As I have seen, those who plow iniquity and sow trouble reap the same.
Job 4:8 · ESVView all translations

Eliphaz, the first of Job's friends to speak, ends his opening argument with a picture from farming: the harvest tells you what was planted. The question is whether that saying, true as it sounds, explains why Job lost everything.

The Picture in the Words

The word for "plow" carries more than farming. It is also used as a picture of plotting evil.

The word literally means to break up the ground for planting. It is also used as a picture of "plotting" wickedness. Job 4:8; Hosea 10:13. Israel, looking back on the trials they went through, says, "The plowers plowed upon my back; they made long their furrows." Psalm 129:3. This surely points to what the blessed Lord suffered on earth, above all the scourging.

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Eliphaz's Authority: What He Had Seen

Eliphaz builds his case on one phrase: "As I have seen." His own experience is his whole authority.

These sentences make it clear that Eliphaz was one of those people who argue very much from their own experience. His motto was, "As I have seen." Now, what we have seen may be true enough for us. But it is a total mistake to build a general rule on one person's experience, and thousands still fall into it. What, for instance, had the experience of Eliphaz to do with Job? Perhaps he had never met a case exactly like it. And if there is a single point of difference between the two cases, then the whole argument from experience counts for nothing.

C. H. Mackintosh

Right Statement, Wrong Address

The saying itself is sound. The error is the man Eliphaz pins it on.

In this speech Eliphaz takes trouble to show Job that everyone on the earth reaps what he sows. "As I have seen, those who plow iniquity and sow trouble reap the same" (Job 4:8). All he says is true in principle, but in Job's case it is false. It is right in itself and wrong in its application. Often the wicked grow old in sin, while the good are cut off in the strength of their youth. The ungodly often live in plenty while those who fear God have to do without the common necessities of life.

H. L. Rossier

The Rule Broken Early

Eliphaz had already asked who ever perished being innocent. The very first death recorded after sin entered the world answers him.

But in his next paragraph (verses 7-11) Eliphaz completely misunderstands the situation. He asks, "Who that was innocent ever perished?" ... What about Abel? He perished being innocent. Why, the first disaster recorded after sin entered the world disproved the position Eliphaz took up. The righteous Abel was cut off. So the idea, which he worked out with his picture of the lions, breaks down. Reaping disaster does not always mean that those who reap "plow iniquity and sow trouble."

F. B. Hole

Where the Method Leads

The mistake is not only in the logic. It shapes how Eliphaz treats his friend.

This harshness shows a wrong principle in Eliphaz, and it comes out more plainly as he goes on. For him sin and suffering are root and fruit. He knows no classes of suffering. He does not tell the righteous apart from the wicked. So in the end he turns out to be a false accuser of his friend.

Samuel Ridout

The Charge Beneath the Words

The words never name Job. One writer sees Satan himself behind the thrust.

Quick as thought, Satan gives the thrust he gave to Job: "As I have seen, those who plow iniquity and sow trouble reap the same." "By the breath of God they perish." This is the thin end of Satan's great wedge. It is the first hint that Job is a hypocrite. We shall find this wedge driven, blow after blow, as we go on in the book.

C Stanley

Sowing and Reaping Held Rightly

The law of sowing and reaping is still true. Forgiveness does not cancel it, and it does not cancel forgiveness.

"Whatever one sows, that will he also reap." The sin of sowing weeds may be forgiven, but the reaping must match the sowing. The first is grace, the second is government. Each acts in its own sphere, and neither interferes with the other... God let David walk the courts of the sanctuary as a subject of grace (2 Samuel 12:20). Only later did David climb the rough slopes of the Mount of Olives as a subject of government (2 Samuel 15:30). We may safely say this: David's heart never felt divine grace more deeply than at the very time he was feeling the righteous action of divine government.

C. H. Mackintosh

Summary

- Plowing — The word for tilling soil also pictures plotting evil. Wrong deeds start as plans.

- Seeing — Eliphaz argues from what he has watched happen. One case unlike his own, and the argument counts for nothing.

- Sowing — The saying is true in principle but false about Job. The wicked often grow old in plenty while those who fear God go without.

- Accusing — Treat suffering and sin as root and fruit, and you stop comforting your friend and start accusing him.

- Reaping — The harvest is real, but it is God's government, not our verdict on a friend. Forgiven sin still has a harvest, and grace is felt most deeply there.

Reviewed by Orion on August 28, 2026