For affliction does not come from the dust, nor does trouble sprout from the ground,
Eliphaz has just described the sudden ruin of foolish men, and Job's losses look like his list. Now he states a principle: hardship does not sprout up on its own like a weed.
The claim in its setting
The saying is true; the use Eliphaz makes of it is not. One writer traces his logic, then separates the principle from the accusation:
Leslie M. GrantEliphaz did not say so, but he implied that Job might be dangerously close to such a charge. He had watched foolish people suffer. So he reasoned that since Job was suffering like this, something must be badly wrong in Job. Job's harvest — everything he had gained — was eaten up (v.5). Why? Because, he says, affliction does not come from the dust, nor does trouble sprout from the ground (v.6). In other words, trouble does not happen by chance. This is true, for there is no doubt that God is behind it.
Nothing rises by accident
If sorrow does not grow out of the soil, someone sends it. The opening chapters of Job show who acted first, and it was not Satan:
J. N. DarbyJob 5:6 says that affliction "does not come from the dust." Whatever the instruments may be, those who live in this world do not direct its course. Nor does even the enemy of our souls, in the first place. It was God who said to Satan, "Have you considered my servant Job?" God saw that Job needed the sifting. The enemy himself was only an instrument in it.
Looking past the visible agents
Job's losses came through raiders, fire and wind. Faith traced them further back:
F. B. HoleThe agents of his sorrows were plain for all to see — the Sabeans, the Chaldeans, the fire, the whirlwind. But behind these lay the evil power of Satan, thrusting hard at him. And behind even this lay the chastening hand of God. Job's faith and patience showed in this: he did not look at the third cause, or even at the second. He looked straight through to God, and accepted everything as from His hand. It is just the same for us today. If we look at second or third causes when trouble sweeps in, it leaves us confused and often angry. If we bow beneath the hand of God we are greatly blessed.
Where Eliphaz goes wrong
He takes a true premise — trouble is sent — and adds a false one: that the amount of trouble measures the guilt. Tested against other lives in Scripture, the rule collapses:
Samuel RidoutSuppose Abraham, Jacob, or David had reasoned this way about their sufferings: then they were wicked, because they suffered! And in the New Testament, how could suffering that produces patience be something to glory in? How could "this light momentary affliction" prepare for us "an eternal weight of glory beyond all comparison"? Eliphaz's own experience shows how little he knows of God's ways with His suffering people.
Good advice, wrong assumption
Eliphaz follows his principle with advice, and the advice is good in itself. What spoils it is the assumption hidden underneath:
Samuel RidoutIt is always good to advise people to trust in God, for He never fails those who trust in Him... So, taken on its own, this counsel is good. But remember the assumption underneath it — that Job is suffering for his sins — and it can only irritate. It is as if he said: "Sin belongs to everyone, as trouble does to everyone, so humble yourself as a sinner before God, and He will lift you up." It is all the more subtle because it comes so close to the truth.
The verse used rightly
Freed from Eliphaz's misuse, the verse steadies anyone under trial. It ties God's control to His care:
William KellySo the trial throws us back on Him. Without Him not a sparrow falls to the ground, and by Him the very hairs of our head are all numbered. Affliction does not come from the dust, nor does trouble sprout from the ground. All of it is under the hand of the One who has made us His for glory. Meanwhile He puts our faith to the test in this present evil age, training us not only in patience but in endurance.
Summary
- Not from dust. Trouble never grows by itself out of the ground; it is sent, and behind every instrument stands God.
- Not from Satan first. In Job's story God raised the subject and set the limits; the enemy acted only as an instrument.
- Not from second causes. Raiders, fire and wind were visible; faith looked past them, took everything from God's hand, and was blessed in bowing to it.
- Not proof of guilt. Eliphaz turned a true principle into a false measure — a rule that would condemn Abraham, Jacob and David.
- Not without purpose. The same hand that sends the trial numbers the hairs of our head, training us in patience and endurance.