense, and ceaseless misery — to have, according to the word of God itself, evil inbred in his very nature (a doctrine enforced by the facts of every day), he that could conceive God to have so made man in such a world has the least worthy notion of God that even Rationalism could conceive. The word of God alone supplies the key, and explains this otherwise inscrutable riddle. According to that word He made man upright; the world and every creature in it He formed good; but man departed from God, and lost Him morally. No wonder, if foundations are out of course — God left and man fallen through self-exalting rebellion, that there should be misery; for the only possible spring of happiness is in the communion of God with His creatures. Sin necessarily destroys it; and man having lost Him becomes a prey to all the evil that the enemy of God can bring into the world, more deeply and if possible irreparably, to sever man from God. This is the account of the Scriptures, and there is none other that can compete with it or explain all, so as either to justify God or to clear up the state of man. To make God Himself the author of man's moral evil is heinous wickedness, and man's conscience knows it, even when he might wish it to excuse himself. Here then at the outset the immense and singular value of God's word comes in; and upon this too a remark of general import may be seasonable.
"By one man sin entered the world, and death by sin." The creature thus falling was the author of sin, not the immortality of the soul, still less God, though He will justly condemn man's guilt the more because of his privileges and His own mercy despised.
Therefore it was a necessity that sin should be allowed entrance into this world, for though an enemy has brought it to pass, God will make it serve to give effect to His eternal purpose. It must not for a moment be supposed that He was the author of sin, or that He brought it into the world. Had He done either His purpose never could have been effectuated. It was by one of His creatures it was brought into existence, and by another of His creatures it found entrance into the world. The devil was the first sinner. His pride made him think he was the equal of God (Ezek. 28:9); Adam by an attempt at equality with God allowed it to come into the world (Gen. 3:5). That God could have prevented the existence of sin, or having allowed it to exist, He could have prevented its entrance into the world, cannot rightly be questioned. It is obnoxious to Him, and He will eventually cleanse His universe from its presence, but in the meantime He makes it, as well as the one who is its father, to serve His purpose.
He is not the author of it: the devil is, he sins from the beginning (1 John 3:8). There was no sinner before him. Set in the most exalted position in which creature was ever set, his pride rose up in rebellion against the One who had made him, and who in goodness gave him that exalted place. We have him addressed by the prophet under the figure of the king of Tyrus (Ezek. 28), and he is told, “Thou wast perfect in thy ways, from the day that thou wast created, till iniquity was found in thee.” Sin began to exist in the thought of that anointed cherub. There the inky river whose foul waters found their way into the garden of Eden, and from thence have filled the world with violence, corruption, sorrow, death, and woe, is traced to its source. How many ages have run their courses since this terrific being brought sin into God’s fair creation Scripture does not say, but the earth seems to bear upon its granite ribs many a scar of past conflict, and violence seems to have been for ages rampant in the lower order of creation, as it is today; but whether this was due to the influence of sin’s primogenitor, or whether it was not, we cannot tell. We do know that he was the first transgressor, and that to this day he remains the same evil, lawless, God-hating being he ever was, and that all who have fallen under his baleful influence remain in their fallen condition unchanged—all except man, who has become the subject of grace, and from whose race God makes a selection, recreating the objects of His choice, that they may be vessels of His praise. The rest remain in their natural rebellious condition, the enemies of God and of His Christ and of the gospel of His grace.
For the angels were sinless at first, as Adam was. God never is the author of moral evil.
Of course God never created any being or intelligence sinful. Sinfulness was acquired by self-will. As Satan fell and became the destroyer, Apollyon, so his angels fell and became demons. All through the four Gospels we get constant allusions to demons. These are clearly those fallen angels who are not under everlasting chains.
Verses
- Psalms 76:10For the fury of man shall praise thee; the remainder of fury wilt thou gird on thyself.
- James 1:13–1513Let no man, being tempted, say, I am tempted of God. For God cannot be tempted by evil things, and himself tempts no one. 14But every one is tempted, drawn away, and enticed by his own lust; 15then lust, having conceived, gives birth to sin; but sin fully completed brings forth death.
- Genesis 1:31And God saw everything that he had made, and behold it was very good. And there was evening, and there was morning — the sixth day.
- Deuteronomy 32:4[He is] the Rock, his work is perfect, For all his ways are righteousness; A God of faithfulness without deceit, Just and right is he.
- Ecclesiastes 7:29Only see this which I have found that God made man upright, but they have sought out many devices.
- 1 John 1:5And this is the message which we have heard from him, and declare to you, that God is light, and in him is no darkness at all.