And he that swears by heaven swears by the throne of God and by him that sits upon it.
Jesus is taking apart a whole system of oath-taking. It let people sound solemn while leaving them free to break their word. His last stroke removes the safest-looking dodge of all: naming heaven instead of God.
The Dodge Being Dismantled
The teachers of the day had built a sliding scale of oaths, and the scale had one purpose — to leave a way out. One writer describes how the vocabulary worked:
The Jews loved to swear on every possible occasion to stress their words. They used all kinds of impressive phrases for this. They swore by heaven, by the earth, by Jerusalem, by the temple, and so on. Clearly the scribes thought that only oaths naming God directly were "real" oaths. Only those bound the person who swore them. They also drew further distinctions between the temple and the gold of the temple, and between the altar and the gift on the altar (Matt. 23:16-22). The Jews barely treated it as sin to swear thoughtless oaths, vows and promises and then not keep them, as long as no one mentioned God's name.
Heaven Is Occupied
The word "heaven" sounds impersonal and safe. The Lord answers that heaven is a throne, and the throne has an occupant.
If one were to swear by the temple, he was actually swearing by the living God who dwelt in the temple. Men think little of swearing by heaven too, and many use the word "heavens" as an exclamation. But heaven is God's throne, so such swearing means swearing by Him who sits upon the throne. All of these things show too little regard for the supreme honour that God is due.
Responsibility Cannot Be Shed
The fine distinctions were not harmless scholarship. They were a working method for escaping what you had promised — and the Lord cancels the escape without exception.
The third woe again shows how the light in them turned to darkness: they turned true proportion upside down when it came to holy things. They valued the gold of the temple above the temple itself, and the gift above the altar that made it holy. And then they used this hair-splitting to teach men how they could swear empty oaths and escape responsibility — a responsibility which the Lord affirms in every case.
What Drove the Distinctions
Two things sat underneath the system: money, and the look of deep thinking.
They have an evil purpose in making these distinctions. And we see how the Lord openly exposes them. Greed was at the bottom of it, the desire to make money.
The reputation mattered too. One writer says the blindness behind these rulings is still with us:
In verses 16-22, the Lord condemns their fanciful teachings. They draw distinctions between the temple and the gold of the temple, and between the altar and the gift upon it. Thoughtless people might look at them with awe, as men of very superior minds. In reality their distinctions were made up, and only proved their own blindness and folly... Blind they were indeed, and that type of blindness is all too common today.
Plain Speech Instead of Oaths
If no oath can be aimed away from God, the graded oath is useless. One writer traces where such swearing comes from, and what the Lord does with it:
All this strong swearing, which the Lord illustrates from Jewish habit, grew out of men's constant experience of deceiving or dodging. So they turned to such means of guaranteeing the truth. But these efforts defeated themselves... The Lord took it for granted that those He spoke to were poor in spirit and pure in heart. So He forbade all such swearing outright. It offends God, and it does not fit the place of His sons.
The same writer limits this to ordinary speech, not the courtroom. He points to the Lord's own answer at His trial:
The question here (as in James) is not in the least a judicial oath. The Lord is dealing with how His disciples behave as individuals, not with how they relate to the governing powers. It is a matter of ordinary conversation, not an oath before the magistrate. Heaven, earth, Jerusalem, and a man's own head, were ways of swearing in the everyday talk of Jews... So the Lord Himself, though silent before, answered when the high priest put Him under oath by the living God. (Matt. 26:62-64.)
Summary
- The dodge. The scribes graded oaths so that only ones naming God counted, leaving the rest safe to break.
- The throne. Naming heaven does not avoid God; heaven is His throne, and the oath lands on the One seated there.
- The reach. No oath can be aimed away from Him, so the responsibility the system tried to dodge stands in every case.
- The motive. Greed lay at the bottom, dressed up in distinctions that looked clever and were only blindness — a blindness still common.
- The remedy. People reach for guarantees because people evade. The Lord bans such swearing for hearts poor in spirit and pure — an oath before a magistrate is another matter.