*Ye* are the light of the world a city situated on the top of a mountain cannot be hid.
I have enough from three rich sources. Writing the answer.
The Lord's words in Matthew 5:14 — "Ye are the light of the world: a city set on a hill cannot be hid" — mark a step beyond what has just been said. The disciples have already been named the salt of the earth; now they are named something more outward and more public.
William Kelly draws the distinction carefully:
William Kelly"Here the character of the position for the disciples goes beyond 'the salt of the earth.' For this was expressive of righteousness; a righteousness not outward like that of the scribes and Pharisees (which sought reputation of man, and was little beyond the pride of a Stoic), but lowly and real as in God's sight. Whereas 'the light of the world' is the shining forth of grace, and inseparable from the confession of Christ in that respect. Salt preserves, but does not make everything manifest as the light does."
So the figure changes from a hidden preservative to an open testimony. The salt keeps corruption at bay; the light brings things into view. The one is a quiet work of holiness, the other an unmistakable declaration.
Kelly notices that the Lord does not repeat the word "earth" here, but enlarges the scene:
"'The world' had no such special dealing of God as 'the earth.' There moral darkness had reigned, which the light was to dispel as far as He gave it scope and power. Redemption, Christ's death, resurrection, and ascension, would give the light a penetrating energy unknown before. For such was the deadly pall which overhung the favoured land during our Lord's earthly sojourn that, contrary to nature, the darkness resisted the light, and 'comprehended not' even the True Light in His person. But when He rose victorious over all the power of the wicked one, the old commandment became the new, and was true not in Him only but in us, Christians, because the darkness is quite passing and the true light already shines."
The shining therefore is not limited to Israel. The disciples are placed in relation to the whole moral night of mankind, and their light has its source and its energy in a risen Christ.
The figure is meant to press home that this testimony cannot be a private thing. Kelly continues:
"This is confirmed by the figure which follows and carries the truth out farther. 'A city set, or situated, upon a hill-top cannot be hid.' The sphere is no longer the circumscribed area of the earth or land, but, as for another aspect we read, 'the field is the world.'... And they, His disciples, are the light of the world: a city set upon a hill-top cannot be hid. Once darkness, they are now light in the Lord, and responsible to walk as children of light, corporately as well as individually. For the fruit of light is in all goodness, and righteousness, and truth."
The city is corporate — a company together on a height, visible from every side. Concealment is not open to them; the only question is whether the light shines brightly or dimly.
Kelly then turns from the city to the lamp, and here the indictment is sharp:
"Men treat their light more fairly than Christendom does the light of which our Lord spoke. Men shrink from natural darkness, its inconveniences, and its dangers; and when they light a lamp, they do not put it under the dry measure (which of course would quite hide it) but on the lampstand, and it shines to all that are in the house. But Christendom fears the light that exposes its neglect of scripture, and of the Holy Spirit's guidance, and of Christ who is and ought to be the all."
The point is not that the light is weak but that those who bear it too often cover it. The remedy is courage — "the faithful are bound with humility yet in courage of faith to let the light shine; for it is not of self, but the confession of Christ in everything going forth as God has taught them, whether men hear or forbear."
One of the most careful observations belongs to F. W. Grant, who warns against collapsing the light into mere benevolence:
F. W. Grant"From it being said, 'let men see your good works,' people often imagine that these are the light itself, and thus make the two things we are considering practically one. Indeed they are made for one another: separate them, and there is at once a fatal deficiency in each. What testimony to Christ can there be, if there be not the life giving evidence? But again, what evidence in the life if the lips are silent as to Christ?"
Grant then presses that the light must shine upon the works, or else the works will be misread:
"Thus it needs the light to shine upon the good works, that they may be seen as such, and glorify your Father who is in heaven. Apart from this, they may glorify humanity, or glorify any lie under the sun. Christ is He with whom in the full reality of it, 'light is come into the world,' and if 'men love darkness rather than light,' it is, as He Himself says, 'because their deeds are evil'... Thus if any are to be in any sense a light of the world, there is but one way of it — by reflecting Him."
Kelly puts the same guard in his own words:
"Benevolent works are no test, and are not what Christ looked for and here expresses. He spoke of works excellent in the sense of what suits the Father and the Son, and of which the Holy Spirit is the sole power in us. It is not His mind to let our good works shine before men, but our light, or confession of Himself in word and deed."
And he follows with a striking warning:
"Nor can anything other or short of this secure the end He proposes. For I might dole out all my goods in what men call charity, or deliver up my body to be burned without confessing Christ, and therefore without in any way glorifying the Father. There is neither light nor love without the faith and the confession of Christ; and self might thereby be honoured, but not the Father."
J. T. McBroom places the saying in its context among the beatitudes, and shows how this shining follows directly upon a willingness to suffer for Christ:
J. T. McBroom"Verses 10-16 show the submission of heart which accompanies the foregoing. Suffering whether for the kingdom or the King was to be esteemed a favour, and it would have its bearing both on the present and the future... They were the salt of the earth and the light of the world. Notwithstanding the persecution and hatred of men they were to be a force for good, able to meet and counteract in divine power the corruption that is in the world through lust, and shed a beneficent influence on all around them."
The shining and the suffering belong together: those who take their place with a rejected Christ become His luminaries in the very scene that rejected Him.
Matthew 5:14 presses two things together that ought never to be separated. First, the disciple's place is necessarily visible — a city on a hill, a lamp on its stand. Concealment is a contradiction of calling. Second, the light itself is Christ confessed, not philanthropy, not reputation, not mere moral decency. The good works that men glorify the Father for are the works that the light shines upon — works that could not be accounted for apart from the open confession of Christ. The warning, then, is twofold: do not hide, and do not substitute. Do not hide, for the whole purpose of a lamp is to shine to all in the house; and do not substitute something lesser — even burning charity — for the one thing that makes the light a light at all, which is the presence of Christ owned in word and life before men.
Nor do [men] light a lamp and put it under the bushel, but upon the lamp-stand, and it shines for all who are in the house.
Now I have enough material. Let me write the answer.
Matthew 5:15 reads: "Neither do men light a candle, and put it under a bushel, but on a candlestick; and it giveth light unto all that are in the house." It is the middle verse in a trio (vv. 14–16) where the Lord declares His disciples "the light of the world" and presses home that this light is meant to shine outward, not to be covered over.
The Lord has just called His disciples the salt of the earth, and now speaks of them as the light of the world. The two figures are not synonyms. William Kelly draws the distinction sharply:
"The salt of the earth represents the righteous principle… But now, in verse 14, we have not only the principle of righteousness, but of grace — the outflowing and strength of grace. And here we find a new title given to the disciples, as descriptive of their public testimony — 'the light of the world.' The light is clearly that which diffuses itself. The salt is what ought to be inward, but the light is that which scatters itself abroad."
That is the key to verse 15. Light, by its very nature, goes out. To hide it under a corn-measure is to contradict the reason it was kindled. Kelly continues:
"'A city that is set on a hill cannot be hid.' There was to be a diffusion of its testimony around. Man does not light a candle to put it under a corn measure, but on a candlestick, 'and it giveth light unto all that are in the house.' After this manner let your light shine before men, 'that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.' Mark it well."
J. N. Darby puts the same thought in his synopsis with characteristic brevity:
J. N. Darby"The disciples of Christ were the preservative principle in the earth. They were the light of the world, which did not possess that light. This was their position, whether they would or no. It was the purpose of God that they should be the light of the world. A candle is not lighted in order to be hidden."
The phrase "whether they would or no" is weighty. The disciple does not choose whether to be a light; the Lord has made him one. The only question is whether the light will be set where it can do its work, or smothered under the bushel.
The bushel is any covering — timidity, worldly prudence, the fear of man, the pursuit of comfort — that would hide the testimony the Lord has kindled. J. T. McBroom ties this back to the beatitudes that precede it:
J. T. McBroom"Suffering whether for the kingdom or the King was to be esteemed a favour, and it would have its bearing both on the present and the future… They were the salt of the earth and the light of the world. Notwithstanding the persecution and hatred of men they were to be a force for good, able to meet and counteract in divine power the corruption that is in the world through lust, and shed a beneficent influence on all around them."
Persecution, in other words, is precisely the pressure that tempts the candle under the bushel — and the Lord forestalls it by reminding His disciples that a hidden light is a contradiction in terms.
A common misreading turns verse 15 into a summons to display our own good deeds. Kelly warns against this firmly — the object is not our works but the shining of Christ through us, out of which good works will follow:
"When people talk about this verse thinking of their own works, they are generally not good works at all; but even if they were, works are not light. Light is that which comes from God, without admixture of man. Good works are the fruit of its action upon the soul; but it is the light which is to shine before men. It is the confession of Christ that is the point before God. It is not merely certain things to be done."
And further:
"The moment you make good works the object, and their shining before men, you find yourself on common ground with Jews and heathen… What so bad, in the way of a thing done professedly for God, as a work that leaves out Christ, and that shows a man who loves Christ to be on comfortable terms with those that hate Him?… Let your confession of what God is in His nature and of what Christ is in His own person and ways — let your acknowledgment of Him be the thing that is felt by and brought before men; and then, when they see your good works, they will glorify your Father which is in heaven. Instead of saying, What a good man such a one is, they will glorify God on his behalf."
Matthew 5:15, then, is no mere proverb about visibility. It is the Lord's insistence that the testimony He kindles in His own must not be smothered. The disciple is a light by the Lord's own appointment, not by his own choosing, and the light he bears is not his character or his charities but the shining of Christ Himself. To put that light under a bushel — whether through the fear of man, the love of ease, or the wish to be on easy terms with a world that hates the Master — is to frustrate the very reason the candle was lit. Set it on the candlestick, and it will do what light does: illuminate the whole house, and bring men not to admire the disciple but to glorify the Father which is in heaven.
Let your light thus shine before men, so that they may see your upright works, and glorify your Father who is in the heavens.
After the Beatitudes, the Lord Jesus turns from describing the character of His disciples to declaring their public effect — salt and light in a corrupt and dark world. Verse 16 closes that section with a positive command that reveals two questions: what is the "light" that is to shine, and whose glory does it serve?
Commentary draws a careful line between the light itself and the works that accompany it. The light is testimony to Christ; the works prove that testimony is real.
Leslie M. GrantIn verse 16 the light is distinct from good works, but both are closely connected. The light speaks of moral and spiritual testimony to Christ. The good works are works that back up this testimony as being real. Apparent good works by themselves would draw attention to the person who does them, that he might be honored; but if the light of testimony for Christ accompanies the good works, this influences others to recognize that God our Father is the source of the works and therefore to glorify Him in heaven, the place of highest authority.
The disciple has nothing of his own to display. What is to shine is the reflection of the One who alone is the Light of the world.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinBut what light is it which is to shine? Surely this can mean only the reflection of Him who is the Light. "He does not say let your good works shine, but let your light shine; that is, let Christ shine in your life; not that ye may see your good works, but that men see them; not to your glory, but to the glory of your Father."
This is also why the lamp must not be hidden by man's activity:
Leslie M. GrantA lamp too is not to be put under a bushel measure, that is, obscured by that which speaks of man's work. Let us not allow our work to get in the way of the light of Christ, who is the only source of light for darkened men.
The two figures of verses 13–16 work together but are not the same. Salt holds back corruption; light pushes back darkness.
W. T. P. Wolston"Ye are the salt of the earth." Now salt is preservative, it preserves from corruption... Salt answers to righteousness. But "Ye are the light of the world," gives another thought. Light answers to grace. Salt merely preserves things pure from corruption, but light is aggressive, it drives out the darkness. So grace goes forth outside and seeks. "It gives light."
The works are seen, but the eye of those who see is to be lifted past the doer to the Father in heaven. The whole Sermon on the Mount focuses on what the disciple is to be before the world, not on the conversion of the world itself.
MagazinesThe Lord Jesus does not speak in these verses of the preaching of the gospel for the salvation of the lost. The entire "sermon on the mount" does not deal with this, but with the Christ-like walk of the disciples of the Lord... it is not the purpose of the "sermon on the mount" that they may receive blessing or be led to the Lord, but that the character of the Kingdom of God may be expressed in His disciples.
The works flow out of the light, not the other way round:
MagazinesHere, the good works are the fruit of the working of divine light in the soul. If we let our light shine, good works will also be connected with it. But they are not the focus of our attention here... Therefore He does not exhort us here to do good works, but to let our light shine. We should not think of "our" works, but of Him. Good works will then be the result. The apostle Paul speaks of the fruit of the light which is in all goodness, righteousness and truth (Eph. 5:9).
This shining is not abstract; it is daily conduct.
MagazinesAre we friendly, helpful, peaceable and righteous in our dealings with colleagues, neighbours and other people? In this way we can let our light shine before men. "Do all things without murmurings and reasonings, that ye may be harmless and simple, irreproachable children of God in the midst of a crooked and perverted generation; among whom ye appear as lights (heavenly lights) in the world, holding forth the word of life" (Phil. 2:14-15 J.N.D. Trans.). To let our light shine means that as well as our spoken testimony for our Lord in the world, our new nature and our position as children of God are expressed by our behaviour.
- Light first. The Lord does not say "let your good works shine" but "let your light shine"; works are the fruit, not the focus.
- Christ reflected. The light is testimony to Christ — His own life shining through the believer, since He alone is the Light of the world.
- Works confirm. Good works back up the testimony as real, so that men cannot dismiss the light as words only.
- Father's glory. The whole point is to lift the onlooker past us to the Father in heaven; if attention stops at us, the lamp is hidden under a bushel.
- Daily walk. Shining is practical — friendly, peaceable, irreproachable conduct as children of God in a crooked generation (Phil. 2:14-15).