Are faith healers for real? Does a faith healer heal with the same power as Jesus?

Answered from the commentary of The Bible Treasury, F. B. Hole, A. J. Pollock and 4 others

No, not as a class: the popular system of faith-healing is called “little short of a pretence to miraculous powers,” and the claimed cures are often false or due to suggestion and personal influence. Some sick people may truly be healed in answer to prayer, and God’s power to heal remains; but healing is not assured in every case, and sickness is not proof of sin or lack of faith. A faith healer does not heal with the same power as Jesus: Jesus healed all who came to Him, at once and by His own word or touch, while the apostles and other servants healed only by power given to them, and not in every case. Miracles may occur, but they do not by themselves prove that a healer or his teaching is of God; claimed power must be judged by the truth it supports.

Verses: Matthew 4:23, Matthew 4:24, Matthew 8:1, Matthew 8:2, Matthew 8:3, Matthew 8:4, Matthew 8:5, Matthew 8:6, Matthew 8:7, Matthew 8:8, Matthew 8:9, Matthew 8:10, Matthew 8:11, Matthew 8:12, Matthew 8:13, Matthew 8:14, Matthew 8:15, Matthew 8:16, Matthew 8:17, Matthew 9:1, Matthew 9:2, Matthew 9:3, Matthew 9:4, Matthew 9:5, Matthew 9:6, Matthew 9:7, Matthew 9:8, Matthew 9:18, Matthew 9:19, Matthew 9:20, Matthew 9:21, Matthew 9:22, Matthew 9:23, Matthew 9:24, Matthew 9:25, Matthew 9:26, Matthew 9:27, Matthew 9:28, Matthew 9:29, Matthew 9:30, Matthew 9:31, Matthew 9:32, Matthew 9:33, Matthew 9:34, Matthew 9:35, Matthew 10:1, Matthew 10:2, Matthew 10:3, Matthew 10:4, Matthew 10:5, Matthew 10:6, Matthew 10:7, Matthew 10:8, Matthew 14:14, Matthew 14:15, Matthew 14:16, Matthew 14:17, Matthew 14:18, Matthew 14:19, Matthew 14:20, Matthew 14:21, Matthew 14:22, Matthew 14:23, Matthew 14:24, Matthew 14:25, Matthew 14:26, Matthew 14:27, Matthew 14:28, Matthew 14:29, Matthew 14:30, Matthew 14:31, Matthew 14:32, Matthew 14:33, Matthew 14:34, Matthew 14:35, Matthew 14:36, Matthew 15:21, Matthew 15:22, Matthew 15:23, Matthew 15:24, Matthew 15:25, Matthew 15:26, Matthew 15:27, Matthew 15:28, Matthew 15:29, Matthew 15:30, Matthew 15:31, Matthew 17:14, Matthew 17:15, Matthew 17:16, Matthew 17:17, Matthew 17:18, Matthew 17:19, Matthew 17:20, Matthew 17:21, Matthew 20:29, Matthew 20:30, Matthew 20:31, Matthew 20:32, Matthew 20:33, Matthew 20:34, Mark 1:29, Mark 1:30, Mark 1:31, Mark 1:32, Mark 1:33, Mark 1:34, Mark 1:40, Mark 1:41, Mark 1:42, Mark 1:43, Mark 1:44, Mark 1:45, Mark 2:1, Mark 2:2, Mark 2:3, Mark 2:4, Mark 2:5, Mark 2:6, Mark 2:7, Mark 2:8, Mark 2:9, Mark 2:10, Mark 2:11, Mark 2:12, Mark 3:1, Mark 3:2, Mark 3:3, Mark 3:4, Mark 3:5, Mark 3:6, Mark 3:7, Mark 3:8, Mark 3:9, Mark 3:10, Mark 3:11, Mark 3:12, Mark 5:21, Mark 5:22, Mark 5:23, Mark 5:24, Mark 5:25, Mark 5:26, Mark 5:27, Mark 5:28, Mark 5:29, Mark 5:30, Mark 5:31, Mark 5:32, Mark 5:33, Mark 5:34, Mark 5:35, Mark 5:36, Mark 5:37, Mark 5:38, Mark 5:39, Mark 5:40, Mark 5:41, Mark 5:42, Mark 5:43, Mark 6:5, Mark 6:6, Mark 6:7, Mark 6:8, Mark 6:9, Mark 6:10, Mark 6:11, Mark 6:12, Mark 6:13, Mark 6:53, Mark 6:54, Mark 6:55, Mark 6:56, Mark 7:24, Mark 7:25, Mark 7:26, Mark 7:27, Mark 7:28, Mark 7:29, Mark 7:30, Mark 7:31, Mark 7:32, Mark 7:33, Mark 7:34, Mark 7:35, Mark 7:36, Mark 7:37, Mark 8:22, Mark 8:23, Mark 8:24, Mark 8:25, Mark 8:26, Mark 9:14, Mark 10:46, Mark 10:47, Mark 10:48, Mark 10:49, Mark 10:50, Mark 10:51, Mark 10:52, Luke 4:38, Luke 4:39, Luke 4:40, Luke 4:41, Luke 4:42, Luke 4:43, Luke 4:44, Luke 5:12, Luke 5:13, Luke 5:14, Luke 5:15, Luke 5:16, Luke 5:17, Luke 5:18, Luke 5:19, Luke 5:20, Luke 5:21, Luke 5:22, Luke 5:23, Luke 5:24, Luke 5:25, Luke 5:26, Luke 6:6, Luke 6:7, Luke 6:8, Luke 6:9, Luke 6:10, Luke 6:11, Luke 6:12, Luke 6:13, Luke 6:14, Luke 6:15, Luke 6:16, Luke 6:17, Luke 6:18, Luke 6:19, Luke 7:1, Luke 7:2, Luke 7:3, Luke 7:4, Luke 7:5, Luke 7:6, Luke 7:7, Luke 7:8, Luke 7:9, Luke 7:10, Luke 7:11, Luke 7:12, Luke 7:13, Luke 7:14, Luke 7:15, Luke 7:16, Luke 7:17, Luke 8:40, Luke 8:41, Luke 8:42, Luke 8:43, Luke 8:44, Luke 8:45, Luke 8:46, Luke 8:47, Luke 8:48, Luke 8:49, Luke 8:50, Luke 8:51, Luke 8:52, Luke 8:53, Luke 8:54, Luke 8:55, Luke 8:56, Luke 9:1, Luke 9:2, Luke 9:3, Luke 9:4, Luke 9:5, Luke 9:6, Luke 9:37, Luke 9:38, Luke 9:39, Luke 9:40, Luke 9:41, Luke 9:42, Luke 9:43, Luke 10:1, Luke 10:2, Luke 10:3, Luke 10:4, Luke 10:5, Luke 10:6, Luke 10:7, Luke 10:8, Luke 10:9, Luke 10:10, Luke 10:11, Luke 10:12, Luke 10:13, Luke 10:14, Luke 10:15, Luke 10:16, Luke 10:17, Luke 10:18, Luke 10:19, Luke 10:20, Luke 13:10, Luke 13:11, Luke 13:12, Luke 13:13, Luke 13:14, Luke 13:15, Luke 13:16, Luke 13:17, Luke 17:11, Luke 17:12, Luke 17:13, Luke 17:14, Luke 17:15, Luke 17:16, Luke 17:17, Luke 17:18, Luke 17:19, Luke 18:35, Luke 18:36, Luke 18:37, Luke 18:38, Luke 18:39, Luke 18:40, Luke 18:41, Luke 18:42, Luke 18:43, John 5:1, John 5:2, John 5:3, John 5:4, John 5:5, John 5:6, John 5:7, John 5:8, John 5:9, John 5:10, John 5:11, John 5:12, John 5:13, John 5:14, John 5:15, John 9:1, John 9:2, John 9:3, John 9:4, John 9:5, John 9:6, John 9:7, John 11:1, John 11:2, John 11:3, John 11:4, John 11:5, John 11:6, John 11:7, John 11:8, John 11:9, John 11:10, John 11:11, John 11:12, John 11:13, John 11:14, John 11:15, John 11:16, John 11:17, John 11:18, John 11:19, John 11:20, John 11:21, John 11:22, John 11:23, John 11:24, John 11:25, John 11:26, John 11:27, John 11:28, John 11:29, John 11:30, John 11:31, John 11:32, John 11:33, John 11:34, John 11:35, John 11:36, John 11:37, John 11:38, John 11:39, John 11:40, John 11:41, John 11:42, John 11:43, John 11:44, John 14:12, John 14:13, John 14:14, Acts 3:1, Acts 3:2, Acts 3:3, Acts 3:4, Acts 3:5, Acts 3:6, Acts 3:7, Acts 3:8, Acts 3:9, Acts 3:10, Acts 5:12, Acts 5:13, Acts 5:14, Acts 5:15, Acts 5:16, Acts 8:4, Acts 8:5, Acts 8:6, Acts 8:7, Acts 8:8, Acts 9:32, Acts 9:33, Acts 9:34, Acts 9:35, Acts 14:8, Acts 14:9, Acts 14:10, Acts 19:11, Acts 19:12, 1 Corinthians 12:7, 1 Corinthians 12:8, 1 Corinthians 12:9, 1 Corinthians 12:10, 1 Corinthians 12:11, 1 Corinthians 12:28, 2 Corinthians 12:12, Galatians 3:5, James 5:13, James 5:14, James 5:15, James 5:16

The above is AI generated summary based on the writers below.

What the commentators say

The passages the answer is drawn from, the most direct first, with the words that bear on the question marked.

F. B. HoleSigns and Wonders

We fully believe that occasionally it pleases God to intervene on behalf of the sick in ways that are supernatural, on the lines indicated in James 5:14-16. We believe that there have been cases even in our days of wretched victims of demoniacal power out in the heathen world being delivered by the faith and prayer and fasting of devoted servants of God. These things have come to pass as the fruit of dealings with God in secret just as they did, only far more commonly, in apostolic days. But we also fully believe that false cults can present us with lists of equally well attested wonders, especially in the form of healings — take for example the Romish cures at Lourdes, and the cures of Christian Science and of Spiritism — which are not of God at all.

A. J. PollockModern Pentecostalism

Of course there is no question but that the early church possessed the gift of healing. There is no question but that the Lord can give healing of the body today. His power is the same. The sick saint may call for the elders of the church, if they can be found, and they may anoint the sufferer with oil, and the prayer of FAITH shall save the sick, and he shall be raised up. Of that there can be no question. It is a pity that it is not more often done.

A. J. PollockModern Pentecostalism, Foursquare Gospel, “Healings” and “Tongues”

Of course there is no question but that the early church possessed the gift of healing. There is no question but that the Lord can give healing of the body today. His power is the same. The sick saint may call for the elders of the church, if they can be found, and they may anoint the sufferer with oil, and the prayer of FAITH shall save the sick, and he shall be raised up. Of that there can be no question. It is a pity that it is not more often done.

A. J. PollockFaith Healing

It seems as if these gifts that appealed to the senses and were visibly miraculous, were intended to carry conviction in connection with the establishment of Christianity, but now that need has passed, and moreover in face of the disunited condition of the church, its failure on every hand, its worldliness, it is no wonder that such a gift is not seen in vigorous manifestation. Apart from a system that exalts faith healing into a position Scripture never gave it, and which in reality degrades the whole Christian profession, there are instances in which, quietly and without ostentation, the prayer of faith has healed the sick.

A. J. PollockFaith Healing

This was very noticeable in the early history of the church, when healing took its place among the gifts the ascended Lord gave in giving the Holy Spirit. That God can and does still in response to faith heal the bodies of His saints at the present time we do not deny, but a word of strong warning needs to be uttered in this connection. There is a class of persons who exalt faith healing into a system, and fix the minds of Christians upon their bodies instead of on Christ and His Word.

Arend Remmers"The Sermon on the Mount"

These things have not been restricted to the beginning of Christendom only. In our days we will find - and especially so in charismatic circles - false prophets, healers and preachers, who perform miracles 'in the name of Christ'. And yet these men are not truly converted. The source of these miracles - if they are miracles at all, is none else than Satan himself. Every child of God should be most careful in judging extraordinary phenomena in Christian circles. By writing this we do not want to give the impression that all who distinguish themselves by sensational doings are not saved. Satan is able to beguile the heart of a believer also.

The Bible TreasuryThe Gospel of Mark

Truly we have no warrant for believing that the Lord has secured to His own a present exemption from the physical and mental disabilities common to mankind. Neither have we warrant for believing that the power He exercised in New Testament times over the sick bodies of men is continued to His present witnesses. In those miracles of healing He demonstrated once for all His power as the First Cause, dispensing with all material remedies as intermediaries, accomplishing His purpose with a word or touch. He was pleased to use a plaister of figs for the recovery of Hezekiah, but the king knew that it was Jehovah who had healed him, as he said, "He has both spoken unto me, and himself has done it" (Isa. 38:15). And we, encouraged by the personal activities of Jesus recorded in the holy Gospels, may use our medicinal remedies in the assurance of His equal activity today both in sympathy and in power to heal.

Leslie M. GrantComments on the Gospel of Matthew

The truth of what they proclaim as to the kingdom is confirmed by the power given them to heal the sick, cleanse the lepers, raise the dead and to cast out demons. This power came from the King Himself: they had received it freely, and they were to freely give, not to use it as de present-day self-styled healers, for their own gain.

A. J. PollockUnitarianism: The Negation of the Christian Faith

We are told that the miracles our Lord performed were “entirely human.” This is most evidently not true. The writer has often said, that when so-called Divine Healers, Christian Scientists, Mormons, Pentecostalists, Roman Catholics at Lourdes, etc., can give proof of their claims of divine healing by restoring a severed limb in a moment of time, leaving no trace of the operation, even if it were so small a part of the human body as an ear, he will immediately recognise their claims. Malchus’ ear is a test case, not yet emulated by any of our present-day so-called Divine Healers. Our Lord performed this miracle (Luke 22:50-51). Was that miracle “entirely human”? We have not heard of these self-named Divine Healers rushing to the battlefields, and restoring severed limbs to the mutilated.

A. J. PollockModern Pentecostalism

But it is clear from our enquiry that the methods practised by the present-day healers and the methods of the Bible are very different. It is clear, too, that there is a great deal of auto-suggestion and personal influence in the matter, and that such cures can be equally claimed by Spiritists and Christian Scientists, and, as we have seen, even in heathen circles, where undoubtedly the influence is Satanic.

Verses

  • Matthew 4:23–2423And [Jesus] went round the whole [of] Galilee, teaching in their synagogues, and preaching the glad tidings of the kingdom, and healing every disease and every bodily weakness among the people. 24And his fame went out into the whole [of] Syria, and they brought to him all that were ill, suffering under various diseases and pains, and those possessed by demons, and lunatics, and paralytics; and he healed them.
  • Matthew 8:1–171And when he had come down from the mountain, great crowds followed him. 2And behold, a leper came up to [him] and did him homage, saying, Lord, if thou wilt, thou art able to cleanse me. 3And he stretched out his hand and touched him, saying, I will; be cleansed. And immediately his leprosy was cleansed. 4And Jesus says to him, See thou tell no man, but go, shew thyself to the priest, and offer the gift which Moses ordained, for a testimony to them. 5And when he had entered into Capernaum, a centurion came to him, beseeching him, 6and saying, Lord, my servant lies paralytic in the house, suffering grievously. 7And Jesus says to him, I will come and heal him. 8And the centurion answered and said, Lord, I am not fit that thou shouldest enter under my roof; but only speak a word, and my servant shall be healed. 9For I also am a man under authority, having under me soldiers, and I say to this [one], Go, and he goes; and to another, Come, and he comes; and to my bondman, Do this, and he does it. 10And when Jesus heard it, he wondered, and said to those who followed, Verily I say unto you, Not even in Israel have I found so great faith. 11But I say unto you, that many shall come from [the] rising and setting [sun], and shall lie down at table with Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of the heavens; 12but the sons of the kingdom shall be cast out into the outer darkness there shall be the weeping and the gnashing of teeth. 13And Jesus said to the centurion, Go, and as thou hast believed, be it to thee. And his servant was healed in that hour. 14And when Jesus had come to Peter's house, he saw his mother-in-law laid down and in a fever; 15and he touched her hand, and the fever left her, and she arose and served him. 16And when the evening was come, they brought to him many possessed by demons, and he cast out the spirits with a word, and healed all that were ill; 17so that that should be fulfilled which was spoken through Esaias the prophet, saying, Himself took our infirmities and bore our diseases.