I appeal to you for my child, Onesimus, whose father I became in my imprisonment.
Paul writes from prison for a runaway slave who had wronged his owner. He does not open with the man's crime. He opens with a family word: this man is his child, and Philemon must now decide what to do with him.
The runaway God intercepted
Onesimus had done real damage before he disappeared, and no one in the ancient world would have expected mercy for him.
William KellyHe had deserted his excellent master, and had probably cheated him as well (verse 18). Even the worst master would have punished such an act with the greatest severity. We may be sure Onesimus had no good reason for leaving Philemon. He proved himself a worthless man who could not value goodness. But what is too hard for the Lord? He led him into Paul's path, converted him, and turned his heart and his steps back to his master.
What "whose father I became" means
Older translations read "whom I have begotten in my bonds." That is birth language. It describes what happens to a person who believes the gospel.
Morrish Bible DictionaryPaul wrote to the Corinthians, "I became your father in Christ Jesus through the gospel" (1 Cor. 4:15). Of Onesimus he says, "whose father I became in my imprisonment" (Philemon 10). This means he had been the means of their conversion, for the Christian is born of God (1 John 5:18; 1 Peter 1:3).
So Paul can speak as if the new birth were his own work. The credit belongs elsewhere.
H. H. SnellIn one place Scripture says that God "bore witness to the word of His grace." In another, an apostle speaks by the same Spirit of a man whose father he had become while in chains, as if he himself had brought about the man's conversion. This shows how gracious God is. He owns the part we play, and He makes much of our little service and faithfulness. Yet we can truly add, "Not to us, O Lord, not to us, but to Your name give glory."
Why the chains are named
Paul also says where this birth happened. That detail is aimed straight at Philemon's affections.
William KellySo he writes, "I, Paul, an old man and now a prisoner also for Christ Jesus, appeal to you for my child, Onesimus, whose father I became" — and not only that, but "in my imprisonment." That would make Onesimus a special object of interest and affection to a man who honoured and delighted in the apostle. If Philemon loved Paul, he would love Paul's child; and Onesimus was his child. Paul calls him his child as emphatically as he ever called Titus or Timothy. But he was a son born as neither Timothy nor Titus was — born while Paul was in chains.
An appeal, not an order
Paul had the right to command. He chose to plead instead, and God Himself deals with people that way.
The Bible TreasuryWhat has God done! We may well say this when we see the Lord God Almighty, the High and Holy One, presenting Himself to us in such a way that He pleads with us. "We are ambassadors for Christ, God making His appeal through us." … This is the grace Paul would bear witness to. He could have commanded, and yet for love's sake he chose to plead. He pleaded for his son Onesimus, whose father he had become while in chains. Had Philemon listened to the ministry of reconciliation, and received the Son of God into his soul? Then let him, as one reconciled to God Himself, exercise that same grace towards Onesimus.
A new relationship
The slave is coming home. But he is no longer just property, and Paul expects Philemon to feel the difference.
J. N. DarbyThe return of his runaway slave was likely to stir up something in Philemon's natural heart. So the apostle steps in with his letter on behalf of his dear child in the faith, born during his captivity. God had already stepped in with the work of His grace. That grace ought to act on Philemon's heart, producing altogether new relationships with Onesimus. The apostle begs him to receive his former slave as a brother.
Christ's heart in Paul's words
The feelings in this appeal are Paul's own. They also show something beyond him.
The Christian's FriendThis is not only a beautiful picture of spiritual affections — of the unbreakable ties between Christians, and especially between a servant of God and the converts given to his ministry. It is also a striking picture of the heart of Christ for His own. Yes, these are Paul's feelings, Paul's tender love, Paul's pleading; but in all of them he was only the vessel of Christ.
Summary
- Fled — Onesimus ran from his master and probably robbed him first. No one expected mercy for such a man. But nothing was too hard for the Lord, who steered him into Paul's path.
- Fathered — "Whose father I became" is birth language. Paul was the means of the conversion. God gives the new birth, and He still credits His servant with the work.
- Fettered — Paul names where that birth happened: his chains. A son born in Paul's prison had a claim on anyone who loved Paul.
- Favour — Paul could have commanded. He chose to plead, as God pleads with people through His messengers. A man who has received such grace should now pass it on.
- Family — Grace made new relationships. The runaway comes back not as property but as a brother. The tenderness of the appeal is the heart of Christ working through His servant.