And the LORD said to Job:
The voice out of the whirlwind pauses, and God turns from creation to speak to one man by name. Why does He pause here, and what is He asking Job to do?
A break in the questions
God's questions have run on for chapters. One writer notes the break and what fills the space around it:
F. B. HoleThe words of Jehovah fill four chapters, with a brief interlude at the opening of Job 40. He puts question after question to Job for him to consider and answer, if he could. All of them concern the mighty power that had acted in creation.
Those questions were about creation. Now the aim narrows to the man himself:
William KellyJust notice how directly He puts the question in Job 40 to Job in person. "Moreover Jehovah answered Job, and said, Shall the one who contends with the Almighty instruct Him?" He ought to be able, if he judges God. This is what fills Job with shame... Job had contended with the Almighty.
The name God gives him
The challenge that follows names Job by what he has been doing:
William KellyAnd Jehovah answered Job, and said, Is the censurer to correct with the Almighty? The reprover of God, let him answer it.
The same writer sets that challenge against who God is:
William KellyIt is Jehovah-God then, who alone orders and alone knows. His kind wisdom takes in every creature, including those clearly outside all the care or even the knowledge of man. Is he then to contend with God, or, if he is so presumptuous, can he pretend to instruct God?
What was actually wrong with Job
Job's friends had accused him of hidden crimes. God's charge is different, and one writer locates it precisely:
Samuel RidoutHere lies the root of Job's trouble: he had sat in judgment on God — he had accused the Almighty of evil.
God takes Job at his word
Job had asked for exactly this hearing. He wanted God to answer so he could lay out his case. Now the request is granted, and the effect is not what he expected:
Leslie M. GrantJob had said that if God would only listen to him, he would present his whole case showing how God was unfair in His dealings. So now God gives Job the opportunity to do this. He asks Job, "Shall the one who contends with the Almighty correct Him?" Where were Job's arguments then? How crushing God's words were to the misplaced pride of Job!
Why the whirlwind and not a gentle voice
One writer ties the storm to what Job still needed to learn:
J. G. BellettIt was not the lesson of a sinner that Job had to learn. He already knew the grace of God. It was the lesson of a saint he needed to be taught, or taught more fully. That is why the Lord seats Himself in the whirlwind. Suppose Job had needed to learn the lesson of a sinner for the first time. Then the Lord would rather have spoken to him in "the still small voice," the tone that suits grace... But Job was already a saved sinner. He knew the grace, but had still to be taught the rights, of God.
The answer God was waiting for
Job does reply. One writer weighs what that answer admits:
Leslie M. GrantHe says, "Behold, I am vile; what shall I answer You? I lay my hand over my mouth..." Job goes deeper here than apologising for what he has said. He expresses his judgment of himself as a person... Then he judges also what he had spoken more than once, and says he lays his hand over his mouth. This is just what Romans 3:19 says of all mankind: "that every mouth may be stopped, and the whole world may be held accountable to God."
Yet Job's confession is not the end of the story:
Samuel RidoutHere the test of Job is all but over. Yet in faithfulness Jehovah will probe still further, into the deepest corners of his heart, to lay bare its potential evil. So we must listen further to what the Lord has to speak.
Summary
- The pause — The questions about creation break off. God turns to speak to Job in person.
- The charge — Job had sat in judgment on God and accused Him of wrong.
- The invitation — Job had demanded a hearing. God grants it, and asks His critic to answer.
- The purpose — Job already knew God's grace. Now he had to learn God's rights, so the voice came out of a storm.
- The result — A hand over the mouth. That is the answer God waited for, and the posture every mouth takes before Him at last.