those who bow down on the roofs to the host of the heavens, those who bow down and swear to the LORD and yet swear by Milcom,
Zephaniah preached while King Josiah was tearing down the altars of Judah. Yet his message is not praise. It is a list of people God means to cut off, and they are not open pagans. They are people who bow to God and then bow to something else.
Who Malcham Was
The name in the second half of the verse belongs to an idol. The people who swore by it were not outsiders to Israel's faith.
Morrish Bible DictionaryAn idol worshipped by some Jews who also professed to worship Jehovah. Zeph. 1:5. Some judge it to have been the same as Molech.
Commentators differ on which idol is meant:
Morrish Bible DictionaryGod could still see the followers of Baal there. He could see the Chemarim, the idol priests named in 2 Kings 23:5 and Hosea 10:5, margin. He could see those who worshipped the host of heaven, and those who swore by Jehovah and by Malcham, or "their king," that is, Baal.
(The ESV renders the name "Milcom.")
Worship on the Roofs
The first group in the verse climbed to the flat roofs of their houses to bow to the stars. One writer ties this to a habit still alive today.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinVerses 5 and 6 name other forms of idolatry. They worshipped the host of the heavens from their housetops. They worshipped the stars and studied their movements, as if the stars could help them and give them a revelation. Astrology, still practised so widely among civilized nations today, is an ancient cult (2 Kings 21:3, 5; Jer. 8:2; 19:13). Others used the Holy Name of Jehovah and at the same time used the name of Malcham. It was all a turning back from Jehovah and a dishonouring of His Name.
Why the Mixture Is Worse
The sin named here is not abandoning God. It is keeping Him and adding to Him. One commentator argues that this is the sharper offence of the two:
William KellyWhat made this idolatry so offensive was that they joined the idols of the nations to Jehovah. To be a plain, outright idolater was not nearly as evil as to show that you know the true God and yet put false gods on a level with Him. It is exactly this outrage against God that the verse describes here.
The same writer shows how small such a compromise looks to the people who allow it:
William KellyThere may be no deliberate plan to abandon His worship. It may only be what they count a small thing: occasional conformity to idolatry while they still profess His name. But God refuses any such unholy compromise. He refuses it quite apart from the danger, for those who allow it, of full revolt from Him. It strikes at His majesty, at holiness and truth, and He will not tolerate it.
Judgment in the Middle of a Revival
Josiah was a godly king, and his clean-up of the land was real. It still did not save the nation.
William KellyJosiah was a deeply godly man. He was strict and zealous against whatever dishonoured the name of Jehovah, and above all he bowed his own heart to the word of God. None of this set the nation right. No doubt there were then, as always, bright hopes among the best people of the land. So it mattered greatly that God should make His mind on the matter known. Then no one, even if fooled for a moment, would be bitterly disappointed in the end.
What God was looking for, He did not find:
The Bible TreasuryBut why could God not be satisfied with the outward improvement in Judah in Josiah's day? He looked beneath the surface. He looked for something real, for a tender conscience, for hearts bowed to His word. He did not find them.
The Same Divided Heart Today
The same divided heart is alive now. One writer names its modern form:
J Wilson SmithFor most professing Christians today it is the Lord and some form of the world, some addition to Himself. It is the mixed worship of the Samaritans, who served the Lord and their own gods at the same time (2 Kings 17:33). It is a sad admission that the Lord is not enough to satisfy, and a love of pleasure more than a love of God.
Summary
- Named: Malcham was an idol served by people who also claimed to serve God — read by some as Molech, by others as "their king."
- Mixed: They did not drop God. They kept Him and added other gods on top — stars on the roof, oaths sworn to both.
- Worse: To know the true God and still set false gods beside Him is a greater outrage than plain, open idolatry.
- Rejected: God refuses such "occasional conformity" outright. He looked beneath Josiah's reform for a real, tender heart, and did not find it.
- Repeated: The same divided heart lives on as "the Lord and some form of the world" — an admission that the Lord alone is not enough.