Thus shall the last be first, and the first last; for many are called ones, but few chosen ones.
Peter had asked what the disciples would get for leaving everything, and the Lord answered with a story: a landowner paid the same wage to early workers and to latecomers. This closing line seals that story — but why does it flip the order of the saying in 19:30?
Two sayings, two lessons
The same words close chapter 19, but here the two halves change places. One writer draws a different lesson from each order:
William KellyThe first of these lessons is, "Many first will be last, and last first" (Matt. 19:30). It plainly shows the failure of nature, the reverse of what you would expect. The second is, "So the last will be first, and the first last; for many are called, but few are chosen." It is the power of grace. God delights to pick out the very last for the first place, and to put down those who are first in their own strength.
The bargain that spoils service
Some workers in the story settled on a wage first. The parable answers that spirit, and it follows Peter's question about what he would get:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinWhile we labor, our labor is not to be for the sake of reward, as one who is hired for a certain sum of money. We are to be laborers with no trace of legality about us. The servant or laborer who aims to earn something by his service and sacrifice lives only for himself. He would be only a hired servant, which the believer is not… The Lord wants us to trust grace. He wants us to leave the rewards, the recompense, to Him and to His will to give as it pleases Him, and to think nothing of our service. So the parable appears as a rebuke to Peter, who was occupied with what he had given up.
God's right to do good
The word "so" ties this line back to the parable. What is on display is not pay scales but God's freedom:
William KellyHere we find, not the principle of rewards, or righteous recognition of the service done by His people, but God's own rights, His own sovereignty… God will certainly acknowledge every service and every loss for the sake of Christ. Yet He still keeps His own title to do as He will. Some poor soul may come to know Christ on the day of his death. God claims His own title to give what He pleases, to give to those who have not worked at all — as we may think — just what is good in His own eyes.
Who turns out to be last
The two groups in the story chose their own ground, and each got what that ground could give:
Leslie M. GrantThe last are those who do not bargain for their own rights. In genuine faith they depend on the grace of God, and God will see to it that they become first. The first are those who put themselves first, using the legal principle of demanding justice. So they receive justice: they are made last.
Many called, few chosen
The ESV does not carry the closing line here; it keeps "For many are called, but few are chosen" at Matthew 22:14. Older translations include it in this verse. Commentators differ over what it means. Some link it to the wide reach of the gospel call, and to what God's grace produces inside it:
J. A. TrenchCompared with Matthew 22:14, the same general principle holds in both cases: a contrast between the outward result and what makes it real. The Gospel call goes out to "as many as you find," and the outward result is that "the wedding hall was filled with guests." But verses 11-13 there prove that being present, and blessed in reality, is not of man's will but of God's calling in grace. The principle is the same in 20:16 — only there it is a question of labour and reward that introduces it.
Others keep the clause inside the parable's own subject — service and reward, not salvation:
Arno Clemens Gaebelein"The first will be last" — so the parable began, and it shows the human failure. At the end the order turns around: the last will be first. The Lord, in His sovereign grace, will lift up those who trusted in His grace. "Many are called, but few are chosen" — this has nothing to do with salvation. It is connected with rewards.
The reversal on a larger scale
The principle also shows up in how God has dealt with whole peoples, not only with individual workers:
A. J. PollockThis shows the Lord's saying, "So the last will be first, and the first last" (Matt. 20:16). The Jews were called first in time, but they will be last in coming into their promised earthly blessing. The Christian, called last, will be first in coming into heavenly blessing.
Summary
- Bargain — Agreeing on terms with God reduces you to a hired hand; the wage you fixed is the wage you get.
- Trust — The later workers named no price. They leaned on the owner's goodness, and that is the true spring of service.
- Sovereignty — God never overlooks real service. Yet He keeps His right to give what He pleases, even to someone who comes to Christ on the last day of life.
- Reversal — Demand justice and you are put last; depend on grace and God Himself sees to it that you come first.
- Reality — The call goes out to many. But the crowd of workers is not what counts; God's grace is what makes anyone real among them.