Accordingly, though I am bold enough in Christ to command you to do what is required,
Philemon 1:8 · ESVView all translations

Paul is writing to a slave-owner about a runaway slave. Here he comes to his appeal, and first he pauses to say what he could have done instead.

"Wherefore" — the request rests on what came before

The verse opens by looking back. The greeting and thanksgiving of verses 1–7 were not warm-up material but the foundation of the plea.

The first word "wherefore" links this section of the letter with the previous seven verses. They were not preliminary small talk before getting down to business. The plea Paul would make was based on what had gone before in the letter. Both Paul and Philemon enjoyed the vital link "in Christ." Paul now moves carefully toward the main point of his letter. His method could well be imitated. We need to be careful in approaching one another.

Truth & Testimony

Paul had the right to command

The word translated "enjoin" is a real command, and Paul had the standing to give one. He names that standing only to move past it.

It was in this spirit the apostle wrote, "Accordingly, though I am bold enough in Christ to command you to do what is required, yet for love's sake I rather entreat." To command what is right is not wrong in someone with the proper authority. But grace respects law in its own sphere, while acting far above law in a sphere of its own. In that sphere Christ is the centre and the fullness — the object, the pattern, and the motive. So the apostle puts love forward, whatever the rights of his position, and this even "in Christ." He only begs a man who, like himself, knew his incalculable debt to the love of God in Christ our Lord.

William Kelly

What stands out in the choice is the absence of self-importance in a man who could have pulled rank.

The first thing that strikes us in Paul is his unwillingness to use the authority that was rightly his. He had the liberty in Christ to command. But he preferred to appeal in grace to the one who had suffered wrong. This is very beautiful. Paul shows none of the presumption of "Man, proud man, dressed in a little brief authority." He is truly humble and unpretentious.

The Christian's Friend

Boldness "in Christ," not boldness for himself

The confidence Paul describes is not personal nerve. It rests on whose interests he is representing.

In verse 8 Paul writes of being "bold in Christ" to enjoin what was fitting in relation to Onesimus. Onesimus was Philemon's slave, and he had run away from his master. But the apostle led him to Christ in Rome. What Paul was about to ask for, he asked with Christian boldness. He was asking for Christ's sake, not for any personal favour for himself. How good it is when we ask for Christ's sake! We may ask the Father, the source of all, or any of His own whom He has enriched.

An Outline of Sound Words

A command would have worked — and cost too much

An order would have produced the outward result. Commentators note that this was exactly the problem.

He would not stand on the position the Lord had given him in the church... Suppose he had sent back Onesimus with an apostolic order. No doubt it would have been obeyed, and the runaway pardoned and reinstated. But would this have satisfied his heart? Where then is the precious display of the grace of Christ? That grace rises above everything, even the deepest evil. It not only forgives but welcomes the wrongdoer to its heart for ever... He would not command, but begged; he names his authority, only to set it aside in a case like this.

W. W. Fereday

Grace cannot be ordered into existence

Paul keeps his apostleship but stands with Philemon on shared ground instead. That leaves the door open for something a command could never produce.

Paul therefore could not give up his apostleship. But he was free to act in grace, and to take his stand on what he had in common with Philemon and the whole church — brotherhood in Christ Jesus. And here, instead of an authoritative command, he could "beg."... It is important to notice how our gracious Lord keeps giving us chances to show grace. He rarely speaks to us in the tone of authoritative command, saying, "Go," "Do this." Instead it is, "here is My mind" — go and carry it out as far as you can.

The Bible Treasury

Kelly puts the principle plainly:

You can never demand or claim grace. In writing the letter to Philemon, the apostle brings motives of grace to bear on the case. He does not dictate what Philemon was to do. He reminds him of his heavenly relationship, and leaves it to Philemon's grace.

William Kelly

A pattern worth copying

The way Paul opens the subject is itself instruction.

Notice too the tactful and delicate way in which he introduces the subject of Onesimus, in verses 8 to 10; begging where he might have used apostolic authority and commanded; presenting Onesimus as his spiritual son, given to him during the time of his trial in his captivity — a consideration well calculated to move the heart of Philemon.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- Accordingly — the appeal grows out of verses 1–7. Paul builds on what he and Philemon already share "in Christ."

- Right — Paul really could command. Commanding what is right is not wrong for someone with proper authority.

- Rather — he names that authority only to set it aside. An order would have won the act but missed the display of Christ's grace.

- Grace — you can never demand or claim grace. Paul brings motives to bear and leaves the decision to Philemon.

- Pattern — the Lord deals with us the same way, showing His mind instead of giving orders. Paul's care with people is worth copying.

Reviewed by Orion on September 10, 2026